Verified Document

Managers Set Bad Strategies In Term Paper

Analysis of the data

Porter's discussion of strategies fails capture the highly specific responses needed from home base countries' multinationals to expand into other nations with cultures highly dissimilar to ones' own. In the Competitive Advantage of Nations, Porter assumes a cultural homogeneity and "likeness" and has never published research illustrating a western multinational or for that matter home base country moving into foreign nations. The research Porter completed with the Japanese Ministry of International Trade highlights the insularity and importance of trust through relationships.

The growth of westernized home base industries into China is significantly more complex than Porter theorizes through the diamond or other analytical constructs as defined in Competitive Advantage of Nations. For example, Chinese consumers prove extremely loyal to domestic products and brands, partially because so few Western items existed in the market until the 1990s.

The transformation to a free market economy did little to change the cultural mindset that customers should buy products made exclusively in China. In particular, the interior areas of the country prove most resistant to accepting Western companies and products. In these areas, socialist loyalties and heavy central planning investment dominated prior to 1976, leaving a highly nationalistic legacy. Currently, customers in these regions appear to have a greater interest in preserving the old state subsidized system and have exhibited more resistance to the economic reforms and open-door policy that started...

Urban, coastal regions prove more culturally liberal but still appear slow to fully accept Western products. Customers grow to accept, and even prefer, foreign offerings, but there remains a significant portion of the population that continues to resist this trend.
These dynamics of the Chinese market for example would be difficult if not impossible to capture within the context of the Porter diamond and associated constructs.

Limited and justifiable conclusions

In the context of the article reviewed, the many insights gained from revisiting the bulk of Porter's previous works shows that the avoidance of the "Bermuda Triangle" by companies is much more difficult than initially portrayed. The negotiation theory that best fits Porters' comments in this article is clearing competitive bargaining, with a strong focus on how corporations become both demand-driven by consumer needs and more aligned with their internal strengths. Analyzing both Porters' presentation and previous works lead to the conclusion that regional competition and superior insights into the dynamics of an organization lead to superior competitive bargaining positions.

References

Forbes (2006) - Why Do Good Managers Set Bad Strategies? Knowledge&Wharton. November 4, 2006. Accessed from the Internet on February 21, 2007 from location:

http://www.forbes.com/2006/11/04/porter-sysco-mcdonalds-ent-manage-cx_kw_1103wharton_print.html

Porter (1990) - "Competitive Advantage of Nations" Harvard Business Review. March - April, 1990

Sources used in this document:
References

Forbes (2006) - Why Do Good Managers Set Bad Strategies? Knowledge&Wharton. November 4, 2006. Accessed from the Internet on February 21, 2007 from location:

http://www.forbes.com/2006/11/04/porter-sysco-mcdonalds-ent-manage-cx_kw_1103wharton_print.html

Porter (1990) - "Competitive Advantage of Nations" Harvard Business Review. March - April, 1990
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Strategy Mapping Is an Approach to Strategy
Words: 1213 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Strategy mapping is an approach to strategy implementation that flows from the balanced scorecard approach to formulation and measurement. Strategy mapping allows for a clearer understanding of the dynamics of strategy to be understood, especially at the implementation level. The framework was developed in order to do three things. These are to set appropriate objectives, establish a dominant value proposition, and then find critical strategies that support that position. The

Bad Leadership Is Hazardous to
Words: 1551 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

Mental breakdown and psychological distress also follow. Good leaders are effective communicators and have the empathy to read warning signs of mental breakdown. They are able to address mental health situations before they start. You will know bad leadership when you see it. Organizations that are run poorly suffer from the same types of problems including inefficiency, poor financial performance and high incidence of workplace injury and mental health problems.

Bad Requirements Can Ruin a Project. Success
Words: 2962 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

bad requirements can ruin a project. Success in relation to projects could be defined in several ways. The literature on Project Management has several definitions concerning project success. A project could be successful either in part or as a whole. A more rigid definition relating to overall success of projects could be on the basis of the argument that all strategic stakeholders are satisfied with the results of the project.

Strategy and Corporate Governance
Words: 3368 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

BP Oil Spill Strategy and Corporate Governance The bp oil spill of 2010 British Petroleum (BP) is one of the largest oil exploring companies in the world. It is recognized for its efficient practices. In recent years it has positioned itself as an environmentally responsible company by stressing its commitment to undertaking exploration activities by causing minimum harm to the natural environment. It has also invested in technologies to make drilling under the

Bad Boss My Boss... Ten
Words: 5042 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Projecting higher expectations: A "bad boss" has not developed positive dynamics with all his/her subordinates. Four key principles, on the other hand, identify practices a "good boss" implements: Be clear up front Get to know the individuals Beware of labeling Monitor ongoing evaluations In the article, "How to spot the boss from hell Classic signs of a Mr. Nasty," Oliver Finegold's (2005) notes that a current study "details the 10 signs of a bad boss -

Strategy Theory and Actual Strategies Being Used
Words: 7593 Length: 28 Document Type: Term Paper

Strategy Theory and Actual Strategies Being Used in Small Insurance Companies Ask any layman on the street what they think about insurance companies and the answer will invariably be negative. Consumers, by and large, view insurance companies with disdain. It is a business that sits among other necessary, yet not always understood businesses, therefore when the economy began to slump very few people had sympathy for the struggles the small

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now