Verified Document

Identity Freedom Term Paper

Chodorow and Reproduction of Mothering In, "A Room Of Her Own," the feminist novelist and author, Virginia Woolf demonstrated that one of the reasons why women writers were in overwhelmingly low numbers than their male counterparts was because of the lack of economic opportunity. (Woolf, 1991) Victorian perceptions also saddled women with the responsibilities of motherhood and domesticity. This took away the opportunity for women (except for a few) to truly come into their own. Nancy Chodorow, a preeminent social scientist addresses the issue. (Chodorow, 1999) She does not get caught up in the traditional feminist or socialization mindset. Even psychologists, Chodorow avers, have not pursued the matter at a higher granularity. All can agree that, explicitly or implicitly, women have been subjugated. Chodorow addresses the problem using psychoanalysis. She believes that the second-class status of women is associated with the issues of mothering, childbearing and childrearing -- aspects which women have been stuck with since the beginning of humanity. She calls this cycle, "reproduction of mothering."

She addresses this problem by proposing the idea that both girls and boys start out the same -- psychically (besides the obvious differences). Children of both sexes have "pre-oedipal" urges towards their mothers. Chodorow avers that because of taboos associated with incest, boys learn to suppress their Oedipal urges. Also, boys eventually automatically fit into the dominant structure in the male-female dyad in society. Girls, on the other hand, fit into "reproduction of mothering," which means a continued cycle of maternal instincts coming to the fore. This cycle is due to the fact that girls' Oedipal attachments manifest in a development of a sense of self from that attachment. Nancy Chodorow calls this a triangle between mother and daughter that is incomplete without a child forming the third vertex. The evolution of this attachment complex then extends to males in a male dominated society as a girl grows up. The transference of this sense of self is then continued with an attachment towards children. And thus, mothering is reproduced time and again across...

Therefore, Nancy Chodorow's thesis is that a woman's sense of self is derived from an attachment to their mothers and that sense of self is fostered by a male-dominated, "asymmetric" society. While males can exercise their superiority by merely remaining in roles society expects of them, women can only actualize their sense of self by diverting their energies to nurturing. Daughters then watch their mothers; and this sows the seeds for the sense of self-derivation from maternal attachment.
Simone De Beauvoir, on the other hand, presents different historical and contemporary scenarios as to why women, who logically, should not be subservient to men in society, actually are. The reasons she places this before the reader are: that women are essential in the pro-creational scheme of thing; that men need women, even as sexual objects. She bemoans the fact that while men can identify themselves as individuals; women have to identify themselves as women before asserting their individualism. Beauvoir writes that in order for a woman to be identified, she has to attach herself to a man. Beuvoir's thesis is that woman is the "Other." (Beauvoir and Parshley, 1979) If we consider a society as a diagram of concentric circles, the closer to the center an entity is, the greater its importance. In this circle, women are always relegated to the nether regions far away from the center. The idea of the Other is not unique, neither is it original. The concept of Other has been used by every part of society that has considered itself an outcast. Edward Said used the concept of Other for those that were victims of colonialism and imperialism in his landmark book, "Orientalism." (Said, 1979)

Beauvoir believed that this Other'ness of women transcended every victimized group and bore the brunt of society twice over. She talks about slavery in America and the struggles during the Civil Rights. She also talks about the victimization of the Jews. The point Beauvoir makes is that these speech communities used their victimization to cohere into self-protecting units: "We, the Jews," or "We, the Negroes," for instance. But through society as a whole or in specific…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Asimov, I. "Armies of God." Roving Mind. New York: Prometheus Books, 1997.

Beauvoir, S. d., and Parshley, H.M. The Second Sex. A limited ed. Franklin Center, Pa.: Franklin Library, 1979.

Chodorow, N. "Gender Personality and the Reproduction of Mothering." The Reproduction of Mothering: Psychoanalysis and the Sociology of Gender: With a New Preface. Ed. N. Chodorow. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1999. 120-24.

Pinker, S. The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature. New York: Viking, 2002.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Overpopulation Philos Identity Freedom Overpopulation Is a
Words: 824 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Overpopulation Philos Identity Freedom Overpopulation is a consistent and pervasive problem in the world today. There is no doubt that if one looks at the available data and even a great deal of public opinion that overpopulation may be the greatest problem for humanity and the earth to date as the expansion of the human population has become exponential and is increasing in intensity in numbers never before seen. Since 1950, the

Identity Development Is a Topic That Has
Words: 2568 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Identity development is a topic that has been studied for some time. There are two main ways to address it: as young children who are just developing an identity and as adults who are changing or developing an identity they never created or did not like as a child. Each person, as he or she grows, develops a distinct and separate identity from other people (Willemsen & Waterman, 1991). While

Identity the Symbolic Interactionist Goffman 1959 Views
Words: 678 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Identity The symbolic interactionist Goffman (1959) views identity in much the same way as behavioral psychologists viewed personality: personal identity is dependent on: (1) the audience (environment), and (2) the basic motives of the "performer." Goffman uses a metaphor for how one presents himself in everyday life as a sort of an actor who can be "sincere" in that they believe in the impressions their performances elicit, or "cynical" in that

Identity Summary of Social Theory
Words: 380 Length: 1 Document Type: Article Review

The complexity of the issue is underscored by the attempts to not discuss the issue on the larger political stage. This is supported by the presentation of race issues as being historical in nature. The inherent suggestion is that at present these issues no longer exist. As long as identity construction is anchored in the political and cultural dynamic then historical antecedents will remain relevant to the discussion and

Identity in Shakespeare Clearly One
Words: 1160 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Most Elizabethans believed their self-identity was wrapped up in a cosmic paradigm of fate and destiny, and were somehow controlled by the stars and planets and had a power over the baser side of man -- tools of God, but with certain amounts of free will. Thus, a very central idea in Shakespeare is this central view that an individual's identity is set by God, the Planets, the Universe, the

Freedom of Information Vs. Privacy
Words: 2207 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Freedom of information is needed to ensure that government and business is transparent and accountable. However, the mass proliferation of computer and communication technologies has created a unique vulnerability that makes it difficult for agencies to effective protect security and privacy without reducing overall access to information. With this in mind, efforts to resolve this dichotomy must be considered. 3.1 Building Better it Infrastructure Critically reviewing what scholars have noted about

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now