Verified Document

Liberty We Are Living In A New Term Paper

¶ … Liberty We are living in a new era, an era of global power and global vulnerability. In response to the terrorist acts of September 11, 2001, and the recognition that we are facing a worldwide network of terrorists whose singular goal is to harm the United States and its interests, we have had to re-evaluate our civil liberties. Has our open society, our open emigration policy, our support of individual freedom and autonomy and privacy, left us uniquely vulnerable? How do we balance liberty with safety? Our current government has made various policy changes that will allow greater invasion of privacy. At the same time, in this period of unrest, troubles within our own society have brought the same issue to the forefront. After repeated episodes where children killed children in high schools, it became commonplace for schools to search lockers and even in some cases to use metal detectors, on the fear and supposition that some children might be carrying guns. Luggage must now be searched in airports. Profiling of potentially dangerous individuals is in place.

How would John Stuart Mill, a famous defender of freedom and autonomy, have analyzed this situation we are in? There is no doubt that On Liberty is a seminal text, and that this famous, short book truly crystallized the philosophy of liberty and remains influential to this day. According to Mill's introduction, civil liberty is simply "the nature and limits of the power which can be legitimately exercised by society over the individual." Mill noted that compulsion and even despotism is a necessary means of rule when a government is dealing with "barbarians"; but once a society has "attained a capacity of being guided...

Mill states, "The only freedom which deserves the name, is that of pursuing our own good in our own way, so long as we do not attempt to deprive others of theirs, or impede their efforts to attain it."
Therein lies the difficulty -- the tremendous difficulty of achieving a balance. In his second chapter Mill says he can see no argument against the freedom of the press. Not even a single voice should be silenced. What would Mill say today, when if the press were allowed total freedom, they might leak important security information from the FBI and the CIA in their attempt to pursue individuals who are masterminding schemes for further terrorist activities that could harm hundreds or even hundreds of thousands of Americans? I believe that Mill, in speaking of the freedom of all voices, was speaking of the freedom to express opinion, to express dissent. The editorial and op-ed pages of our newspapers should allow all voices to join in, no matter what their opinion. This is different than leaking important security information. And yet Mill is definitely an optimist, one who believes that mankind can and will better itself, and learn and choose wisely. He might be dismayed to see what turmoil our world is in today. And if he were to take a good look at the scope of history he might see that unfortunately, the impulse to war -- the "barbarian" impulse -- is something that seems impossible to eradicate from human nature or human society. It occurs again and again. Even after the devastation of World War I and World War II, we have had violent civil wars around the world, we continue to see torture…

Sources used in this document:
What of Mill's point that individuals should be allowed to act as they wish, as long as they don't make themselves "a nuisance to other people." He says, "To individuality should belong the part of life in which it is chiefly the individual that is interested; to society, the part which chiefly interests society." In these complicated time, the overlap between the two is complex. An individual child may borrow a gun -- and harm society. An individual terrorist may learn how to fly planes in America -- and bring down the World Trade Centers and harm and kill thousands -- as well as cost millions to society. One of the individual rights is the right to live a safe life -- a life where stopping to get gas, one is not gunned down by a sniper; where, attending school, one is not gunned down by a classmate; where, going to work one sunny morning, one is forced to jump from a 100 story window because one is burning to death. I believe Mill would have called this a time for government intervention, much along the lines we are seeing now, because he would view this as an unfortunate time where "barbarians" put us at risk for our very safety -- out of which liberty arises. But I also believe he would argue for a very public discussion, one that has been squelched. Though humans are a mixture of barbarian and angel, of evil and grace, and always will be, there are ways in which societies can adjust to terrible times. And one of those ways is to encourage an open discussion of all issues.

Mills, John Stuart. On Liberty. Original Book published 1869. Available at Bartleby.Com, Great Books online.

Myerson, George. Mills on Liberty. Hodder & Stoughton (2002).
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

New Media and Politics With the Passage
Words: 1314 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

New Media and Politics With the passage of time, the world has become a global village. Media has played a significant role in reducing communication gaps and barriers between people all across the globe. The emergence of new media technologies has not only affected people all across the globe but also the conventional medium being used for communication thus further diversifying its role. The increasing span of media and its role

New Revolution Literature the Literature
Words: 1966 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

The expansion meant progress and it implemented the idea of progress into the minds of the new people. As Thomas Jefferson noted, the permanent moving forward of the boundaries and the idea of growth and multiplication enhanced the feeling of unfailing progress: "However our present interests may restrain us within our limits, it is impossible not to look forward to distant times, when our rapid multiplication will expand itself

Living and Doing Business With Australians Word
Words: 1195 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Living and Doing Business With Australians Word Count (excluding titles): 1159 The Commonwealth of Australia has a population of twenty two million and consists of six states and two territories and has the thirteenth largest economy in the world. The majority of the population gathers around the coastal cities and has one of the lowest population densities in the world. Australia is a country overflowing with natural beauty and unparalleled multiculturalism.

New Testament Book of Romans
Words: 3366 Length: 13 Document Type: Research Proposal

Instead, Paul positions the way of faith over against "works of the law" (Rom 3:27-28), pitting God's sovereign grace over against human effort. In the interests of his Gentile mission, Paul aims to deflate an inflated sense of Jewish identity, particularly "boasting," which religious leaders routinely displayed while observing ritual religious practices. Paul stressed the time had come to recognize, in accordance with the promises to Abraham, the reality of

New York's Ban on Sale of Big
Words: 605 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

New York's Ban On Sale Of Big Size Soda New York's plan to enact a ban on the sale of large sodas and other sugary drinks as a way of combating obesity is questionable. The government has no valid reason to dictate the size the soda and sugary drinks in the market. The size of soda and other sugary drinks does not get sugar out of the equation; it only makes

New Testament and Christianity
Words: 1265 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Gospel: Gospel is a message that has contents on Jesus, God, salvation, the Kingdom of God, and everything that is done to reach out this message to the believers. Gospel is also one of the books in the New Testament talking about the life, death, resurrection, and the works of Jesus Christ. • Original sin: Original sin refers to the tendency and deprivation to the evil that is seen as

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now