Civil Service
The war in Iraq has spawned a debate over whether or not all persons should have to spend some time in the civil service when they reach the age of eighteen. There are huge sacrifices that are being made in Iraq and Afghanistan but they only really affecting working class Americans. Not everyone can be in the military but everyone can participate in various aspects of the civil service. The purpose of this paper is to provide definitive proof that civil service should be mandatory at the age of eighteen.
Mandatory service
Many veterans and ordinary Americans believe that a grave mistake was made in 1973 when the draft was abolished. Many felt that military service should be mandatory.
An article in Washington Monthly explains,
Such a system should be mandatory not voluntary. It should be broad, not narrow, with exceptions based on inability rather than personal inconvenience. (Exceptions for prison inmates, for example, but definitely not for the college-bound or well-heeled). It should involve women as well as men, in stark contrast to our draft and the male-only service plans of most other countries. Eventually, it should ask something of all Americans, just as the jury system (at least in theory) does now. (Keisling)
Now there are some definitive problems associated with making military service mandatory at the age of eighteen. First of all making military service mandatory would be extremely costly. It was estimated that it would 50 billion a year in 1994, we can guess that the cost which be much higher today. It would also be extremely difficult to train millions of American for military service each year. For this reason making military service mandatory would be extremely difficult.
However our nation is in desperate need of civil service personnel. These individuals could serve in areas such as education,
(Keisling) This type of service would be beneficial to the servant and the recipient. Serving in one of these capacities could result in better neighborhoods and less crime. In addition, the civil servant will be exposed to people from different socioeconomic backgrounds.
An article found in The American Prospect asserts that the war on terrorism is a wake up call which validates the need for mandatory civil service at the age of eighteen. The article asserts that mandatory civil service should be a right of passage for young Americans. The article also points out that for it to become a true rite of passage it has to involve young people from every walk of life. The article asserts, "for national service to become a unifying rite of passage, elites will have to serve alongside everyone else. "If you did have prominent people -- a la Chelsea Clinton -- it might send ripples down the social ladder," Moskos says. On Marshall's desk at the Progressive Policy Institute is a photo of Elvis Presley in his GI uniform -- a reminder, he says, that the burden of national service must be shared equally. (Just)
President Bush has also addressed a need for more civil service personnel in the wake of September 11. The president and his administration encouraged individuals to get involved in organizations such as Ameri-corps, Peace-corps, and Senior Corps. Bush asserts that there is a great need for this type of service amongst young Americans. (Bridgeland et al.)
The president of the California Wellness foundation, Gary Yates supports Bush's assertions concerning civil service. In an article entitled "Mandatory National Service: Building National Spirit and Solving Social Ills" Yates contends that civil service should be made mandatory for everyone at the age of eighteen. Yates believes that mandatory civil service is really necessary for youths that have very little job skills and are engaging in criminal activity. He asserts that mandatory civil service will allow them to develop job skills, while contributing to the community and the country. The article asserts,
Mandatory national service would address the "critical years" problem, the after-school years between 18 and 24 when men and women are more likely to be the victims or…
The Vietnam experience illustrated that, as well as the need for more fair methods of defining exemptions and assigning stateside military duties in times of foreign wars. It is rather well-known that 18 is a comparatively dangerous age, primarily because, with the exception of consuming alcohol and tobacco products, it marks a period of youth where one enjoys all the legal rights of adulthood in the U.S. despite the fact
Vebell was interested in art from a very early age and he attended the Harrison Art School at the age of 14 where he excelled at life drawings. When he graduated from high school, Vebell won three art scholarships and he attended all three schools -- moving from each throughout the day. He launched his professional illustration career in a busy Chicago agency and then enlisted in World War
Fault: An Alternative to the Current Tort-Based System in England and Wales The United Kingdom statistics regarding claims THE NATIONAL HEALTH SYSTEM OBSTACLES TO DUE PROCESS THE CASE FOR REFORM THE REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT THE RISING COST OF LITIGATION LORD WOOLF'S REFORMS MORE COST CONTROLS THE UNITED STATES PAUL'S PULLOUT THE INSURANCE INDUSTRY TORT REFORM IN AMERICA FLEEING PHYSICIANS STATISTICS FOR ERROR, INJURY AND DEATH THE CALL FOR REFORM IN 2003: A FAMILIAR REFRAIN THE UNITED STATES SITUATION, IN SUMMARY NEW ZEALAND CASE STUDIES THE SWEDISH SCHEME COMPARISON: WHICH SYSTEM IS
Stock Leader Does Having a New Black President Make it Easier for Minorities to Advance to Leadership Roles in Business? "Excuse me, sir. I'm looking for the Color Line. Would you know where I can find it?" (Miller) The United States has made great strides in regard to minority relations by electing its first black president. By today's standard, minority entails many different things such as classifying by nationality, race, religious preference, physical disability, gender
Teaching Young Americans What it Means to be a Good Citizen Citizenship education, to give it a name, does not simply belong to the social studies teacher. -- Peter S. Hlebowitsh, Daniel Tanner and William G. Wraga, 2000 Statement of Generative Theme. Children born today will probably never know a day and age when mankind does not have a permanent presence in outer space, and the world is becoming a much smaller place
Politics of the Common Good Tom Shulich ("ColtishHum") In "A Politics of the Common Good," Michael Sandel defends the idea of reintroducing the concept of "virtue" into American political debates (261-269). Sandel contends that our political discourse has become impoverished in recent decades, reduced to only two concerns: welfare and freedom. Welfare has to do with economics and freedom has to do with respecting people's rights (Sandel 262). Rather than limiting
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now