Verified Document

Famine, Affluence, Morality Peter Singer's Principle Goal Essay

Famine, Affluence, Morality Peter Singer's principle goal of "Famine, Affluence and Morality" is to get members of society to alter their contemporary conceptions of morality. His primary means of achieving this goal is to get people to rethink the notion of giving charity to those in need. He utilizes the 1971 destitution of people in Bengal as a case study in which he urges the affluent to change their view of morality so that they donate money and time to help the indigent. The author's assumption is that by getting people to understand the moral obligation in helping those in need, such as those in Bengali who have been ravaged by "Constant poverty, a cyclone, and civil war" (Singer, 1971, p.229), he will effectively change the way people consider moral situations. This change in their thinking will then influence their propensity for aiding other people in other situations outside of Bengal, and will supposedly make the world a better place in which wealth serves more utility than the facilitation of luxury.

Essentially, then, Singer is advocating that people use their wealth to support and aid others, so long as in doing so they are not doing anything else bad or failing to support themselves and their families. The author takes the liberty of posing a number of counterarguments to his viewpoint and readily disproving them all. The Bengali case study takes prominence in nearly all of his counterarguments. For instance, one such counterargument contends that distance is a factor in deciding who should provide...

Yet Singer readily disputes this contention by positing that, from a moral perspective, distance does not matter. The only thing that matters (morally) is saving lives, whether such lives are across the street or located near India. The author believes that it is not morally defensible to waste money on matters of luxury when that same money could provide food to starving people regardless of where such people are located.
Another common counterargument for the reinforced sense of morality that Singer offers is that the number of people who are willing to help negates individual responsibility. This type of logic adheres to the fact that if someone were hit by a car in the middle of Times Square, with hundreds or thousands of people watching there is less personal responsibility for people individually. However, the author dispels this notion by stating that "the fact that there are millions of other people in the same position…does not make the situation significantly different from a situation in which I am the only person" (232) who can help someone. This concept readily ties into the author's point about marginal utility. Marginal utility is the concept that giving a considerable amount of aid may negate a person's ability to take care of himself and his family. It can be used to dispute "any utilitarian or consequentialist ethic" (singer, 1991, p. 625). There is little use in an action that is part of marginal utility. People tend to think that if they give more than the next person…

Sources used in this document:
References

Singer, P. (1991). "A refutation of ordinary morality." Ethics. 101 (3): 625-633.

Singer, P. (1972). "Famine, affluence and morality." Philosophy & Public Affairs. 1 (3): 229-243.

Singer, P. (2007). "Review essay on the moral demands of affluence." Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. 75 (2): 475-483.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Peter Singer
Words: 1826 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Universal Consequentialism as a Means of Assessing Global Situations Poverty in developing countries is a significant moral issue. In terms of moral frameworks, a universal form of consequentialism most accurately assesses the (in)justice of such poverty and global situations of a similar scope. Specifically, universal consequentialism with an emphasis on equal consideration -- the belief that "benefits to one person matter just as much as similar benefits to any other person"

Human Rights and Poverty
Words: 1262 Length: 3 Document Type:

Moral Obligation to Help Reduce World Poverty There is little doubt that global poverty is a significant issue, creating hardship and suffering for many people. The statistics are astounding; every day 34,000 children under the age of five years die due to poverty, this equates to 11 million children a year (Eskelinen 11). Furthermore, 1,000 million people lack access to clean drinking water (Ord 178), and 2,000 million people lack

Nthe Effectiveness of Human Rights
Words: 1570 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Also, the death penalty still in use in a great deal of countries might provide another subject for debate from the point-of-view of human rights. A minimalist set of human rights, meant only to keep people safe from humiliation and pain cannot be effective. This is mainly because while certain human rights seem to be of little necessity, they are actually indispensable. Economic, civil, and political rights are of great

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now