Verified Document

Iraq & Iran Nies The Intelligence Reform White Paper

Iraq & Iran NIEs The Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004 instituted the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) (as well as the position of Director itself) and tasked it with coordinating intelligence gathering and dissemination between the disparate agencies of the IC. In 2007 the ODNI implemented Intelligence Community Directive (ICD) 203, which outlined analytical standards for the production of any intelligence product with the goal of ensuring that the IC recorded and shared data in rigorous, analytically sound way, and the implementation of these standards was one of the most important changes seen within the IC after the establishment of the ODNI itself. To understand the importance of these analytical standards not only in the creation of intelligence products but in the actions those products inform, one may compare and contrast the 2002 National Intelligence Estimate (NIE) on Iraq, which was prepared without concern for the analytical standards outlined in ICD 203, and the 2006 NIE on Iran, which implements the ICD 203 analytical standards in its assessment of Iran's nuclear intentions and capabilities.

Before comparing and contrasting the 2002 and 2007 NIEs, one must briefly outline the five analytical standards set forth in ICD 203. They are: objectivity, independent of political considerations, timeliness, based on all available sources of intelligence, and exhibits proper standards of analytic tradecraft.

Each of these standards are fairly self-explanatory, although the fifth standard, exhibiting proper standards of analytic tradecraft, is somewhat more involved, because it demands that any given intelligence product provide a...

national security as well as previous analysis.
While ICD 203 makes it clear that the first four standards are vital in guiding "the writing of intelligence analysis in all IC analytic elements," the extensive nature of the directions for exhibiting the proper standards of analytic tradecraft demonstrates that the ODNI interprets these standards as the key to successful intelligence analysis, and indeed, a look at the 2002 and 2007 NIEs reveals how following the proper standards of analytic tradecraft actually works to ensure that the other four standards are met.

Though written before the implementation of ICD 203, the 2002 NIE on Iraq, titled Iraq's Continuing Programs for Weapons of Mass Destruction, has been criticized for failing to meet standards of objectivity, freedom from political considerations, and timeliness, but these failures may be seen as part of a larger problem with the report. In particular, while the 2002 NIE exhibits a failure to meet these standards, a pervasive problem is the way it disregards the proper standards of analytic tradecraft when it comes to properly describing the "quality and reliability of underlying sources" as well as distinguishing "between underlying intelligence and analysts' asusmptions and judgements."

This can be seen when one compares the introduction of the unclassified 2002 NIE with the 2007 NIE on Iran, because the difference in terms of language and clarity is stark. The 2002 NIE begins with a list of "key judgements," including the central assessment "that Iraq has continued its weapons of mass destruction (WMD) programs in defiance…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Office of the Director of National Intelligence. Analytic Standards. Intelligence Community

Directive 203 (ICD 203). June 21, 2007.

Office of the Director of National Intelligence. Iran: Nuclear Intentions and Capabilitites.

National Intelligence Estiamte. November, 2007.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Iraq Is One of the
Words: 826 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

The fact that he was experienced in politics and learnt a lot of lessons from his predecessor's failures played an important role in securing his position. His initial ruling saw ruthless legislations and the eradication of practically all of his potential opponents. Saddam's ruling emphasized that he would not accept any kind of opposition and whoever expressed the slightest desire to contradict him was harshly punished. The few protests

Iraq in the Ottoman Empire
Words: 2468 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

The last Mamluk governor ruled in the 19th century as Europe was increasingly asked for advice, military weapons, and for help to promote trade. The British were the most influential in this regard which indicates an economic viability to Iraq that the Ottomans were either unable or uninterested in pursuing. The Ottomans, as a European Empire, were unable to maintain influence over its own province. After floods and plagues in 1831, the Ottoman's sent a

Lesson Plan Amp; Reflection I Didn't Know
Words: 857 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Lesson Plan Amp; Reflection I didn't know what state you are in so was unable to do state/district standards! Lesson Plan Age/Grade Range; Developmental Level(s): 7-8/2nd Grade; Below grade level Anticipated Lesson Duration: 45 Minutes Lesson Foundations Pre-assessment (including cognitive and noncognitive measures): All students are reading below grade level (5-7 months) as measured by standardized assessments and teacher observation Curricular Focus, Theme, or Subject Area: Reading: Fluency, word recognition, and comprehension State/District Standards: Learning Objectives: Students will develop

Branding New Service Dominant Logic
Words: 12522 Length: 50 Document Type: Dissertation

Branding in Service Markets Amp Aim And Objectives Themes for AMP Characteristics Composing Branding Concept Branding Evolution S-D Logic and Service Markets Branding Challenges in Service Markets Considerations for Effective Service Branding Categories and Themes Branding Theory Evolution S-D Logic and Service Markets Branding Challenges in Service Markets Considerations for Effective Service Branding Branding Concept Characteristics Characteristics Composing Branding Concept Sampling of Studies Reviewed Evolution of Branding Theory Evolution of Marketing Service-Brand-Relationship-Value Triangle Brand Identity, Position & Image Just as marketing increasingly influences most aspects of the consumer's lives, brands

Iran Intelligence
Words: 1599 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Iran Intelligence In many ways Iran has learned to do what other developed nations have done to protect their interests: try to specialize. This is exactly what it has done in regards to its intelligence and war capabilities. It now has a diverse military and populous system that it at least publicly presents as being able to undertake very distinct protection and defense tasks both inside and outside of the country.

Iran Country Assessment Vulnerability Assessment
Words: 1513 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Iran Country Vulnerability Assessment Outlook Each country has extent of constraints during their development. Iran has suffered similar issues by virtue of being among the developing country. It has also been countries that require not only acquiring, but retaining its power to guard its resources. The country has also been surrounded by powerful governments of Iraq and Afghanistan which have been a threat to Iran. Iran's system of government is theocratic, meaning

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now