Verified Document

Legal Abortion In Canada Unlike Term Paper

The "No New Law!" campaign then shifted its focus to the establishment of freestanding clinics and insurance coverage for women who needed the procedure. Because provincial governments regulate health care in Canada, pressure was put on them for publicly funded clinics. Pro-choice activists also pressured the federal government to approve RU-486 for Canadian testing.

Although criminal sanctions are no longer in force, improved equal access has been disappointing. Rich women have always had access to safe abortions and always had a choice, but working women have not. Their choice was inhibited by the state's involvement. Weir (1994) states the women now who have the greatest difficulties are women of colour, rural women, women from under-serviced areas, poor women, unemployed women, women with disabilities, and women whose first language is not English. How much money women have and what kind of work they are employed in makes a huge difference in their ability to access abortion services.

Access to legal abortions is regulated under provincial health policies (Palley, 2006). The Canada Health Act requires provinces to provide equal access to health care facilities. The national policy since 1995 has been that abortion is a medically necessary service, but this policy often gets undermined by the politics of provinces and territories and intense pressures by anti-choice interest groups. Canada's federal government is limited in its powers and only allowed to sanction provincial violations of the Canada Health Act (with financial penalties). The federal government does not usually interfere with provincial health affairs. Palley (2006) states, "Also, the federal government at the national level has not utilized sufficient financial penalties to ward off substantial lack of compliance with respect to provision of abortion services in many of Canada's provinces and territories" (p. 565). This perhaps explains why inequality of access to services still exists.

Despite the fact that feminism...

All agree that freestanding abortion clinics are central to providing care and service to women with unwanted pregnancies. They see them as central to resisting state control of reproduction. Unlike the therapeutic abortions, which were required in the Criminal Code, freestanding clinics provide elective abortions. The power thus shifts from the state to the woman herself. The therapeutic abortion system preserved the idea that abortion was a criminal act and only permissible when necessary because of exceptional circumstances and danger to the woman's health. Feminists moved the decision into the hands of the woman.
After the 1988 Court decision, feminist acitivists defended abortion clinics from antichoice harassment. When new clinics appeared, they built local support groups. They lobbied to include clinic abortions in provincial disbursements for health care, and they took up fundraising for legal cases (Weir, 1994). CARAL worked to move the context of abortion into the arena of family-planning with "better and more equal access to counseling, contraception, and education" (p. 258). PCAN, which is more leftist, wants a network of "community-based reproductive healthcare centers that would provide birth control, counseling, and other services" (p. 258).

True choice involves much more than abortion rights. As Weir points out, social policies that support women, including prenatal education, universal daycare, parental leave, community midwives, affordable housing and economic equality, are needed in order to ensure real freedom of reproductive choice.

References

Albert, R. (2005). Protest, proportionality, and the politics of privacy: Mediating the tension between the right of access to abortion clinics and free religious expression in Canada and the United States. Loyola of Los Angeles International and Comparative Law Review, 27 (1), 1-62.

Palley, H.A. (2006). Canadian abortion policy: National policy and the impact of federalism and…

Sources used in this document:
References

Albert, R. (2005). Protest, proportionality, and the politics of privacy: Mediating the tension between the right of access to abortion clinics and free religious expression in Canada and the United States. Loyola of Los Angeles International and Comparative Law Review, 27 (1), 1-62.

Palley, H.A. (2006). Canadian abortion policy: National policy and the impact of federalism and political implementation on access to services. The Journal of Federalism, 36 (4), 565-586.

Weir, L. (1994). Left popular politics in Canadian feminist abortion organizing, 1982-1991. Feminist Studies, 20 (2) 249.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Presidential Election Comparison of Candidates
Words: 3328 Length: 12 Document Type: Thesis

A primary is another system of electing delegates with a mandate to vote for a given candidate. Unlike caucuses, primaries are votes conducted by the government on behalf of the political party. This vote can be open, closed, semi-closed or semi-open. Open primaries allow citizens to vote in both parties' primaries; semi-closed only the primary for the party you belong to (independents may vote in these as well) and in

Medical Futility in Nursing Care Caring and
Words: 3647 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

Medical Futility in Nursing Care CARING AND CHOOSING Bioethics is described as both a field of intellectual inquiry and a professional practice that examines moral questions affecting various disciplines (Arras, 2007). These disciplines include biology, medicine, law, public health, policy and ethics. In these disciplines are scholars, teachers, and clinical practitioners, including nurses. Their work has recently been subjected to an unprecedented turn in perspectives concerning relevant issues and behaviors. Among these

Reflecting and Analyzing Justin Trudeaus Qualities
Words: 2524 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

What is impressive about Justin Trudeau? Politics represents vision as well as process. Image, after all, is defined as what one is rather than what one wishes others to think of oneself. Vision drives public policy. Justin Trudeau interests us owing to his vision, value system, guiding behavioral standards and grand ideas (including his ideas defining the people of Canada and molding their identity, and his desire to share ideas with

Lesbian Health Issues Living in a Heterosexual Society
Words: 25618 Length: 75 Document Type: Dissertation

Lesbian Health Care Lesbian Health Issues in a Heterosexual Society The additional burdens placed on the lives of minorities as a result of social exclusion can lead to health disparities. Social exclusion theory has been used in previous research to investigate the health disparities that exist between socioeconomic classes and individuals of different ethnic backgrounds living in the United States, but it has not yet been applied to another important minority group:

Sociology: Changing Societies in a Diverse World
Words: 9606 Length: 30 Document Type: Book Report

Sociology: Changing Societies in a Diverse World (Fourth Edition) George J. Bryjak & Michael P. Soroka Chapter One Summary of Key Concepts Sociology is the field of study which seeks to "describe, explain, and predict human social patterns" from a scientific perspective. And though Sociology is part of the social sciences (such as psychology and anthropology), it is quite set apart from the other disciplines in social science; that is because it emphasizes

Lesbians in U.S. History Sexuality
Words: 3565 Length: 11 Document Type: Thesis

In other words, World War II produced an important shift in both mentality and reality. Although many of the women who had been employed during the war returned to being homemakers, there was also a significant percentage which managed to reconcile being a mother and a wife with work. Also, despite the fact that their wages were far from being equal to those of men, their contribution to the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now