Verified Document

Imperialism Was Always Seen As Positive For Essay

¶ … Imperialism was always seen as positive for Westerners, but as destructive by the peoples of Africa and Asia." To what extent does this statement appear to be true? Rudyard Kipling's "The White man's burden" seems to be an ironic condemnation of imperialism. Whilst most Westerners of the viewed imperialism as a necessary fact and as a boon to the 'savages', Kipling was a pre-contemporary in more ways than one and saw the 'Whites' as simply one more other race populating the world. The White man in his greed and folly was perpetrating needless wars and occupying another's land as well as stealing their wives, children, property, and money for the benefit of themselves. Kipling, however, was unique in that most Westerners disagreed with him. To them, they were not only doing their duty but many defined their acts as charity. They were educating the illiterate; teaching the savage the ways of Jesus Christ; showing the primitive how to till and cultivate his soil as well as manage his business; and, in all ways, positively affecting the inferior race with the gentility and keener intelligence of the superior. Others admitted their stake of personal self-interest, but pegged on the same rationalizations: they were benefitting the inferior savage by occupying his land.

The fact that this seemed to be the common attitude of the period is clearly seen in literature that has become classic. Pollyanna and Tom Sawyer, for instance, are two classic productions of the period that contain scenes where the town's people meet on ways to fund the missionaries who are sacrificing themselves in teaching God's word to the primitive people. The view that the other was primitive was internalized in the lay Westerner. Many believed, the African et al. was a cannibal. (In fact, the concept that the other was less intelligent and of an inferior race was believed by Darwin who popularized it to a certain extent).

It may be that the very act of stealing a land from another and imposing one's people, laws, and customs in that land is an act that is so horrific and palpably inexcusable that the perpetrators shrank from its existence by not denying it - they couldn't do that -- but by justifying...

Their claim was that they were extending Roman discipline, order, and law to the conquered and thus their dependencies were benefiting from their imperialism.
Bonaparte wanted to conquer the world. He claims -- as did Hitler later -- that he was unifying the people by doing so and disseminating a common code of law. Hitler would assert that he was populating the world with superior race -- the Aryans -- and ridding it of inferior. Each conquering individual and nation not only excused their acts but also promoted them as profitable to mankind. In fact, as late as 1990, McKinley pronounced that "The American flag has not been planted in foreign soil to acquire more territory but for humanity's sake" (Spivak et al., 271). This sort of imperialism, popularized by Theodore Roosevelt, was of a different sort: it was called neo-colonialism in that rather than actively occupying the other, America exploited the other nation by imposing international monetary institutions, via military threat, missionary interference, strategic investment, and by actively intervening in overthrowing leftist governments even though these may have been democratically elected. The imperialism of the 18th-19th centuries and neocolonialism has the same roots: the arrogance of the West in alleging its superiority over a so-called 'inferior' nation and, thereby, rationalizing its interference in the other's way of life.

This is far easier to do when the occupier sees the other as inferior and rationalizes his act as benign if not benevolent.

Edward Said vociferously condemned imperialism in his book Orientalism (1978) which argued that Western discourse shaped the Orient into an imagined caricature in order to bend it to its own caprices. Orientals were regarded as chaotic, corrupt, irrational, and unable to govern themselves. They benefitted from the sagacious rule of the wiser European who knew the Oriental better than the Oriental knew himself. Observed Richard Francis Burton: "The Oriental…

Sources used in this document:
Sources

Aristotle, and C.D.C. Reeve, (translator) (1998) Politics. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Pub

Bartolome de Las Casas, 1550. Apologetic History of the Indies. Columbia University. http://www.columbia.edu/acis/ets/CCREAD/lascasas.htm

Fromkin. D (1989) The Peace to End All Peace: The Fall of the Ottoman Empire and the Creation of the Modern Middle East. New York, NY: Avon,.

Said E. (2003). Orientalism, New York, NY: Vintage Books
Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty, Cary Nelson and Lawrence Grossberg eds. (1988.) "Can the Subaltern Speak?" 271-313 in Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois PressMill.JS A President in Council the Best Government for India. Library of Liberty http://oll.libertyfund.org/?option=com_staticxt&staticfile=show.php%3Ftitle=264&chapter=21938&layout=html&Itemid=27
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Positive and Negative Effects of
Words: 1496 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

All this may lead to instigate cultural disharmony within the nations (Knight, 2006, p. 2). On economic front too, often globalization is attacked as a view that it supports excruciating imperialism and colonization. It is undeniable fact that globalization has improved the world to a greater degree, yet the negative effects of some consequences cannot be denied. It has led to wide increase of socio-economic disparities within societies, nations and

Social Welfare Policy Has Always Been a
Words: 3226 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

SOCIAL WELFARE POLICY has always been a controversial subject in the United States because of the difference between its perceived and real benefits. Usually public is unable to decide who are social welfare programs designed for and whether they actually benefit the target population. The government on its part fails to convince the public of the benefits and advantages of having various social welfare programs running in the country. Some

Globalization U.S. Imperialism
Words: 2188 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

globalization and imperialism and argues that globalization is actually nothing more than imperialism under a new guise. The writer uses several sources to illustrate the definition of imperialism and then holds it against globalization to prove they are one and the same under different names. There were nine sources used to complete this paper. Globalization = U.S. Imperialism As mankind continues with the process of globalization, many world leaders point to

British Imperialism on Display
Words: 811 Length: 2 Document Type: Chapter

Shooting an Elephant - Orwell I clearly got the impression that Orwell was caught between a rock and a hard place, to understate the situation. He raged at the Burma residents who hated the British and took it out on British police -- and on the other hand, he knew imperialism was a bad policy and he did not have positive thoughts at all about his duty in a British uniform.

Middle East Background Information of
Words: 1503 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

This has caused a divide in Iran, where traditionalists want to save the old religious and moral values, while many people want to bring more changes to Iran, like democracy and true free elections. This has created a rift in the country, and has caused unrest and even hatred of western values. That is one of the things that has caused Muslim fundamentalists in Iran (and elsewhere in the

Drugs, Rock Music and Developing Countries Examining
Words: 3218 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Drugs, Rock Music and Developing Countries Examining the effects of imported rock music on developing countries and its impact on violence and drug abuse is by no means a simple or straightforward task. One important factor is that this type of music overwhelmingly appeals to young people under age 30, and these are often the majority of the population in many developing nations, especially the Middle East and North Africa. To

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now