Verified Document

Is Roger Goodell Competent To Reform The NFL's Policies  Essay

NFL and Decision Making The National Football League (NFL), probably the most popular and richest sports league in America, has been in the news a lot lately. The issues involving the NFL have not been about football per se -- and about what teams are dominant early in the season -- but rather about wrongdoing by football players and incompetence and poor decision-making by the commissioner of the NFL, Roger Goodell. This paper reviews the domestic violence issues that have made headlines over the past few weeks and months, and the wrongheaded attempt at leadership the public has witnessed from the commissioner.

A History of Lenience by the NFL

It was April, 2007, and in the previous season more than 50 NFL players had been arrested for various crimes, so Commissioner Roger Goodell got tough on these players by instituting a "newly stringent personal conduct policy" (Pennington, et al., 2014). Goodell insisted that he could handle the wave of criminal activity by players himself, and that was installing himself as "…the judge and jury presiding over every case" (Pennington, p. 1). Goodell was quoted saying, "It is my job -- not law enforcement's job -- to protect the National Football League," however the offenses the commissioner was ruling over were drug use or driving while intoxicated, Pennington explains. Moreover, eyebrows were raised because Goodell was...

An example that Pennington offers is quite dramatic: a Packer linebacker, Erik Walden, was arrested for assaulting his live-in girlfriend. After the police reduced the charge to "disorderly conduct" (and dismissed that charge), then handed Walden 50 hours of community service, Goodell gave Walden a one-game suspension. Meanwhile, eight weeks earlier Bengal receiver Jerome Simpson was busted with two and a half pounds of marijuana, and Goodell suspended Simpson for three games.
Therein is one of the major inconsistencies in terms of judgment by Goodell. A player is given a one game suspension for brutally attacking a woman, but a player getting arrested for marijuana is suspended for three games. Hence, the impression was that the NFL "…had treated domestic violence as a back-burner concern," and players charged with drunken driving and drug offenses were given tough suspensions (Pennington, p. 2).

The Ray Rice Case -- and Others

In February, 2014, Baltimore star running back Ray Rice was arrested for domestic violence -- against his finance -- and Goodell meted out a two-game suspension, even though the police report indicated that Rice had rendered his finance unconscious with a blow to the head. When the media learned that a player had been given a three game suspension for a drug violation, a "…firestorm of criticism" was launched against Goodell for just handing a two-game suspension to the high-profile running back Rice (Pennington, p. 2). Goodell, who had shown knee-jerk responses to the Rice issue, suddenly changed his policy to give first-time offenders in domestic violence cases six game suspensions.

Subsequent to that new policy, a graphic video was released in August 2014…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Boitnott, J. (2014). 5 Mistakes by Roger Goodell Every Entrepreneur Should Avoid. Inc.

Retrieved September 23, 2014, from http://www.inc.com.

Carter, C.J. (2014). Roger Goodell's news conference: 5 things to know. CNN. Retrieved

September 23, 2014, from http://www.cnn.com.
Pennington, B., and Eder, S. (2014). In Domestic Violence Cases, N.F.L. Has a History of Lenience. The New York Times. Retrieved September 23, 2014, from http://www.nytimes.com.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

National Football League
Words: 3870 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

National Football League is the most profitable sports enterprise. The industry boasts over 100 teams and grosses billions in profits each year. The purpose of this discussion is to analyze this industry using Porter's five forces. We will also provide a company analysis of the Cincinnati Bengals. In addition, the discussion will focus on an analysis between the United States Army and the National Football league. Industry Analysis of the

Labor Unions the National Football League NFL
Words: 1254 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Labor Unions The National Football League (NFL) is a high profile sports organization that contributes to the large and growing sports business market and is one of the most recognized corporate brands in America. Every Sunday millions of people watch professional football presented by this organization. Commercial slots for these games provides incredible amounts of revenue as products such as jersey's, cable packages and season tickets contribute to this powerful organization.

Sports and Anti-Trust Is the National Football
Words: 4609 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

Sports and Anti-Trust Is the National Football League's Requirements to Enter the Draft a Violation of Antitrust Law? If so why? Why does the NFL think it is not a violation? Defining the AntiTrusts Legislation Sherman AntiTrust Legislation Clayton Antitrust amendment Presidential support The Maurice Clarett Case The NFL's position, The effect is could have on the game. Judge Scheinin's decision Sherman Antitrust Act Clayton Act Basis of Judge Shira Scheinin's Decision Other cases from other Professional sports leagues, like the NBA, that are

Football More Popular Than Baseball
Words: 6295 Length: 20 Document Type: Essay

Football A recent poll by Harris Poll showed that professional football -- the NFL -- is the most popular sport in the United States. The sport was cited as the favorite by 36% of respondents (SBD 2012). This is up from 24% in 1985. The same poll noted a decline in the popularity of baseball that was almost as severe, that sport dropping from 23% support in 1985 to just 13%

Football Stadium Financing a Football
Words: 1552 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

For all intents and purposes, the public benefits which are stated to accompany the development of a football stadium become increasingly less pertinent to a city's bottom line as time passes. The aging of stadiums and the constant development of newer facilities means that with the passage of just a decade, the returns on such attractions as sports attendance, convention attendance and construction employment have diminished or disappeared entirely.

NFL Foundation
Words: 3936 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Their activities and support of the foundation; enable the league to demonstrate a higher purpose which is of greater social value. (Ferriter) In the majority of cases, the NFL is using the various high profile marketing events to illustrate the importance of sports in promoting various charity related events. The Super Bowl is the biggest event with it using the game as an avenue to help the community which is

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now