Verified Document

Educational Research: Charter Schools Descriptive Vs. Experimental Term Paper

Educational Research: Charter Schools Descriptive vs. Experimental Research

Experimental research studies seem to be 'cleaner' on their surface than descriptive research studies. A researcher can, in experimental research studies, apparently control all extraneous external variables. He or she can simply focus on the variables that are being studied and analyzed over the course of the study. For instance, in the lengthy descriptive "Fourth-Year Report" conducted by the United States government in 2000 on Charter Schools, variables as diverse as the proportion of students on public assistance for their lunch, proficiency in English, income of families, income of the district, all had to be taken into consideration when analyzing the results of the comparison between public and private schools.

Because the multi-variable descriptive study comparing charter and public schools across the nation was quite broad in its demographic sweep it was difficult to extrapolate conclusive data from its findings. It analyzed overall school performances in their success at helping students pass proficiency exams, student retention, and grades. It also measured the schools against objective standards thought to indicate the schools were providing a better student education, such as student to faculty ratios. Economic and demographic differences between districts and schools were important in creating a picture within the context of the research...

It would be easy to compare an affluent public school with a poor charter school and conclude that the student to faculty ratio was of no bearing upon educational success, and that charter schools were not valuable to students. (Fourth Year Report, 2000)
The value of experimental research, upon reviewing such a sprawling study, one might contend was greater control and brevity of focus. No matter how many variables one took into consideration, others sprung into focus upon further analysis -- simply taking into consideration parent's economic situations might be enough, one might need to consider parental involvement, whether more parents were single or divorced, the youth of the parents, etc.

Too many uncontrolled demographic differences between charter and public schools were one of the criticisms levied against the most recent report of the Education Department's study of charter schools. The study did not take into consideration the greater poverty of many charter schools, for example. (Schermo, 2004) But using experimental research, such as comparing two classrooms created in isolation for the purpose of a study, while it may create more similar conditions in the 'laboratory' of the study, ultimately fails to take into the long-term nature of education. What works for a student in the short run may be less valuable than what works in the long run -- for example, the question is…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

"Fourth-Year Report: 2000." (January 2000) U.S. Government Website. Retrieved 15 Jan 2005 at http://www.ed.gov/pubs/charter4thyear/b3.html#4

Harvard University. (2004) "Harvard University and National Bureau of Economic Research: Achievement in Charter Schools and Regular Public Schools in the United States: December 2004. Charter Schools Website. Retrieved 15 Jan 2005 at http://www.wacharterschools.org/learn/index_studies.htm

Schemo, Jean. (Aug 17, 2004) "Charter Schools Trail in Results: U.S. Data Reveals." New York Times. Section A1. Retrieved 15 Jan 2005 at http://www.nytimes.com/2004/08/17/education/17charter.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Action Research on the Impact of Video
Words: 2494 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Action Research on the Impact of Video Technology Classrooms on Student Achievement Audio-Visual Technology & Student Achievement Research problem / topic. The proposed research study will examine the impact of integrating video technology in classroom lessons on the achievement of students. In this study, consideration will also be given to students' perceptions of the impact of integrated video on their achievement and gender-based differences in achievement related to the integration of video

Public School System in America
Words: 3272 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

However a poll take in 1994 by the Wall Street Journal found that 28% of Americans would prefer to have their own children homeschooled (Houston & Toma 2003). The authors further explain that the increased number of children being home schooled has created issues associated with truancy laws and in some cases been the catalyst for the passing of new laws. In fact 35 states have created new legislation related

Social Science Research Are Qualitative and Quantitative
Words: 4883 Length: 16 Document Type: Essay

social science research are qualitative and quantitative research methods. Qualitative research is believed to operate from a subjective, constructionist view of reality, whereas quantitative research operates from an objective, positivist viewpoint of the world. There has been quite a bit of debate over the merits of each of these approaches, often with one paradigm belittling the assumptions of the other. The current literature review explores the philosophical foundations of

Single Sex Education
Words: 3042 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

graduating high school student enters college he or she is perceived to be a young responsible adult in thought and action. However, the college environment is one in which there exists no curfews, parents, or other restrictive elements to curtail an individual's activities and decisions. As such it is important that those students arriving at college have the necessary maturity and life experience background to receive and enjoy an

Framework for Implementing the Z. Mathematical Model to a Six Grade...
Words: 12060 Length: 30 Document Type: Term Paper

positive outcome in the educational progress for the students resulting from applying the Z. Model framework. In Mr. Zander's classroom, the average improvement in test scores is 16.75 points. The is the rise in test scores resulting from the students taking the same standardize test, once at the beginning of the school year, and a second time after 6-7 months Z. Model application. The baseline group data was taken form

Scholarly Journal Articles on Place Based Education
Words: 2687 Length: 10 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Graham, M. (2007). Art, ecology and art education: locating art education in a critical place-Based pedagogy. Studies in Art Education: A Journal of Issues and Research, 48(4): 375-391. This study situates place-based education in the context of critical pedagogy in order to provide a framework for art education with a focus on ecology. The study asserts that the local places are marginalized and undermined by the emphasis on consumption in the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now