Verified Document

GE Moore Term Paper

Related Topics:

G.E. Moore According to G.E. Moore, Ethics is a "systematic science," that seeks to offer "correct reasons for thinking that this or that is good," (6). As a science and a rational discourse, Ethics must be based in logic and must not reflect any logical fallacies. Therefore, in sections 5-13 of Principia Ethica, Moore systematically analyzes the nature of 'good' and proves that it is logically impossible to define the term. In fact, Moore shows that one of the most common philosophical pitfalls is the attempt to define 'good,' either in absolute or relational terms. As Moore illustrates, good is indefinable because the concept is too simple and too fundamental. A definition necessarily implies a breaking down of something into relational parts; because the concept of 'good' cannot be broken down into any smaller elements, it cannot be defined logically. Because Ethics is a logical discourse, no philosopher studying Ethics can define 'good.'

Although good is indefinable, Moore ironically asserts that "how 'good' is to be defined is the most fundamental question in all Ethics," (5). Moore calls the question "What is good?" The "first question" of Ethics, and proposes that "Unless this first question be fully understood and its true answer clearly recognized, the rest of Ethics is as good as useless from the point-of-view of systematic knowledge," (5). Moore believes this for two reasons: one, because 'good,' however, indefinable, is central to the study of Ethics; and two, because Ethics is a "systematic science" dependent on logic. Interestingly, the answer to the question "What is good?" does not imply that good can be defined. Rather, the "true answer" that Moore wants his readers to recognize is that 'good' is an indefinable concept that is nevertheless the primary consideration of Ethics.

In fact, 'good' is to Ethics as 'foot' is to podiatry. However,...

Moore uses the analogy of a horse to illustrate why one term can be defined and not another. One can define a horse as a "hoofed quadruped of the genus Equus," for example, but one cannot define 'good' in this way. 'Good' is too simple, too pure of a concept to narrow down any further than it already is. Similarly, Moore points out that it would be impossible to define the color yellow because there is nothing to compare it to, nothing more fundamental than the appearance of the color itself. To define yellow in terms of its physics is useless because we cannot actually perceive the physical vibrations of color. Likewise, it is impossible to define 'good.'
One of the reasons why the "first question" is fundamental to Ethics is because the 'good' is the "only simple object of thought which is peculiar to Ethics," (5). No other discipline concerns itself so singularly with what is 'good' and what is 'not good.' 'Good' is the domain of Ethics much as 'God' is the domain of theologians and 'brain' is the domain of the neuroscientist. However, philosophers providing definitions of 'good' fail to ascribe to reason and logic, which Moore believes are necessary for Ethics to be a viable, practical "systematic science.'

Another reason why the "first question" is so important is that a mistaken definition of 'good' leads to more "erroneous ethical judgments than any other," (5). Ethical judgments must be based on reason; otherwise they are vacuous proscriptions. Moore states that the object of Ethics is "to give correct reasons for thinking that this or that is good," (6). Simply stating that "being nice is good" is not enough. The only way to reasonably deem one thing or another as 'good' is…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Moral Philosophy the Title 'Moral
Words: 499 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

(Ethics: The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy) In essence, it can be said that moral philosophy is the field in which questions about what is good, what is bad, what is right, what is wrong are all dealt with, in addition to certain moral principles that an average human being follows through his lifetime. Some of the more popular questions which may be raised during a moral philosophy session could be:

Classic Internationalisation Theories
Words: 5335 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

Firms with what organisational patterns are more likely to acquire existing firms? In what stage of internationalisation is acquisition more likely? Such research should not assume that such decisions are always rational. It may be that irrational factors are important at times. For example, it might be that the rush to acquire businesses in Europe prior to 1992 and to acquire companies in Asia in the mid-1990s reflected a

Intel Corporation Has Progressed From
Words: 2905 Length: 8 Document Type: Thesis

Typically ne entrants are formed from mergers and acquisitions of existing competitors and their continued attempts to dominate the higher-volume, lower price segments of the market. Competitive Rivalry The entire industry is characterized by its very high level of competitive rivalry, between not only global competitors who compete on semiconductors and microprocessors, but also on entire board-level products including motherboards and networking equipment circuitry. This translates into a heavy emphasis on

GMO Genetically Modified Organisms
Words: 3252 Length: 11 Document Type: Research Paper

Genetically Modified Organisms Technology GMO Gentically Modified Organisms A Genetically Modified Organism (GMO) is any organism that has had its genetic makeup altered by humans Ahmed, 2002. The organism could be an animal, plant, or microorganism. The changing of the genetic code could involve subtracting, adding, or altering. All these changes could be from the same species or different species, which would give the organism characteristics that it does not have normally. GMO

Ethics Are "An Individual's Personal Beliefs About
Words: 793 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Ethics are "an individual's personal beliefs about whether a behavior, action, or decision is right or wrong" (Griffin, 2010). Is everyone considered a manager? Why, or why not? The traditional functions of management include planning, organizing, staffing, and directing. All of these involve certain ethical considerations which will reflect both the individual's personal beliefs as well as the belief systems of the organization. Ethics is more than a gut instinct or

Ethics on Sports "It Is
Words: 5409 Length: 15 Document Type: Research Proposal

D., What is Altitude Training section). The Website promoting products that Hypoxico Altitude Training Systems offers, reports that when a person is exposed to hypoxia, oxygen reduced environments, his/her body "struggles to produce required amounts of energy with less available oxygen. This struggle triggers the onset of a range of physiological adaptations geared towards enhancing the efficiency of the body's respiratory, cardiovascular and oxygen utilization systems" (Hypoxico Altitude Training, N.D.,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now