Verified Document

Critical Thinking Analysis Of "Equality Term Paper

Apart from this fault in Okun's conceptual framework, this passage also failed to capture the readers' understanding because the author failed to provide specific cases and examples to prove his argument. Another problem in Okun's conceptualization of the equality-efficiency relationship is that he displayed lack of flexibility and open-mindedness in considering that the issue of rights as encompassing the economic sphere, and also includes the socio- political, cultural, and even historical roots from which human rights developed. This was evident when he claimed that "the domain of rights is full of infringements on the calculus of economic efficiency. Our rights can be viewed as inefficient..." (10). In this claim, Okun covered only one facet of the issue of rights, which is the economic aspect. There was no elaboration on the relationship of the economic sphere with the political, cultural, and historical roots of rights, as it relates to the individual and society. Establishing a relationship among these factors is crucial because this is not only inevitable, but a complete picture of rights (individual and collective) will provide readers a deeper understanding of the different dynamics surrounding the issue at hand.

Okun was also found to commit the fallacy of generalizing without sufficient support from data and secondary information. Chapter 2, wherein Okun cited economic policies implemented that were related to equality and efficiency, his claim on the issue of lobbying for specific...

By simply stating that there are "subtle dependencies" and "the wealthy can obtain undue political leverage," Okun failed to give clarity to these terms, and their relationship to the issue being discussed (27). In a similar manner, Okun failed to provide sufficient evidence to support his succeeding argument, which asserted that "Congress has realized that no single person speaks for the consumer" (29). This general statement did not have statistical data to prove this claim -- that indeed, a member or members of the Congress recognized this consumer problem.
Chapter three, which discussed the issue of income and equality of opportunity, featured the same fallacy of generalization committed in the previous chapters. In the statement, "[i]ncome and wealth are the two box-score numbers in the record book on people's economic positions," Okun had consistently shown a commitment to stating general statements without statistical evidence or data support (65). A similar fault in analysis was committed when he discussed the issue of income inequality. Lastly, specific instances that further made Okun's analysis ineffective and unconvincing was his use of 'loaded' statements and incorrect cause-and-effect relationship (i.e., pointing to unequal opportunity, unequal income and inefficiency as having the same relationship, when in fact inefficiency is the effect of two causes: unequal opportunity and unequal income) (77).

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Critical Thinking Political Cartoon Analysis
Words: 1417 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Cartoon Analysis An Analysis of Tom Toles' Gay Rights Cartoon Tom Toles' most recent cartoon for the Washington Post shows a wedding cake with -- instead of the traditional bride and groom figurines -- a groom and a groom, smiling and holding hands. One of the figurines is playing on the Sinatra tune, "New York, New York," saying, "If we can make it here…" suggesting that gay marriage can make it anywhere.

Shirley Chisholm an Analysis of the Life
Words: 2566 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Shirley Chisholm An Analysis of the Life and Work of Shirley Chisholm In light of the fact that black feminism has gained more of a voice in the last few decades it is important to remember the people who first brought the plight of the black woman, specifically, to the forefront of national public and political discourse. One of these women was Shirley Chisholm. She was the first black member of the

Stiglitz Analysis of the Price of Inequality
Words: 3113 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

Stiglitz Analysis of the Price of Inequality In the year 2013, issues of socioeconomic inequality are perhaps as pressing and problematic as they have ever been. This is the assertion at the crux of Joseph E. Stiglitz text, The Price of Inequality: How Today's Divided Society Endangers Our Future (ISBN-13: 9780393345063). Released in 2012 by W.W. Norton & Company publishers, the 560-page text is a timely and compelling contribution to the current

Signs of Safety Practice Model Critical Analysis
Words: 1761 Length: 7 Document Type: Article Review

Signs of Safety Practice Model Critical Analysis Practice Model Read Signs Safety text (Turnell, A. & Edwards, S. (1999). Signs safety: a solution safety oriented approach child protection. New York W.W. Norton. ) learn Signs Safety practice model, heavily relied Minnesota child welfare practice community. The Signs of Safety child protection practice model was adopted as a policy to create better outcomes for vulnerable children. The purpose of the model was to

Feminist Analysis of Dryden's Marriage
Words: 2348 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Adultery and any sort of infidelity turns out to be a different story for men as Rosenthal stresses: "prohibition against adultery is not about property, pregnancy, misdirected male desire, or bloodlines, as one might have thought, but about the prevention of female comparison" (Rosenthal, 2008) as sharing men would be established by the size of their sexual organs. A recurrent theme in the play from a gender perspective relates to

Training Needs Analysis Practices for Managers: A
Words: 17400 Length: 60 Document Type: Thesis

Training Needs Analysis Practices for Managers: A Study of Saudi Arabia Private Firms Training needs analysis (TNA) is defined by Mabey and Salman (1995:158) as a "process of collecting data which allows an organization to identify and compare its actual level with its desired level of performance." The authors also indicate that this performance could be interpreted as meaning the competencies and attitude necessary for the staff to do the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now