Verified Document

Modernity And Migration Essay

Modernity and Migration Modernity in Manhattan

New York City has been the setting, backdrop, and focus of a substantive corpus of films, few of which showcase it as favorably as Manhattan. There are many subplots in the film Manhattan, and one belongs solely to the city itself. The film is an ode to New York City, irresistible even if one is not a fan of urban spaces. In the opening scenes, Woody Allen's voice-over describes New York City from five different perspectives, each of which he rejects until he captures the milieu to his satisfaction -- and to the audiences. The Manhattan that Allen introduces to the audience is exciting, beautiful, romantic, multidimensional, and set in black and white against the rhapsodic melodies of George Gershwin. The New York aesthetic is conveyed through affectionate photography that brings the audience along on a tour of the cultural centers, familiar highlights, and architectural confections- -- all picture-perfect, or course. In fact, the New-York-City-at-its-best montage is underscored by Rhapsody in Blue -- the incomparable visuals of skyline complete with lights on the bridges and fireworks in the sky are a stark contrast to Allen's trademark hyper-neurotic, loquacious, and consummately confused characterization of Issac.

If cities are the archetypal modern environment," then New York City leads the peloton (Sudnerland, 2010). Cities in films are the platform where the forces of modernity clash, ne and eclipse, creating chaos or excitement, imprisonment or liberation. Manhattan exposes the disruption of relationships as they attempt to navigate a pin-ball existence in which they bounce from conviction to uncertainty to confusion -- and back again. The only thing the characters in Manhattan can be sure of is that they will eventually pop out of the game at intervals, which allows them to take stock and catch their breath before they are flung once more into the fray. Alexander Walker of the London Evening Standard aptly wrote, "So precisely nuanced is the speech, so subtle the behaviour of a group of friends, lovers, mistresses and cuckolds who keep splitting up and pairing off like unstable molecules" (Palmer, 1980, p. 114).

The characters in the film Manhattan are the stereotypical "perpetually dissatisfied New Yorkers" the audience has come to expect -- the layer of familiarity increases...

The audience at once recognizes and likes the characters. Yet, not even one relationship in the film is static and every character, save Tracy and Yale's wife, Emily, seem wrung out by their uncertainties and relationships that seem perennially ready to slide into contentious territory. Most of the characters are in analysis or are writing books -- about each other. They have bought into that component of the lifestyle that dictates everyone must have analyst -- in so doing, they have bought into the lifestyle as a whole.
Through his solipsism, Woody Allen "successfully projected his own self-absorption as a universal condition -- and people responded with their personal identity politics" (Hoberman, 2007). The zeitgeist of the film -- lovingly expressed in Isaac's fantasies and list of all things wise and wonderful -- was not the zeitgeist of New York City just a few short years before the film was made. There was the default of 1975 and the blackout of the summer of 1977. The audience would never put the troubles of the decade together with the New York City that Allen paints.

In the movie the Purple Rose of Cairo, a 1930s movie character walks right off the silver screen and into the real world. In Manhattan, Allen creates a haunting reversal by projecting his own character into the film. It is a study of the transitory. Mary manifests a liquidized modernity that is positively dizzying (Bauman, 2000). She is warm and funny morphing to snotty and elitist. She loves Yale, she disdains Yale. Her ex-husband was louse, her ex-husband is alluring. Mary enjoys Isaac's company, but pounces whenever she can denigrate him. Mary's nomadic orientation to her life causes her to drift through an unhappy, neurotic version of her own life. If she is not tortured by the transitory nature of her relationships, she is at least "an unhappy person…trouble, as she tells Isaac. Yet, Isaac seems attracted to Mary particularly since she matches his moves, one-for-one -- they are like two pieces on a chessboard. Most of the other women in the film are in motion, also. Jill's nomadism is expressed in her evolution from bisexuality to homosexuality. Tracy is the brilliant Dalton student…

Sources used in this document:
References

Berman, M. (2007). Introduction: New York calling. In Marshall Berman and Brian Berger (Ed.), New York Calling: From Blackout to Bloomberg. London, UK: Reaktion Books.

Hoberman, J. (2000, July 3). Defending Manhattan. The Village Voice.

Palmer, Myles (1980). Woody Allen. Glenside, PA: Proteus.

Phillips, A. (1994). On Flirtation. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Modernity Might We Not Argue
Words: 1331 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

..) Are the benefits of modernity worth the costs we must pay to be modern? In my opinion, the benefits of modernity are worth some of the costs we must pay to be "modern," although not worth all of them. In today's world, the internet, for instance, arguably makes us better off than before, yet worse off as well. For example, almost everyone nowadays enjoys, at least to an extent, the

Practicing Nursing in Modernity
Words: 2582 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Nursing Concerns in Practice Synthesize knowledge from the liberal arts and sciences and nursing science to understand global perspectives, stimulate critical thinking, and use current technologies There are multiple ways that I was able to fulfill this particular course objective. Some of the more cutting edge developments in information technology are outside of the realm of nursing science, and are generally applied to liberal arts and sciences. However, while networking with colleagues

Manhattan Transience and Privilege in
Words: 1240 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Where Allen's character Isaac consorts with writers and socialites who have doormen and analysts, Mookie of Lee's film is ensconced by violence, hostility and a permeating sense of economic despair. From the perspective of those experiencing New York as a place of transience primarily for the despair and rootlessness it could instill in one, Allen's existential crises, his divorces and his writer's block could seem of superficial importance at best.

Universality of the Western Interpretation
Words: 5955 Length: 18 Document Type: Article Review

Schwartz (2006), many arguments are presented, most of which generally criticize the Western treatment of First Nations people or address women's rights issues. As an example, "Aboriginal Australia: Current Criminological Themes" by Rick Sarre (2006) focuses on the affect of British colonialism in Australia on the Aborigines, connecting it to a vast overrepresentation of Aborigines in the Australian penal system. "The Left Realist Perspective on Race, Class, and Gender"

Saudi Female Expats in Paris
Words: 4635 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Paper

It is through interviews and analysis; we will see how these individuals feel about the new cultures and regulations around them. Living in a new place, these individuals can very easily let go of the limitations they were under before. Therefore, their answers will give a sound idea of what sort of struggle they are experiencing with the new culture and how to retain their self and identity. Limitations. This study

Racism and Various Forms How Does an
Words: 2589 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Racism and Various Forms How does an understanding of racism in its various forms inform the counseling professional practice? Racism is regarded as the negative feelings exercised by one ethnic group towards other individuals belonging form a different group. The brutality and attitude towards the group is observed in the behaviors and attitudes of individuals and members of certain group causing major issues in terms of their religious, social, color, or descent.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now