Verified Document

Ethics The Divine Command Theory Of Morality Term Paper

Ethics The Divine Command theory of morality is known as a nonconsequentialist theory because this particular theory of morality is one that is not in any way based on the consequences or outcomes of specific action, but rather holds that all actions have any intrinsic rightness or wrongness. In the case of Divine Command Theory, rightness or wrongness is decided based upon whether or not a specific action can be said to be in accordance with the dictates of God. Indeed, while there are advantages to this idea of morality, such as the more simple categorization of actions into a dichotomy of what is permitted, there are also many sever disadvantages, as well. These disadvantages can make the view difficult to entertain. For example, one of the main issues depends on the source of the divine command. If the divine moral commands come out of scripture, for example, how can on be certain that one is following the scripture exactly and how can one be certain that the scripture has been interpreted and (in the cases of many religious scriptures) translated correctly. Secondly, given that there are a great number of religious scriptures that all purport to be the actual and revealed word of God, how can one be certain that one is following the correct scripture? Moreover, how can one reconcile the conflicting claims of these different texts, or (in many cases) the conflicting moral imperatives of a given scripture. Of course, there is even another serious difficulty with this possibility.

One other such difficulty...

For example, let's consider the Biblical story of Abraham and Isaac. In this story, God commands Abraham to take his child out to the woods and to sacrifice him. Despite the fact that Isaac was his most beloved son he takes him out and is prepared to sacrifice him when, at the last possible second, God stops him from slaughtering son and instead produces a ram that is to be used for the purposes of ritual sacrifice. Thus, what we see here is that if we use the divine command theory as the basis for a system of ethics then it is possible that one undertakes an action that must be considered "inherently good" because it conforms to the will of God, but which is clearly moral evil. In the above story, while Abraham does prove his loyalty to God he only does so at the near-expense of his child's life. Such an ethical system seems difficult to condone and practice if it does not rule out the undertaking of events that seem cruel and ruthless, whether or not they are the divine commands of a God or Gods. Along with the above considered argument of the proliferation of scriptures and scriptural materials, this argument suggests that, though the divine command argument does allow for a simplicity in terms of creating a black-and-white codification of things, it also possesses several severe problems that considerably undermine it as a reasonable ethical system. Thus, while there are some benefits to adhering to this view, as the Abraham story reveals, holding to a…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Divine Command Theory
Words: 1031 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Ethics On the surface, both ethical relativism and ethical egotism are appealing theories. The ethical relativist avoids many of the problems that arise from encounters with different moral codes, and can help to eliminate some of the culture clashes and social problems inherent in the human condition. For example, when many Westerners come into contact with Middle Eastern cultures such as that of Saudi Arabia, they are tempted to pass judgment

Ethics in a Computerized Society
Words: 2132 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

This may be done without the consent of the owner of the information thus also infringing on their right to privacy. Education has also been revolutionized greatly by technology. As a result of technological advancements it is now possible for teachers and students to communicate over thousands of miles. Instructors are also able to give assignments which students can submit despite the distance. In this way, technology has enabled global

Morals and Ethical Theory
Words: 1803 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Morals and Ethical Theory Morals & Ethical Theory The objective of this study is to read pages 1 -- 26 of Stephen D. Hales work entitled "This Is Philosophy" and to answer the questions of: (1) Is morality just what God tells me to do? (Divine Command Theory); (2) Is morality just my own personal code? (Egoism); and (3) Is morality just how society says we should act? (Moral Relativism) This study will state

Relativity of Moral Truth
Words: 649 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Relativity of Moral Truth The viewpoints on moral truth are varied within circles of philosophic thought. Moral ethics are, for the most part, relative, though on what grounds of relative truth is a subject of much discussion. Three positions will be discussed in this paper: the topic of the Divine Command Theory, Ruth Benedict's beliefs in cultural relativism, and Thomas Nagel's morality of rational consistency. Of the three, Nagel's relative moral

Religion, Libertarianism and Virtue Ethics Religion Is
Words: 1113 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Religion, Libertarianism and Virtue Ethics Religion is a social institution, which grows out of individuals' collective attempt to structure and understand the university (McGonigal, 2012). It is a natural consequence of human behavior and social groups. It endeavors to explain occurrences and social inequalities. In so doing, religion tends to justify inequalities, thus, provides a foundation for religious identification, which often breeds social conflict (McGonigal). Libertarianism is a political philosophy, which claims

Occupy Wall Street Moral Implications Economic Implications
Words: 2106 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Occupy Wall Street Moral Implications Economic Implications Utilitarianism Kantian Ethics Virtue Ethics CRITICAL ANALYSIS BIBIOGRAPHY Occupy Wall Street is about moral and economic vision; it is not about policy demands. Therefore we cannot ask for certain yes and cannot compromise on the other because all moral, social, economical and behavioral values are interlinked and if one is detached then the whole chain comes in broken pieces. All we need in to publicize our internal and external issues in

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now