Verified Document

Legal Cases Are An Essential Part Of Term Paper

Legal cases are an essential part of any democratic society because they set precedents which aid in the creation of new laws. The purpose of this discussion is to compare and contrast following three legal cases; Dorsett v. Board of trustees for state colleges and Universities, Riggin v. Board of trustees of Ball University, and Brouillette v. Board of directors of merged area IX. We will examine the impact of these cases on our democracy. Comparisons and Contrasts

Dorsett v. Board of Trustees for state colleges and universities was decided in the 5th district circuit court in 1991. The plaintiff in this case alleged that "various administrative decisions had harmed his reputation, that he had been unfairly denied summer employment and salary increases, and that he had suffered other miscellaneous harassments." (Dorsett v. Board of Trustees for State Colleges & Univs) In this case the plaintiff sued his employer in an effort to change or affect some of the administrative policies that were prevalent at the time. The plaintiff alleged that the administrative policies caused harm to his career and that his constitutional rights were denied.

The Fifth Circuit court ruled in favor of the defendant. The court concluded that these matters were trivial and simply an interfaculty dispute. The court also ruled that the purpose of the administrative policies of the state were designed to protect students and provide their educational needs. The ruling stated,...

We recognize that such decisions might seem extremely significant to [the plaintiff] who has devoted his life to teaching. But we believe, nevertheless, that the alleged harms suffered by [the plaintiff] do not rise to the level of a constitutional deprivation." (Dorsett v. Board of Trustees for State Colleges & Univs.)
Riggin v. Board of Trustees of Ball State University is similar to the previous case in that they both name an institute of higher education as defendants. Both cases also deal with the relationship between employee and employer. In Riggin v. Board of Trustees of Ball State University the plaintiff asserted that Indiana Open Door Law was violated when the Trustees of the University met in private to discuss the further employment of Riggins. The law states that "meeting of an agency considering the public's business must be open to the public, unless there is a specific statute permitting closure." ("Tapping Officials' Secrets")

The university counterclaimed that the professor was incompetent and exhibited "failure to cover pertinent topics in the course syllabus, poor organization of lectures, failure to hold class regularly, and failure to provide opportunities for students to meet with the professor on an individual basis." The findings…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Brouillette v. Board of Directors of Merged Area IX, 519 F.2d 126 (8th Cir. 1975)

Dorsett v. Board of Trustees for State Colleges & Univs., 940 F.2d 121, 123 (5th Cir. 1991)

Riggin v. Board of Trustees of Ball State University, 489 N.E.2d 616 (Ind. App. 1986).

Tapping Officials Secrets." 2001. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press Fourth Edition. 7 April 2003. http://www.rcfp.org/tapping/index.cgi?key=IN2
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Legal Research There Is a
Words: 672 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

The first step in doing proper legal research is to fully identify the legal issues. This involves determining what statutes are involved or what principles of common law might apply. This is where many researchers fall short and it is essential that the researcher fully identify the parameters of the case before beginning the research otherwise valuable time and effort will be wasted. Once the legal issues have been identified the

Case Study and Contract
Words: 730 Length: 2 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Kapoor G.K., (n.d). Business Law Including Company Law. Chapter 1 This book, in the isolated chapter 1 discusses the elaborate meaning of a contract and what makes up a legally binding contract. It discusses the elements of a contract in the context of sales and gives examples of what an offer in a contract is and acceptance which are two essential parts of a contract. The chapter further discusses the potentiality

Case Study on Implementing Company Sponsored Childcare
Words: 5099 Length: 19 Document Type: Case Study

President, Harper Supply Company The possibility of providing child care assistance to employees Since we last spoke I have been conducting extensive research into the matter of providing some form of child care assistance to the employees of Harper Industries. Needless to say, I have read much, studied much, and learned much. The final form of this reading, studying, and learning is attached to this memorandum. As you know, we had a very

Legal Research and Argument to Begin the
Words: 2020 Length: 7 Document Type: Case Study

Legal Research and Argument To begin the research for this case and the argument that follows, one must first examine the case and determine what is essential. It is assumed that the engineer was negligent because he should have known about the circular which advised that further structural support would be required for the type of building he was constructing. It is not enough to rely upon 20 years-worth of experience

Legal Analysis Case Summary the
Words: 1794 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

Here, the Plaintiff and all of the members of the God Squad were arrested and removed from school property by police. The police acted on probable cause that the group was inciting violence on school property after observing their offensive and disruptive behavior. Additionally, the Plaintiff was given an arraignment, charged with trespassing, disturbing the peace, and inciting a riot, and was released on bail to the custody of his parents.

Legal Business Form Implemented at Treme Legal
Words: 1527 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Legal Business Form Implemented at Treme Legal Form of Business for Treme When an entrepreneur starts an industry, he or she should always have a vision of what their business should be like and in most cases, this is done through looking at the positives that will bring success and good fortune to the business. It is very essential for an entrepreneur to have information and know how to use good production

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now