Verified Document

Learning Problems Vs. Language Problems Research Paper

Learning Problems vs Language Problems The objective of this study is to examine how learning problems and language problems are related. Specifically considered will be the fact that when students who are learning English as their second language and who are experiencing academic or behavioral difficulties that the teacher and the school's problem-solving teams must examine whether these problems are related to learning a new language or whether the problems may be due to cognitive delays or developmental delay or disability.

The work of Fisher ( nd) entitled "Assessing English Language Learners for a Learning Disability or Language Issue" states that English language learners all "with learning disabilities...too often...fall through the cracks." (p.13) The reason stated for this is that these learners are often considered to be "slow English learners, or they may be in a school district that does not have enough resources to test them in their L1 for learning disabilities." (Fisher, nd, p. 13)

I. Reasons for Misdiagnosis

There are reported to be multiple reasons that English language learners are diagnosed with a learning disability and the first stated reason and the primary reason for misdiagnosis is that of "the issue of how to correctly diagnose an ELL." (Fisher, nd, p. 14) It is reported in the work of Fisher that the work of Geva (2000) made the observation that "too often ELLs were placed in special education classes on the basis of 'socioeconomic, linguistic and cultural factors rather than the psychoeducational factors." (p.14 cited in Fisher, nd, p. 14)

In addition, it is stated that the professionals "who were sued to dealing with and treating students in their L1 (English) were not trained or prepared for these different learners who had English as their L2" and that this "misinterpretation of the data that was collected to determine...

The intuition of the teacher should not be held as completely viable. Assessing language learner's proficiency has been found to be a faulty method in testing for learning disabilities.
Teachers have also held the misconception that testing should not occur until the English Language Learner develops proficiency in the English language but it can take up to seven years for the English Language Learner to develop language proficiency and by this time the students has lost meaningful education time. Another mistake made by teachers is the belief that there should be an identifiable gap in what the English Language Learner has learned and what they are expected to have learned in a given time period. Finally, it is important to understand that hearing and vision problems may impact the progress of the English Language Learner.

II. Myths and the English Language Learner

There are several myths about Special Education and ESL. For example, when the English Language Learner is not responding, the educator should consider whether or not the student is in what is termed as the 'silent phase' which means that the English Language Learner is recording facts and data and is receptive to information however; the output of the English Language Learner is at this time limited. This period may last from six weeks up until six months. (WebEx Events, 2007, paraphrased) In addition, it takes up to a year of English Language Learning for the ESL to gain proficiency in the English…

Sources used in this document:
References

Recommended Practices for Assessment, Diagnosis, and Documentation of Learning Disabilities (2014) Learning Disabilities Association of Ontario. Retrieved from: http://www.ldao.ca/documents/Assessment%20Protocols_Sept%2003.pdf

Special Education and English Language Learners: Guidance for LEA Staff

An Overview of the ELL/SPED Programs and the Identification Process

(Webinar #1) (nd) Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education. Retrieved from: http://dese.mo.gov/sites/default/files/webinar/documents/ELL-QandA-12-09-13.pdf
Fisher, SM (nd) Assessing English Language Learners for a Learning Disability or a Language Issue. Retrieved from: http://www.hpu.edu/CHSS/LangLing/TESOL/ProfessionalDevelopment/200980TWPfall09/tesolwpssvol7issue2_Fall09/7_2Fisher.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Language Learning and Language
Words: 1654 Length: 4 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Perfect When it comes to present perfect, it is important to note that the tenses of verbs and the specificity via which a prior event is describe is pivotal. Indeed, under the present perfect paradigm, it is important to use the words "has" or "have" but one would not be more specific than that when it comes to the timing of the event as that would be outside the present

Fingerspelling As Children Learn New Languages They
Words: 1838 Length: 6 Document Type: Peer Reviewed Journal

Fingerspelling As children learn new languages they are taught how to sound out words in order to be able to write it correctly when the need comes. Language development in children takes on the traditional form of first experiencing the language, listening to the language, and then viewing the language in written form in order to fully understand what specific words stand for. This is however not possible for all children.

Computer Learning Problems Briihl, D.S. 2001
Words: 995 Length: 2 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Kinshuk, Liu, T., & Graf, S. (2009). Coping with mismatched courses: Students' behaviour and performance in courses mismatched to their learning styles. Educational Technology Research and Development, 57(6), 739-752. Retrieved from ERIC database. Kinshuk and Graf first establish the fact that students are often required to learn material that is not adaptive to their preferred learning style. The work then goes on to analyze how an interactive adaptive online/computer aided system

Language and Language Practices Language Is the
Words: 1505 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Language and Language Practices Language is the written and verbal method by which people communicate with one another. It employs sounds or written designs that are understood by others to create words, phrases, and sentences. Other species have language, as well, but it is not believed to be as complex as the language used by human beings (Bloomfield, 1914; Deacon, 1998). There are many facets to language, and there are nuances

Language Learning Acquisition My Language Learning Acquisition
Words: 1488 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Language Learning Acquisition My Language Learning Acquisition Learning languages that are not native to you is not easy, but it is something that can be done by people who are passionate and dedicated. The easiest way to learn a language is through immersion into that language, and the best time to learn is as a child. Children soak up so much of what they see and hear all around them, that they

Language Is the Perfect Instrument
Words: 4854 Length: 14 Document Type: Term Paper

Consider the fact that the Iroquois are said not to have had a strong word for the singular "I," and that they subsequently developed what was arguably the longest lasting communal representative democracy the world has ever known. The Inuit, whose culture revolves around the arctic world, have dozens of words for snow - this sort of technical knowledge allows quick and accurate transmission of conditions and training in

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now