Verified Document

English Only Legislation Is 'English Term Paper

Language continually reminds one (or not), and underscores and reinforces (or not) one's roots, identity, and authentic self. That is, I believe, the real reluctance of those who would cling, too stubbornly, it has been argued by Hayakawa and others, to their first, original tongue. That is also why much of the intimacy, energy, comfortableness, and fun instantly evaporated from the Rodriguez family atmosphere the afternoon one of Richard's teachers suggested to the children's parents that the family speak more English, and less Spanish, at home. Along with one's language of birth (whatever it is) come feelings of being understood and accepted; and from those spring a sense of one's own selfhood and identity. In my opinion, that is the main, underlying, reason why 'English Only' Legislation is not a particularly practical solution to multilingualism in the United States (if multilingualism needs a "solution"). This is not because such legislation (admittedly) might not have certain public benefits, such as everyone' speaking and understanding one another in one way. It is, instead, because language, especially one's first, whatever it is, is like the tip of a huge iceberg, beneath which lie identity; cultural heritage, first loyalties, and sense of belonging.

Therefore, to mandate 'English Only' in public is, in effect, to mandate 'mainstream American' only (whatever that now is) at least in public. But even in public, one can still truly only be who one is, however fluently - or haltingly. Therefore, passing 'English Only' legislation, at the federal, state, or any level, would not actually decrease multilingualism. Instead, it would merely drive it 'underground', effectively making publicly 'banished' languages (e.g., Spanish; Vietnamese; Japanese, and many others) all the more cherished (and defiantly spoken whenever and wherever possible) by...

Perhaps, back then, there was simply more to look forward to in assimilating, and, maybe even more importantly, more of a mainstream culture to which everyone wished to belong, and thought they could belong, with English language being the ticket in. Perhaps also, in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, people in America felt more collectively bonded. In World War II, for example, almost every American of whatever background rallied around the flag to defeat our enemies abroad. That has not happened in any war since.
It is my own belief, then, that 'English Only' legislation is a band-aid solution (if even that). Somewhere along the way, America has lost its soul. We need to find ways to get our soul back, If we can, somehow, do that, it may well also be the case that everyone in America will once again want to speak English - publicly; privately; and as a symbolic expression of a way of life they once feel a part of - and personally cherish.

Works Cited

Crawford, James. "Introduction." Language Loyalties: A Source Book on the Official English Controversy. James Crawford (Ed.). Chicago, Ill.: University of Chicago Press, 1992. 1.

Hayakawa, S.I. "The Case for Official English." In A Meeting of Minds: A Brief Rhetoric for Writers and Readers. Patsy Callaghan and Ann Dobyns

Eds.). New York: Pearson Longman, 2004. 446-452.

Headden, Susan, et al. "One Nation One Language: Only English Spoken

Here." In A Meeting of Minds: A Brief Rhetoric for Writers and Readers.

Patsy Callaghan and Ann Dobyns (Eds.). New York: Pearson Longman, 2004. 452-456.

King, Robert D. "Should English Be Law?" In A Meeting of Minds: A Brief

Rhetoric for Writers and Readers. Patsy Callaghan and Ann Dobyns

Eds.). New York: Pearson Longman, 2004. 456-465.

Rodriguez, Richard. "Public and Private Language." In A Meeting of Minds: A Brief Rhetoric for Writers and Readers. Patsy Callaghan and Ann Dobyns

Eds.). New York: Pearson Longman, 2004. 438-446.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Crawford, James. "Introduction." Language Loyalties: A Source Book on the Official English Controversy. James Crawford (Ed.). Chicago, Ill.: University of Chicago Press, 1992. 1.

Hayakawa, S.I. "The Case for Official English." In A Meeting of Minds: A Brief Rhetoric for Writers and Readers. Patsy Callaghan and Ann Dobyns

Eds.). New York: Pearson Longman, 2004. 446-452.

Headden, Susan, et al. "One Nation One Language: Only English Spoken
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

English Legal System the Sources
Words: 1401 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

The Da Costa ruling, however, determined that any ruling of the European Court of Justice must necessarily apply to all national courts when interpreting Community Law (Craig 2001). In this way, the law is guaranteed to be applied evenly in and in the same manner in all member nation courts when deciding Community Law issues, whereas prior to this ruling differing interpretations of the same facets of Community Law

English Literature - Satire Proposal
Words: 840 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

First and foremost, the doctrine of separation of powers handicaps the Executive Branch from maintaining the confidentiality and security of decisions during wartime as well as decisions in postwar and pre-wartime planning in connection with subsequent wars initiated, by necessity, in the timely and efficient response to the global War on Terror throughout the next decade, at least. Understood in relation to the magnitude of the threat to this nation

English Only Education State Laws
Words: 872 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Proposal

Whereas California law requires instruction to take place in English except for the immersion classrooms, Colorado only provides a funding limitation for non- and limited-English speakers that expires after two years (Colorado Statute 22-24-104). That is, a student may receive instruction in languages other than English for longer than two years, but no institution, district, or facility will receive state funding for that student after the two-year period until

English Only Policy
Words: 1336 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

English Only Policy is an issue of hot debate throughout the country. Many states have passed "English Only" laws, and more still are considering. Although opponents list several reasons for their position, the proponents of the policy by far present the most logical causes. Bilingualism is a hindrance to learning English and a detriment to a child's short-term and long-term academic advancement, therefore it should be the only medium of instruction

Legislation of Foreign Nurses Practicing in the United States
Words: 2042 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Legislation of Foreign Nurses Practicing in the United States The United States Health Care system is undergoing a major crisis of nurse-staffing shortage. A survey conducted by the American Hospital Association -- AHA of 715 hospitals performed during spring 2001 showed that a vacancy of 126,000 positions of registered nurses prevails through out the nation. The International Council of Nurses -- ICN, a federation of 125 nursing organizations indicated it to

Legislation on Foreign Nurses Practicing in the United States
Words: 1310 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Legislation Pertaining to Foreign Nurses Practicing in the United States Discuss the process that this legislation will go through, referencing the steps to the legislative and administrative process The Rural and Urban Health Care Act of 2001 (S 1259 and HR 2705) dramatically expanded the existing H-1C temporary nursing visa program established in 1999. Before, there were only three ways that foreign-educated nurses could get permission to enter the United States to

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now