Verified Document

Frege's Much-Discussed Book, The Foundations Of Arithmetic, Book Review

Related Topics:

¶ … Frege's much-discussed book, The Foundations of Arithmetic, is an influential and valuable insight into the philosophy of mathematics. A German mathematician and philosopher, Gottlob Frege was unwaveringly devoted to improving the philosophical underpinnings of mathematics and science. In the Foundations of Arithmetic, Frege delves deeply into not only an understanding of numbers, but he also looks into much larger questions surrounding meaning and truth. Frege argues against the idea that arithmetic is based on psychology, and instead notes that logic is the main underpinning of arithmetic. The Foundations of Arithmetic ultimately argues that analytic judgments govern the laws of arithmetic, and thus these laws exist a priori. This important contribution brought him great praise from many academics, but his work was not without flaws. Importantly, The Foundations of Arithmetic has been criticized for a relatively weak understanding of basic terms underlying the discussion of psychology. This is an important and weighty criticism, since much of Frege's book is based upon his rejection of the idea that logic is founded upon psychology. Despite these important criticisms of Frege's book, The Foundations of Arithmetic remains an important and insightful book into the philosophy of mathematics a century after it was first published in the original German. Friedrich Ludwig Gottlob Frege was born in Germany in 1848. He got his doctoral degree in Gttingen, and quickly wrote his post-doctoral thesis, and became a university professor. During his long and fruitful academic career, the tireless Frege worked extensively to build up the philosophical foundations of mathematics and science. Among his important contributions is the invention of an artificial language called Begriffsschrift, which was based on logical notation (Frege Biography). Frege wrote extensively, publishing a number of other influential papers during his lengthy career, including Grundgesetze der Arithmetik,...

Important in Frege's analysis is his rejection of the idea that logic is founded upon psychology. Instead, Frege effectively argues for the logicist proposal that arithmetic is founded on logic.
Frege's analysis focused on defining numbers using logical terms, but he also delved into broader questions of truth and meaning. Frege attempts to determine if the laws of arithmetic are synthetic or analytic, and whether these laws are a posteriori or a priori. He delves deeply into the concept of dumber, by beginning to determine sense of numerical identity. Ultimately, in The Foundations of Arithmetic, Frege argues that logic is based on psychology, and also notes that arithmetic is based on logic.

Originally published in German as Die Grundlagen der Arithmetik, The Foundations of Arithmetic is written in what is often a stilted and difficult style, making Frege's mostly lucid and innovative thoughts somewhat inaccessible to modern readers. For example, Frege notes,."..number is neither a collection of things nor a property of such, yet at the same time is not a subjective product of mental processes either, we concluded that a statement of number asserts something objective of a concept."

Important (in fact central) to The Foundations of Arithmetic is Frege's discussion of number. Frege's analysis of number is based on logic and context. Notes Frege, "We next laid down the fundamental principle that we must never try to define the meaning of a word in isolation, but only as it is used in the context of a proposition: only by adhering to this can we, as I believe, avoid a physical view of it."

Importantly, Frege argued…

Sources used in this document:
reference: the sense of the words determine the sense of the sentence; and the reference of the words determine the reference of the sentence."

In conclusion, Gottlob Frege's The Foundations of Arithmetic has made a lasting and influential contribution to the philosophy of mathematics. This book is essential reading for anyone interested in the philosophy of mathematics, and is also invaluable for anyone interested in the broader field of analytical psychology. The Foundations of Arithmetic provides a convincing argument that logic is the basis of arithmetic, rather than psychology, and also makes the important argument that analytic judgments govern the laws of arithmetic, and thus these laws exist a priori. It was in these discussions that Frege likely made his greatest contributions to the philosophy of mathematics. Despite his great critical success and long-lasting influence, Frege's works were not without their weaknesses. Importantly, many psychological terms within The Foundations of Arithmetic are not thoroughly defined, and critics have argued that Frege occasionally twisted definitions in order to suit his purposes. These serious criticisms are tempered by Frege's willingness to address these oversights within his texts. Despite these criticisms, The Foundations of Mathematics remains an influential book that is worthy of the great praise that has been heaped on it in the years since its publication nearly a hundred years ago.

References

Barbosa, Rosario. A Must for Any Philosopher of Mathematics, September 23, 2000. Amazon.com Reviews. 24 November 2003. www.Amazon.com

Frege Biography. Friedrich Ludwig Gottlob Frege. 24 November 2003. http://www.findlink.dk/frege/frege.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Benefits, Role and Criticisms of Labor Unions
Words: 3319 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Role of Labor Unions in Industrial Relations In their definition, labor unions have always been known as organizations that have always aimed at getting their members both financial and non-financial benefits. The role of labor unions is however bigger than that and they have been known to aid in helping employers improve the productivity and discipline of their workers. Labor unions respond to issues differently. This is explained by the differences

Book of Job
Words: 1490 Length: 5 Document Type: Book Review

Book of Job There is a fair amount of controversy surrounding the book of Job along with various controversies about who wrote it. Some scholars maintain that Job did live in the time of Moses, and that the book was written by him; others disagree and maintain that the book was written by Elihu or Isaiah. Since so much of the book focuses on the idea of "wisdom" and comparable

Book of Job and the Questions of
Words: 1780 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Book Of Job and the Questions of Suffering The Book of Job and the Question of Suffering The religions of the ancient near East were mostly polytheistic. Its history spans more than two millennia, from the Bronze Age to the early Iron Age. There are various sub-religions that make up these religions of the ancient near east they include; Assyro-Babylonian religion, Canaanite religion, Egyptian religion, Minoan religion and many more. These religions

Foundation Comparison: Burj Khalifa Vs. Taipei 101
Words: 1914 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Foundation Comparison: Burj Khalifa vs. Taipei 101 This report aims at assessing the foundation of the world's tallest and second tallest skyscrapers; the Burj Khalifa Tower in Dubai and Taipei 101 in Taipei, Taiwan. Currently, Burj Khalifa is the world's tallest building taking over the title from Taipei 101 topping out at a height of 828 metres. Khalifa is built on silty sand and sandstones while Taipei 101, with a

Foundations; Compare Meiji Restoration Founding German Reich.
Words: 1458 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Foundations; Compare Meiji Restoration founding German Reich. Identify similarities differences origin nature events. Refer social groups involved nature wrought social political structures created. The Meiji Restoration and the German Reich The Meiji Restoration Period is relatively similar to the founding of the German Reich when considering the fact that both eras brought significant reform in these countries and made it possible for them to experience great technological advancements as a consequence.

Algebra Lesson Plans and Curriculum for the
Words: 2991 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Algebra Lesson Plans and Curriculum for the 7th Grade Classroom The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) provides a comprehensive set of principles and standards for developing curriculum for grades K. through 12th. Chapter two of their text Principles and Standards for School Mathematics specifies the six principles considered vital for the development of a coherent math plan. The principles are general enough to apply across a wide variety

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now