Booker Prize-winning novel Amsterdam by Ian Mcewan is not really about euthanasia per se; it is about the twisted relationships between the two main characters, Clive Linley, composer, and Vernon Halliday, newspaper editor. Deeply affected by the death of their mutual friend and lover Molly Lane, Clive and Vernon agree that if they should ever exhibit the symptoms of some deadly illness, that they agree to assist the other in euthanasia. Thus, the two friends initially start out by presenting a view of euthanasia that is strongly ethical; euthanasia is a meaningful and sometimes even necessary means to alleviate unnecessary suffering. After all, life is already filled with enough suffering. Extension of life by a matter of days, weeks, or even years does not necessarily equate with promoting the values inherent to a good quality of life.
As the events of the novel progress, however, Vernon and Clive demonstrate that their ethical reasoning is not as cogent as it appeared at the onset. Vernon and Clive reveal their ethical egoism, particularly in Vernon's wish to destroy Julian Garmony's career and in Clive's having a bystander effect problem. After a heated argument in which each one presumes moral superiority over his friend, Clive and Vernon turn their euthanasia compact into a means of murder. Doing so totally twists and distorts the meaning of euthanasia, and its less-likely-to-be-abused cousin, physician-assisted suicide. Mcewan therefore presents multiple points-of-view regarding euthanasia without offering a truly deep ethical analysis of how the practice can realistically go awry. The situation between Vernon and Clive is hyperbolic and for dramatic effect.
Therefore, Amsterdam shows more about its caddish, conniving characters than it does about the ethics of euthanasia. It is not the law itself but how it is used that is the issue, which is precisely why regulations are in place for when patients invoke their right to die with dignity. Sure, Vernon and Clive abuse their privileges, but in reality, the outcome of the story could scarce have happened in real life. Real euthanasia laws tend to avoid the kinds of problems that allow Vernon and Clive to carry out their nefarious schemes. Still, Mcewan builds tension delightfully, and showcases the egoism, harsh utilitarianism, and
Mcewan does not actually make a case one way or another for or against euthanasia. He shows how, using the example of Molly, physician-assisted suicide could have minimized her suffering and that this is precisely why physician-assisted death should be legal as it is in the Netherlands. At the same time, Mcewan shows how physician-assisted death can be abused -- if it is used in a coercive way, to replace patient autonomy, or in any way to violate ethical precepts. Ultimately, the reader comes away with a great sense of personal responsibility. If people are to be entrusted with the right to choose their manner of death, then when and how can the system delimit that right? The broader question is how to prevent abuses of power, not to take away the right of a person like Molly to die with dignity.
The euthanasia pact is a darkly humorous interjection into the debate. It has no legal bearing. Their plot could never reasonably be carried out the way it occurs in the novel; euthanasia is not designed to be a method of homicide. What Vernon and Clive do is simply order a hit on each other; that is hardly euthanasia and reading too much into the euthanasia theme would be doing a great disservice to the public health and bioethics committees that have worked so hard to have physician-assisted death made legal in countries like the Netherlands and Canada.
The faulty, self-righteous, egoistic ethics of…
Ethical Issues Surrounding Abortion Notwithstanding the laws being passed in various states against a woman's right to chose to terminate her pregnancy, the position of this paper is that Roe v. Wade is the law of the land and a woman has the ethical and moral right to decide to have an abortion. There are many positions for and against Roe v. Wade, and there are many ethical issues that may
Ethical Issue in the Medical Field Nurse practitioners at just about all levels and fields of practice encounter a variety of ethical problems throughout the span of their daily operations. In the preceding 30 years there has surfaced a remarkable global grant on nursing ethics providing complete philosophic evaluations involving the types of problems nurse practitioners encounter and also the procedures that may be best utilized for coping with them. The
Ethical Issues of Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia The ethical issues relating to assisted suicide and euthanasia have captured the attention of the public. The topic of Euthanasia is a contentious one and it inescapably incites strong emotional argument and gives rise to tough beliefs that do not straight away lend themselves to consensual harmony. It is improbable that a decision can be reached which will meet with universal support whenever such
As the narrow policy discussions regarding Physician-Assisted Suicide continue, we ought to encourage all presently existing and legal methods of reducing the painful sufferings during the last phase of life. References Drickamer, Margaret, a; Lee, Melinda. a; Ganzini, Linda. (1997, Jan 15) "Practical Issues in Physician-Assisted Suicide" Annals of Internal Medicine, vol. 126, no. 2, pp: 146-151. Emauel, Ezekiel. (1997, Mar) "Whose right to die?" The Atlantic Monthly, vol. 17, no. 2,
Ethical Issues in Healthcare Euthanasia Euthanasia is also termed as 'mercy killing', involves concluding the existence of a terminally ill patient on deathbed due to a life-threatening illness. In essence, another individual decides to conclude the existence of the patient by multiple methods, such as using a lethal dosage of injection. The patients can choose euthanasia (voluntary), reject using euthanasia (involuntary), or could be unable to response, depending on their neural function.
Legal and Ethical Issues in Healthcare Healthcare ethics have to do with the wide range of moral decisions that have to be made in medical practice. These are the other considerations that have to be made besides the regular policies and procedures designed for effective medical practice. Of the various aspects of the human body and life, none is as important as health. Technological advancements in the practice of medicine and
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now