Verified Document

Memory Theory Of Personal Identity Term Paper

Every aspect of personhood is thus integrated, and cannot be separated from each other. Personality theories are particularly interesting when applied to cases such as split-brain patients. In split-brain patients, there is no dominant hemisphere, with only the sub-dominant halves remaining. In these cases, there is no connection between the two halves of the brain, each perceiving the world according to its own field of perception. Bundle theorists then argue for the integration of the variety of experiences in a unified person, although these experiences are diverse.

The theory can then be likened to a person having several diverse experiences at the same time, which is the case for most persons going through life at any particular time. In the case of a split-brain patient, several states of awareness of several different experiences occur, according to bundle theorists. There is no third, separate entity as might be assumed by memory and ego theorists. The entire experience occurs within the person, and the person remains an individual, although the experiences and awarenesses within the same person are diverse and numerous.

Evaluation

Memory theorists are essentially attempting to separate the personal identity from everything else, including morality and experience. Identity is assumed to be made up of a number of essentially physical parts that remain the same in essence throughout life. This has been shown by study and experience to be incorrect. There are many variables within the individual, even in terms of physical properties. As Hume points out, growth occurs both in the personality and the physiology of a person. The fact that the identity does not change is explained by the gradual process of growth. This may then also be what led to Locke's memory theory that separates the physical aspect from all other...

Human beings are integrate parts forming a whole within themselves and as part of a community. To separate any of the parts from each other is to deny the very nature of humanity. Hume on the other hand assumes both integration and a dynamic process of experiences in terms of the identity and personality.
According to personality and identity theories today, Hume's bundle theory is therefore the superior of the two. Everything in life is integrated, including the various aspects that form the human identity. Life is indeed a dynamic process of growth and identity change and formation. The gradual nature of this process ensures that the same identity remains throughout life. Thus, while Locke was on the right track assuming that the identity remains the same, he was incorrect in assuming that it is entirely static.

Personal identity is made up of many parts, as Locke states, but each part is dynamic, as Hume states. Human beings are thus the sum of their experiences, but not separate from them, as memory theorists hold. Experiences serve as a process human beings go through in order to change and grow. This process serves as the vehicle to the final end, which is death.

Thus through changing experiences and perceptions, the human being grows not only in physiology but also in personality to reach maturity. When old age is reached, wisdom is achieved, which could then again form part of the experiences and perceptions of the offspring, thus affecting future generations. In this way then personal identity continues to change and grow, affecting the evolution of the community and humanity as a whole.

Third, evaluate which (if either) is the better theory of personal identity.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Soul Theory of Personal Identity
Words: 790 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Soul Theory of Personal Identity I've always ascribed to the soul theory of personal identity. This theory essentially stipulates that as we move through time we do so consistently as long as we continue to have the same soul. In structure this theory, some might argue, is comparable to the body theory. The underlying principles are the same. The soul theory states that as one has the same soul, one is

Identity Development Is a Topic That Has
Words: 2568 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Identity development is a topic that has been studied for some time. There are two main ways to address it: as young children who are just developing an identity and as adults who are changing or developing an identity they never created or did not like as a child. Each person, as he or she grows, develops a distinct and separate identity from other people (Willemsen & Waterman, 1991). While

Identity Construction in Literary Texts
Words: 9748 Length: 30 Document Type: Literature Review

Chokshi, Carter, Gupta, and Allen (1995) report that during the critical states of emergency, ongoing intermittently until 1989, a low-level police official could detain any individual without a hearing by for up to six months. "Thousands of individuals died in custody, frequently after gruesome acts of torture" Those who were tried were sentenced to death, banished, or imprisoned for life" (Chokshi, Carter, Gupta, & Allen, ¶ 6). The enactment

Personal Model of Helping Therapists Do Whatever
Words: 2318 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Personal Model of Helping Therapists do whatever they can to help their clients overcome a wide range of problems ranging fromdeath of a pet to major life changing crisis, such as sudden loss of vision. However genuine a therapists' desire to help is, they will be limited by the tools he or she uses. It makes sense, then, as a therapist to design and integrate webs of models that have shown

Identity Is This Explanation Sufficient,
Words: 321 Length: 1 Document Type: Thesis

Aspects of identity that might have been denied or denigrated because of colonial mentalities can resurface and be admired. Discourse on gender and social class has also deepened and enabled identity constructions to flourish outside the confines of proscribed gender roles. Culture changes, and so too does identity. The values placed on identity aspects like religion have shifted too, making religion a less salient part of people's identity. On

Person Identity
Words: 1053 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Person Identity Weirob believes that she is only her body because her identity is uniquely tied to it. Her body is what has experienced (i.e., seen, smelt, tasted, felt, etc.) the world; it is that to which she has attachment. Her body is the only constant in all of the arguments of identity. She was unconvinced by appeals to theories of identity tied to souls (which are unknowable, she argues) or

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now