Verified Document

Federalism And Social Security Essay

Federal Social Security is one of the strongest federal social welfare programs in the United States. Initiated as part of Franklin Delano Roosevelt's New Deal, Social Security kick-started a revolution in federalism that characterized the twentieth century. Prior to New Deal reforms, federal powers were kept largely in check. Social Security was, and still is, challenged on constitutional grounds because of the way its parameters allow for a strong federal government. Social Security raises issues of federalism, in its use of federal resources, funding and power. Moreover, Social Security precludes states from opting out. This essay will analyze the overall effectiveness of Social Security, as determined by the overall goal of the policy in promoting social welfare. The thesis is that in spite of some weaknesses and presumptions, Social Security remains consistent with the constitutional framework of federalism.

When President Roosevelt backed Social Security, the policy was a direct response to the Great Depression. Yet Social Security remained an integral part of America's social welfare program, which was previously nonexistent. A staunch affirmation of states' rights had previously precluded American presidents from considering a move as radical as federalized social insurance. However, the new global realities and two world wars at the start of the millennium signaled a need for a stronger national identity as well as a more robust national government. Social Security met with some resistance, but it...

Since 1937, the United States Supreme Court has consistently permitted federalism to permeate domestic policy. As Katz (1997) puts it, the courts have "allowed the national government to define the reach of its authority for itself," (p. 1).
Social Security can generally be considered effective in terms of its fulfilling its main duty of helping senior citizens, and in terms of its fulfilling the broader goal of promoting greater quality of life based on the fact that providing social insurance would reduce the burden of unemployed seniors on the economy overall. Because payroll contributions form the fiscal foundation of Social Security, it was relatively simple to frame Social Security not as a means by which to redistribute wealth, but a means for individual Americans to contribute to their own retirement fund. Thus, Social Security was effective in calming fears of America becoming socialist. Such fears have plagued the American psyche since even before Roosevelt was president and continue to haunt the nation today as it contemplates the validity of providing universal health care coverage to its citizens.

Moreover, Social Security can be considered effective because there are greater numbers of senior citizens in America than ever before. Roosevelt might not have foreseen this social phenomenon, but clearly it would be inconceivable to have a generation of seniors who are living longer and…

Sources used in this document:
References

Jeffrey, T.P. (2011). Authors of social security believed it was unconstitutional. Retrieved online: http://cnsnews.com/blog/terence-p-jeffrey/authors-social-security-believed-it-was-unconstitutional

Katz, E. (1997). American federalism, past, present, future. Retrieved online: http://www.ucs.louisiana.edu/~ras2777/amgov/federalism.html

Norton, G. (2011). Breaking: Supreme Court rules Social Security is constitutional. Daily KOS. Retrieved online: http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/08/29/1011367/-Breaking-Supreme-Court-Rules-Social-Security-Is-Constitutional
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Stress: The Social Security Administration
Words: 1586 Length: 5 Document Type: Book Report

115). Congress certainly has the sole right to enact the legislation with which administrative agencies must comply. Moreover, the Congress has an oversight function, and it can and does react when people respond negatively to administrative actions, as occurred in the SSI and disability review examples (Derthick, p.153). Of course, the Court system is the major overseer in the United States. Derthick maintains that courts and administrative agencies perform sufficiently

Federalism in U.S. History the Word Federal
Words: 580 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Federalism in U.S. History The word federal denotes alliances between independent sovereignties. "The Oxford Guide to the U.S. Government," an important source for any student or teacher of history, describes federalism in the United States as "the division of governmental powers between the national and state governments." "The Oxford Guide" informs us that "state governments can neither ignore nor contradict federal statutes that conform to the supreme law, the Constitution."

Federalism the Tenth Amendment of the U.S.
Words: 727 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Federalism The Tenth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution provides that "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people." (U.S. Constitution, Tenth Amendment) This is interpreted to mean that the states have implied powers in addition to the powers explicitly enumerated to them in the Constitution. (Gardbaum 1996, 1252) Thus, the Tenth

Impact of Federalism on Privacy Rights
Words: 1290 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Federalism and Constitutional Debates One of the most significant and innovative ideas in the American Constitution is federalism even though the word does not appear in it. This concept entails sharing of power between two different levels of government i.e. federal and state governments. Through this system of government, power from the central government is shared to state governments. While federalism has existed in the United States for centuries, there are

The History of American Social Welfare
Words: 1457 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

United States is a country of settlers, anti-immigrant sentiment has permeated public discourse and is damaging the social fabric of the nation. Early anti-immigrant sentiment is symbolized most powerfully by the Nativist movement, which closely resembled white supremacy (Committee on US-Latin American Relations, 2014). What fueled anti-immigrant sentiment included fears of losing jobs and other conflict theory perspectives showing how immigrants are perceived of as threats to the existing social

Analytical Case Study of Federalism Port Arthur Massacre and Firearms...
Words: 2798 Length: 9 Document Type: Case Study

Gun Violence in Australia & its impact on federalism & coordinated gun control policy. Gun violence yielding en masse public murders in Australia have provoked the question of whether laws governing guns are too lenient or perhaps have enabled the dangers arising from unregistered firearms. The role of federalism has begged the question of whether more jurisdictional authority is needed by one of the provincial levels of Australian government. First however,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now