Verified Document

Military Stereotyping The Negative Effects Research Proposal

This situation can be somewhat complex, as an individual is likely to be placed in a position where their own skill set will be put to efficient use, meaning that their capabilities often (and ideally always) match the position and designation they have (USAI 2009). This means that perceptions of an individual's capabilities based on his or her MOS is likely at least partially rooted in truth, but that does not mean that these perceptions should reach the level of stereotyping individuals based on their specialty. The military has almost every conceivable employment position tat exists in the civilian world, from plumbers to cooks to pilots, and each classification can carry its own burden of presumptions and stereotypes around with it. Non-combat positions especially can be viewed with derision due to the reasons many individuals are placed there -- lack of fitness or disability -- meaning that otherwise eligible individuals placed in non-combat positions might have certain negative stereotypes of lack of fortitude or cowardice to contend with (Smith 2010). These stereotypes work the other way around, as well, and individuals who are given elite combat classifications might be seen as unfit for certain other less combative positions further on in their careers. These stereotypes quite clearly cut both ways, harming both in a directly negative manner in and ways that take longer to observe.

The Gender Problem

Gender has always been an issue in the military; stories of women dressing as men in order to fight and serves as soldiers go back for millennia. Even today, women are specifically barred from serving in combat positions in the United States military (USAI 2009; Smith 2010). This is not the full extent of the stereotypes that women in the armed forces face, however. Though this non-combative status is one part in the overall stereotype that is attached to women in the military, it is far from the most meaningful or the most complex. Women are held both to be inferior to men in many ways, and at the same time they are seen as too masculine (or too unfeminine, perhaps) for joining the military in the first place (DeGroot 2001).

one of the...

Seen as weaker, less capable, and less effective in leadership positions, women are trusted less and therefore are prone to lose capabilities and effectiveness through disuse and an erosion of confidence (Boyce & Herd 2004). This is especially apparent in leadership positions, where the lack of trust and confidence in a female leader's capabilities leads directly to a diminished leadership capacity, as decisions and orders are questioned or directly disobeyed (Boyce & Herd 2004). This then reinforces the stereotypes that female leaders face, reducing the opportunities available to them in the military despite measures that indicate largely equal capabilities and likelihoods of success if female armed forces members were given equal opportunities (DeGroot 2001; Boyce & Herd 2004).
Conclusion

If the United States military could eradicate these stereotypes and others that exist within the organization, granting promotion and responsibility based solely on merit, its operations would become much more efficient and successful. Stereotypes based on awards, occupational specialties, and gender do not lead to any positive organizational or individual behaviors, but rather limit the perspectives of both the organization and its members. Broadening perspective and opening opportunities would be far more beneficial for all concerned.

References

Boyce, L. & Herd, A. 92004). "The Relationship Between Gender Role Stereotypes and Requisite Military Leadership Characteristics." Sex roles, Volume 49, Number 8, pp. 365-78.

DeGroot, G. (2001). "A few good women: Gender stereotypes, the military and peacekeeping." International Peacekeeping, Volume 8, Issue 2, pp. 23-38.

Frey, B. (2007). "Awards as compensation." European Management Review, Volume 4, Number 1, 2007, pp. 6-14.

Smith, S. (2010). "Army MOS." Accessed 1 February 2010. http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-an-army-mos.htm

USAI. (2009). "Branches &…

Sources used in this document:
References

Boyce, L. & Herd, A. 92004). "The Relationship Between Gender Role Stereotypes and Requisite Military Leadership Characteristics." Sex roles, Volume 49, Number 8, pp. 365-78.

DeGroot, G. (2001). "A few good women: Gender stereotypes, the military and peacekeeping." International Peacekeeping, Volume 8, Issue 2, pp. 23-38.

Frey, B. (2007). "Awards as compensation." European Management Review, Volume 4, Number 1, 2007, pp. 6-14.

Smith, S. (2010). "Army MOS." Accessed 1 February 2010. http://www.wisegeek.com/what-is-an-army-mos.htm
USAI. (2009). "Branches & MOS List." Accessed 1 February 2010. http://www.us-army-info.com/pages/branches.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

U.S. Military Bay of Pigs
Words: 3159 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

By the end of the year, United States wished to look for another person to replace Fulgencio Batista. It is also thought that Batista was suggested that the CIA should assassinate Fidel Castro but Batista rejected the offer (Hugh Thomas, p.30). The then Director of CIA, after Castro took over stated verified that Castro was not inclined towards Communism and that any American intervention before the takeover or at

The Effect of Integration on Ci Humint Collection Women in Combat
Words: 20780 Length: 70 Document Type: Essay

Women in Combat: The Effect of Integration on CI/HUMINT Collection The Effect of Integration on CI/HUMINT Collection: Women in Combat Key Words: #Combat # Integration # CI/HUMINT The success of any counterinsurgency operation depends largely on the effectiveness and appropriateness of intelligence gathered. Human subjects are a crucial source of intelligence for counterinsurgency operations. Recently, the Pentagon announced its plan to open up all ground combat roles that had previously been closed to

The Effect of Integration on Ci Humint Collection Women in Combat
Words: 20308 Length: 20 Document Type: Essay

Women in Combat: The Effect of Integration on CI/HUMINT Collection The Effect of Integration on CI/HUMINT Collection: Women in Combat Key Words: #Combat # Integration # CI/HUMINT The success of any counterinsurgency operation depends largely on the effectiveness and appropriateness of intelligence gathered. Human subjects are a crucial source of intelligence for counterinsurgency operations. Recently, the Pentagon announced its plan to open up all ground combat roles that had previously been closed to

Effect of WWI on Jews and Germans
Words: 3140 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Germans and Jews After WWI Germans and Jews After World War I In World War I, more than 12,000 Jews lost their lives fighting for Germany (Flannery, 43). They were a large part of the culture there, and had intermingled as much as they were able to. However, despite the way they were involved in so much of what was taking place in the country, they were also never really accepted. After

Women-Workforce Effects and Issues Related to the
Words: 6393 Length: 22 Document Type: Term Paper

Women-Workforce Effects and issues related to the promotion and use of women and their skills into the American workforce This paper explores the promotion of women within the American workforce. Specifically the aim of this study is to discover whether organizational systems within the U.S. are utilizing women to their fullest potential. The aim of the researcher is to examine whether or not women are still subjected to a 'glass ceiling'

Barbie Doll Effects
Words: 1728 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Barbie Doll Effects Mattel's top-selling doll could have started a cultural revolution. Barbie could indeed be responsible for shaping gender identity and norms in American culture in particular. The demand for ethnic Barbies and themed Barbies points to the fact that all little girls, whatever their family or cultural backgrounds, are aspiring to be like Barbie. Pop star icons like Brittany Spears and Jessica Simpson bolster the Barbie image ideal. Whether

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now