Verified Document

Investigate Unethical Illegal Business Term Paper

¶ … companies operating inside the United States attempt to conduct this business legally have become far and few between. The issues that will be investigated will include outsourcing the work offshore by these to places such as Pakistan, the Ukraine and the Philippines, the legal and ethical issues facing the students who use the service and the mechanics of the term paper writing industry. Frankly, due to these legal and cost issues, it is becoming less and less profitable for stateside companies to exist and this as much as legal pressure is propelling the offshore exodus. While the laws may have not been totally effective, the lure for these companies for cheaper operating costs overseas is making the decision to leave the borders of the U.S. easier and making student term-paper cheating an international phenomenon. Analysis

Detection Tools

Simple cut and paste plagiarism is an issue that technology has dealt with easily. Tools and software packages are available for the use of teachers and professors to see if the students have plagiarized their work from Internet sources. Sites such as "Dustball.com" offer the service for free ("Dustball"). However, more effective for pay services are also available to check. However, such services do not detect original one-time works written by an author for a specific student. This is much harder for schools to detect, hence the proliferation of overseas outsourcing companies in the wake of stateside laws and legal injunctions.

Ethical Issues/State Laws Forbidding the Practice

The fact that students have been outsourcing their paper writing to others is as old as fraternity and sorority rumpus rooms. The old school method of cheating originated in the halls of the fraternities and sororities or from the files of relatives and friends. At the time of the writing of a 1973 Political Quarterly article, the problem was old and many times overlooked or acquiesced by school faculty and staff. Only the most publicly documented cases of cheating from publicly available sources were caught and punished with expulsion, grade reductions, warnings, probation...

State laws had generally failed to stop or stem the tide of what even at that time was rampant cheating (Stavisky 445). Certainly, the Internet and Google have made life even easier for cheaters.
There are no federal laws dealing with the issue, but many state laws in about a dozen states make the practice illegal. Probably the most draconian is Pennsylvania. This statute has been on the books since 2007. Under Pennsylvania Statute § 7324, which states that "Any person who violates the provisions of this section shall be guilty of a misdemeanor of the third degree ("Law.oncle")."

Pennsylvania is not the only state that has been getting tough on cheaters and the U.S. companies that service them. Earlier in 2011, New York considered S1940-2011which is similar to the Pennsylvania Law passed the New York State Senate. The sale of dissertations, theses and term papers over the Internet was already illegal under New York state law and this law simply extended the coverage in an amendment to the state's educational law ("New York Senate"). It is also illegal in Massachusetts (Shvartsman).

Those who buy the papers face a number legal problems. Students who buy the term papers and then turn them in as their own or buy or resell a paper are in violation of copyright infringement laws if they do so without the author's permission. In addition to the legal problems, the students have academic and ethical responsibilities that they are violating in contravention of documents and agreements that they have signed in getting into college or a school.

These relationships may be to themselves, their institutions, or to their classmates. Students who engage in the use of someone else's term paper could face severe penalties at their school, up to and including expulsion from the institution. More and more such institutions have rules against buying term papers and essays. The key legal issue for the term-paper mills is to make sure that they have the authors' permission before the sale of their term papers to students (ibid).

The way that the essay writing services are…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Costello, Carol, perf. CNN American College Students Outsource Their Essays to India, Pakistan and the Philippines . You Tube, 2009. Film. <http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YPOfC_dGRRs>.

"The Plagiarism Checker." Dustball. Dustball.com, 2010. Web. 13 Dec 2011. <http://www.dustball.com/cs/plagiarism.checker/>.

"S1940-2011: Relates to the Unlawful Sale of Dissertations, Theses and Term Papers ." New York Senate. Nysenate.gov, 02 March 2011. Web. 13 Dec 2011. .

Shvartsman, Shulamit. "Term Papers for Sale Text Size:." Lawyers.com. Education-law.lawyers.com, 2011. Web. 13 Dec 2011. <http://education-law.lawyers.com/school-law/Term-Papers-for-Sale.html>.
Steward, Shaday. "What are Academic Essay Writing Services?." Shaday-stewart.suite101.com. N.p., 12 December 2009. Web. 13 Dec 2011. <http://shaday-stewart.suite101.com/are-academic-essay-writing-services-legal-a176909>.
"§ 7324. Unlawful Sale of Dissertations, Theses and term Papers.." Law.oncle. Law.onecle.com, 27 November 2007. Web. 13 Dec 2011. <http://law.onecle.com/pennsylvania/crimes-and-offenses/00.073.024.000.html>.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Business Ethics Palmeri, C&rupp, L 2013, May
Words: 5051 Length: 16 Document Type: Essay

Business Ethics Palmeri, C&Rupp, L 2013, May 3, Disney Bangladesh Exit Pressure on Clothes makers Who Stay, Retrieved from http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-05-03/disney-bangladesh-exit-puts-pressure-on-those-who-may-stay-1-.html The work of Palmeri and Rupp (2013) is focused on highlighting the issues faced by the multinational organizations while operating in developing markets. It is highly likely for large organizations to develop their overseas presence. However the economically developing markets a number of issues including environmental, infrastructural, and compliance with health and

Business Ethics Issues a Company's
Words: 1800 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

On the other hand, applicable laws do have authority and under the concept of moral relativism, it may be justified that any duly passed law be complied with (Svensson & Wood, 2008). One lesson from this case might be that laws between entities in different sovereign nations can be much harder to enforce than laws between entities within the same nation. In the future, Pakistan and other nations might want

Business Ethics Focus on Merrill Lynch According
Words: 4347 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Business Ethics Focus on Merrill Lynch According to Laura Hartman and her co-writer, Joe Desjardins in the work entitled "Business Ethics: Decision Making for Personal Integrity & Social Responsibility" philosophical ethics may be clearly differentiated from theological ethics because theological ethics attempted to disseminate the well-being of an individual on a religious basis while the ethics of an individual's philosophy is such that provisions of justifications that can be applied to

Business Ethics Introduction Summarize the Overall Viewpoint
Words: 980 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Business Ethics Introduction (Summarize the overall viewpoint of the author, and discuss the major issues presented in the case.) In the case, the author is showing how Dennis Kozlowski and Mark Schwartz were at the top of an elaborate scheme to defraud Tyco. This was accomplished by talking about how their troubles began based upon Kozlowski's desire to avoid paying taxes on artwork in New York State. As the investigation expanded, the

Business Ethics in His Book
Words: 1739 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

However, she will either not feel comfortable in the culture and leave or, she will at least give thought to her actions at work and behave ethically so she is not fired. Outline: Introduction Thesis statement: How a person acts in their personal life is indicative of how he/she will act in business. Need more involvement from secondary schools and companies as role models. Personal situation at work with unethical employee. A. Anomie outside of

Business Ethics Has Become a Serious Subject
Words: 1492 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Business ethics has become a serious subject of discussion the world over because of the rather intricate complexities attached to it. There are so many different facets to business related ethical problems that everyday something new emerges that needs to be tackled in the light of current legal structure or philosophical framework. The case of Patricia Dunn from HP might also sound like one of those complicated cases of ethics

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now