Verified Document

Mother Pudovkin's Mother 1926 Versus Term Paper

The pictorial values, and the acting of both "Erin Brockovich" and "Good Night and Good Luck" are profoundly different than "Mother," although both show political awakenings. The more recent American films focus on extraordinary individuals, persons of physical beauty and glamour, or persons of great fame and influence, and the acting is differential, unique, and what the characters say is equally as important as what they do, unlike "Mother." It is true that Erin Brockovich is an every woman type of character to some extent because of her lower class, her status as a single mother, and her lack of education and political voice. Even Murrow is an everyman to some degree because of his status as every American in the eyes of the nation during his London broadcasts, his reputation, and his willingness to voice what many Americans thought during the McCarthy hearings but feared to say aloud.

Both film's focuses are psychological in terms of how the acting renders the main character, unlike "Mother." Although it was also based upon a past historical event, "Mother" does not try to tell the mother's internal and unique story in relation to these events, it uses one mother's image to uphold its own political values. The mother comes to realize that she must bend to the forces of history, and support revolution, rather than change history. Her actions, like holding a flag in protest, are symbolic rather than personally gratifying. The acting, rather than personalized in both American films, is general, and depicted in broad, sweeping gestures rather than subtle shifts of dialogue, or changes in hairstyle or expression to indicate the character's growing political awareness.

The overall texture of both films deploys a different kind of realism than "Mother." The silent film is in black and white, and focuses on motion, and shadows, like the motion of charging horses or the painful shadows beneath...

Many shots seem more symbolic than important to the story, like shots of the Russian soil and homeland. In "Erin Brockovich" rather than mythical shots, the film either shows what seems ordinary, like the drab interior of a law office in a county that is actually filled with invisible poisons, or the beauty of Erin's clothing and manner, which is sassy, aggressive, and uniquely 'hers.' Erin's reality looks like viewer's reality, only slightly worse, and her appearance makes her look better than the viewer's reality, and for that she seems more significant, unlike "Mother" who seems poorer, sadder, yet also more significant.
Good Night and Good Luck" tries to give a historical impression of the era in which it is set. Its black and white tones and shadows, unlike "Mother's" were deliberately chosen by the director of George Clooney to take the viewer far back in time and to gain a sense of what television looked like back then. The visual distances the viewer, but in a familiar way, to a presumably more innocent time (on the surface) where anchorman were trusted, and spoke with deep, resonating voices, and believed in the values of truth, justice, and the American way. But Murrow, because he is a real historical personage, like Erin Brockovich, cannot stand for 'all of us' and the act of locating him in a specific era of history and method of television production adds a further layer of distance.

It is possible that archetypal and purely visual images of acting like that of "Mother" can no longer be taken seriously in modern film acting. Still, the power of the film's images raises a profound question about the nature of modern filmmaking, because the film should not move the viewer, and yet it does. The film seems to take risks, artistically, even though it was anything but risky ideologically when it was made.

Works Cited

Erin Brockovich." Starring Julia Roberts. 2000.

Good Night and Good Luck." Directed by George Clooney. 2005.

Mother." Directed by Vsevolod Pudovkin. 1926.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Erin Brockovich." Starring Julia Roberts. 2000.

Good Night and Good Luck." Directed by George Clooney. 2005.

Mother." Directed by Vsevolod Pudovkin. 1926.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Mother's Day and the "Hallmark" Image of
Words: 664 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

MOTHER'S DAY AND THE "HALLMARK" IMAGE OF MOM Think about Mother's Day and the "Hallmark" image of Mom. Look at cards, ads, etc. And be specific - how does the idealized mother appear? What are the stereotypes? Expectations? Mother's Day and the "Hallmark" image of Mom Mother's Day and the "Hallmark" image of Mom This is a day celebrated worldwide to recognize maternal bands, motherhood and the contributions made by mothers in the society.

Mother Tongue and Newman Those Who Immigrate
Words: 989 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Mother Tongue and Newman Those who immigrate into the United States from other countries are encouraged to adapt to the culture of the majority population, namely white males of European descent. Language is the component of culture which is first targeted by those who try to force assimilation. When a person comes to the United States, they will feel compelled to learn English and be able to read and write in

Mother Tongue Rhetorical Techniques in Amy Tan's
Words: 916 Length: 3 Document Type: Thesis

Mother Tongue Rhetorical Techniques in Amy Tan's "Mother Tongue" As anyone who has ever been in an argument can tell you, what you say is often far less important than how you say it. Even in other less-aggressive circumstances, perception is generally far more important than substance -- this is certainly the case when it comes to politics, and often the case in more personal situations and relationships. When it comes to

Mother Come Home Analysis and
Words: 384 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

To show the childlike nature of the boy's mind, all of the characters become animals and the already simple line drawings become even simpler. Using the colors and the drawing style of the graphic novel enable the author better able to realize his ultimate purpose in creating the text, to show the mental state of family members left behind after someone dies. The fact that one of the characters is

Mother Daughter
Words: 2179 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Eva sacrifices herself because it is her choice to do so, but mostly because she genuinely loves her daughter Sula. The ambivalence in the relationship between Annette and Antoinette is painful at times, and leads to the mental illnesses that consume both mother and daughter. It is uncertain whether mental illness impeded the mother-daughter relationship from developing in Wide Sargasso Sea, or whether the thwarted relationship caused mental illness. In

Mother's Day Ideas Mother's Day
Words: 526 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

The Women's Media Center has a contest going to give women a chance to tell their stories of why they have chosen their own unique goals and paths in life. This is comparable to many of the contests that consumer packaged goods manufacturers have used very successfully in the past to get user-generated content to promote their brands. This promotion centers on pro-choice messaging for women. This is also

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now