Verified Document

Johnson, V. 2003 . "A Comparison Journal

820). This view is contradicted by the great number of different cultures that existed in Africa prior to European involvement in the continent, and the many cultures that still remain in one form or another on the continent today. It also overlooks the massive cultural changes that have necessarily come about in the African Diaspora through the variety of experiences and dramatically changed lifestyles experienced by Africans and people of African descent living in non-African countries. According to Johnson's own argument about the inaccuracies and fallacies that arise from the unempirical grouping of different cultural groups together, such an oversimplification of the African/African-American experience is necessarily misleading and ultimately detrimental to the goal of student development. Johnson's assertions in whole and in part could be made more valid and more reasonable to her readers if she employed any empirical evidence whatsoever in this article. Her assertions of the shared values of African-American students and the larger African community (including those living in Africa and those of African descent), for instance, require actual evidence from carefully conducted studies; one could just as easily provide an abundance of anecdotal evidence that different groups and individuals in the African/African-American community hold highly different values and worldviews from each other, and could even question the very existence of a pan-African community and culture. Without real measurement and objectivity, the assertions made in this article are simply opinions -- opinions obviously shared by other scholars, but without the amount of evidence and rationalization that are necessary for the purposes of scientific advancement.

One could of course argue that...

This is likely quite true, but there is nothing in African culture as defined by Johnson that would allow for the making of blanket assertions based simply on feeling or casual observance -- neither the assertion of nor the belief in unity shows its actual existence, and the assertion that the quality of unity and the other six principles identified by Johnson are already "a part of African-American life" is something that requires true evidence, not simple repetition (pp. 827). While it is likely -- almost necessary -- that African-American students come to college with different outlooks, experiences, and developmental needs than European-American students, establishing these outlooks and needs requires true observation, not broad and ungrounded sociological and cultural assertions.
Conclusion

Johnson is not necessarily incorrect in her ultimate assessment that traditional student development programs and procedures are under-serving African-American students. It is likely that different methods ought to be developed, perhaps from completely different cultural perspectives and worldviews, in order to meet the needs of these students. Johnson does not provide an accurate or empirical understanding of the differences in either the needs of these students or the potential methods for addressing and meeting these needs, however, and this makes her article hugely unscientific and essentially meaningless. Her oversimplified view of the situation is self-defeating according to her own arguments; greater empirical observation and scientific rigor is necessary to make her ideas and conclusions more valid and more clearly necessary and applicable.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Johnson and Johnson Annual Report Review Financial
Words: 1743 Length: 6 Document Type: Case Study

Johnson and Johnson Annual Report Review Financial Report Review Company: Johnson and Johnson Consolidated Balance Sheets Total Assets: $121,347,000,000 Total Liabilities: $56,521,000,000 Total Shareholder's Equity: $64,826,000,000 Company's Retained Earnings: 85,992,000,000 Shares of common stock the company has been authorized to issue: 4,320,000,000 shares Shares the company has issued: 3,119,843,000 shares Cash (cash and cash equivalents): $14,911,000,000 Decrease in cash and cash equivalents during 2012: $9,631,000,000 F: Increase in cash and cash equivalents during 2011: $5,187,000 Consolidated Statement of Earnings Essentially, the term "consolidated" as used

Comparative Study Between Homer's Odyssey and the Coen Brothers O...
Words: 11490 Length: 30 Document Type: Thesis

O Brother, Where Art Thou? Homer in Hollywood: The Coen Brothers' O Brother, Where Art Thou? Could a Hollywood filmmaker adapt Homer's Odyssey for the screen in the same way that James Joyce did for the Modernist novel? The idea of a high-art film adaptation of the Odyssey is actually at the center of the plot of Jean-Luc Godard's 1963 film Contempt, and the Alberto Moravia novel on which Godard's film is

Fundamental Analysis of Johnson and Johnson, Inc.
Words: 7682 Length: 25 Document Type: Term Paper

JOHNSON & JOHNSON The Fundamental Analysis of Johnson & Johnson Inc. (J& J, 2005) Economic and Market Analysis Globalization Industry Analysis Company Analysis Brief History of the Company Analysis of Capital Asset Pricing Model Intrinsic Value Valuation Measures Trading Information Competitors Awards & Recognition Our modern business world consists of an extremely competitive global economy where manufactures search for opportunities to strategically reduce costs and increase market share and profitability. Historically, the most often chosen solution for holding down costs was to systematically reduce

Anorexia According to Guissinguer 2003 Anorectics, "...React
Words: 2104 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Anorexia According to guissinguer (2003) anorectics, "...react to loss of body weight by displaying adaptive responses that originally evolved to facilitate leaving food depleted areas." Discuss. Anorexia is a disorder attributed to attempts to attain a fashionable shape, but numerous studies suggest that it is possible for psychological and societal factors to contribute in the development of this disorder. According to Kaye et al. (1998), anorexia is a disorder characterized by unusual

Artworks a Comparison of Picasso
Words: 717 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Like Picasso, Van Gogh (though with an old world soul) would find fullest expression once landing in Paris. After a year of being in the company of other Impressionists like Paul Signac -- and being in a city that itself so filled with history, Catholicity, and romance -- Van Gogh's soul brightened from its gloomier days in search of a Protestant mission: his 1886 painted bulbs are the reflection of

Nursing: Comparative Critical Review to
Words: 3585 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Finkielman et al. (2003) In a study conduction by the Department of Anesthesia and Intensive Care at the Haukeland University Hospital in Norway which was a follow-up of after intensive care with objectives of research of "health problems, quality of life, functional status, and memory" Kvale et al. (2003) following intensive care. Findings in brief were that further research is needed to fully understand exactly how the many psychosocial and

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now