Verified Document

Freedom And Human Action Essay

Free Will A friend of mine has just offered to give me a well-written paper that he wrote for a philosophy class. It just so happens that the paper topic is just like the one I have been assigned in my philosophy class. His paper got an "A," and I know that he has not sold this paper or posted it on his blog. The chances of my being caught, therefore, are nil. Moreover, I am very busy and because I am distracted, it is unlikely I will do a very good job on my philosophy paper. If I turn my friend's paper in as my own, I will get a good grade without doing much work. I still took the class; I am still learning. This would just alleviate my stress.

However, after some deliberation I decide that I will write my own paper. I was tempted, but I resisted. The reason for my decision is not based on fear (I knew there was no way I would get caught because my friend goes to a different school). I just want to do what is right, because I believe in karma. I want to do good, and to be an ethical person. Therefore, I resist temptation.

In this paper, which I did write myself, I will outline the views of d'Holbach and Frankfurt. I will hopefully show what each of these two philosophers would have said about my "Potential Cheater" situation. The framework for viewing the Potential Cheater is therefore not based on ethics, so much as it is based on the nature of determinism vs. free will.

After outlining d'Holbach's and Frankfurt's respective views on free will vs. determinism, I will provide an evaluation of their respective reasoning. In particular, I will argue that Frankfurt's view is more plausible than d'Holbach's view because d'Holbach's hard determinism is too restrictive. Hard determinism and d'Holbach's view does not accurately reflect the complexity of the human experience. This would be my main objection to hard determinism, regardless...

Imagining that I am d'Holbach, I will state my defense. While acknowledging that d'Holbach has a case, I will say that his point-of-view only has an internal logic, which cannot be applied to the real world. For this reason, d'Holbach's view does not succeed in getting around my main objection to hard determinism.
Part II: d'Holbach

Baron d'Holbach was a hard determinist, meaning he completely disavowed the potential for human beings to have any free will in any situation. D'Holbach believed absolutely and immutably in a deterministic universe. The universe and the laws of nature, which are immutable, have predetermined all of my thoughts, emotions, and actions. D'Holbach would argue that I was pre-wired somehow to resist temptation to cheat. The philosopher would also have argued that my friend's offer was also written in the stars, and that he was predetermined to make the offer to me. Every variable of the Potential Cheater situation, from the school that I attend and the classes that I take, are all predetermined. My instincts, inclinations, and interests are all predetermined, and I am just acting everything out according to a grand plan. When I resisted temptation to use my friend's paper in philosophy class, I was not acting as I thought out of moral goodness. I deserve no praise for my actions, because I did not actually do anything. I simply followed my instinct. What I did by resisting the cheating is no different than an alligator suddenly chomping down on a baby.

Part III: Frankfurt

Harry Frankfurt is a compatibilist, meaning that he believes free will and determinism are compatible philosophical concepts. Like determinists, Frankfurt believes that there are certain things over…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Human Freedom the Idea of Human Freedom
Words: 908 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Human Freedom The idea of human freedom transcends the spectrum of most subjects worthy of academic discussion. The purpose of this essay is to investigate, describe and discuss the concept of human freedom as it specifically relates to sociology and the social landscape. In order to accomplish this I will highlight some of aspects of human freedom to demonstrate the complexity and necessity of understanding this ideal. Political, religious and economic

Freedom and Responsibility: An Ethical
Words: 2111 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

Science has become a dominant facet of modern society and has to a large extent replaced the guiding role of religion. Therefore, science has a great responsibility to ensure that research freedom is not irresponsibly applied. This has resulted in numerous debates on subjects such as science and the environment and modern cloning. This in turn has raised the question whether scientific freedom is always ethical. There is a

Freedoms Should Be Allowed That
Words: 987 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Look at any communist regime in the last 100 years, where religion is considered an opiate of the masses. The government becomes god in that circumstance, and can get away with anything, including mass genocide (the Origin of Rights - posted on." True freedom should be given to individuals who do not harm other members of society. One classic example of a lack of freedom that does not make sense is

Freedom What Is Freedom Freedom
Words: 1815 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

" Western world it appears is slightly alienated from the spiritual world that most people in the east like Hindus take for granted. For an average person in the West, physical and material world is the only world and spirit is only an illusion. For those in the east, like Hindus, physical world is the illusion and spirit is the only truth there is. Western social, political and economic systems play an

Humans Have Wondered About Certain
Words: 2625 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

This object, though, sets in human consciousness in many divergent ways -- perception, memory, retention, etc. Depending on the manner in which the idea is intentional, the object may be identical but interpreted different and thus a divergent sense of reality for individuals. Opposite of Descartes and Kant, there is no one finite way of describing this object and it is entirely dependent upon the method of reduction and

Human Rights and Child Prostitution in Haiti
Words: 6002 Length: 20 Document Type: Essay

Human Rights and Child Prostitution in Haiti The Republic of Haiti is a Caribbean country occupying smaller portion of Hispaniola Island. It shares the island with Dominican which is equally another Caribbean country with population of just over 600, 000. In 2011, the population of the Republic of Haiti hit 9 million-mark with chances of a tremendous growth projected in the subsequent years. With the capital located at Port-au-Prince, the country's

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now