Verified Document

Criminal Justice - Systematic Problem Thesis

Equal Protection: Equal protection is a fundamental constitutional protection, that in modern times, guarantees the equal effect of law to all persons. In that regard, the Supreme Court has established specific suspect classes of individuals, such as membership in a minority race, whose rights to equal protection must be guarded most scrupulously, primarily because the need to do so has been more than adequately demonstrated by aspects of relatively recent American history.

According to criminologists and researchers who have conducted studies of the impact of criminal laws in general, and of capital punishment in particular, criminal defendants who are members of minority races (as well as those who are poor) are statistically much more likely to receive the death penalty in comparison with non- minority (and wealthier) criminals convicted of identical death-penalty-eligible offenses (Schmalleger, 2007; Zalman, 2008). This discrepancy suggests that capital punishment in the U.S. still violates one of the most basic constitutional principles, and therefore, constitutes a significant problem in contemporary American criminal justice administration. Wrongful Conviction:

The other major problem arising in connection with capital punishment as it is currently implemented within the American criminal justice system has come to light more recently, as a function of advances in definitive evidence analysis and identification techniques developed through applications of DNA-based science. Specifically, now that current technologies are being used to test evidence preserved from trials in which criminal defendants were sentenced to life imprisonment and death, dozens of inmates have been proven to have been wrongfully convicted on the basis of faulty evidence such as police error, erroneous witness testimony, and prosecutorial misconduct (Lancet, 2008; Zalman, 2008).

To date, there are no known instances where an innocent subject has been put to death after erroneous conviction, but that it only attributable to the fact that several states have abolished the death penalty since their conviction and because the procedural mechanisms of the...

To the extent that existing procedural safeguards against erroneous conviction have been demonstrated to be inadequate, the current form of death penalty laws are another serious problem in the American criminal justice system. The fact that those inadequacies are statistically more likely to affect racial minorities compounds that problem significantly.
Global Surveys and Benchmarking Best Practices Toward a Solution:

Today, capital punishment is being phased out of the laws of many modern nations, so much so that the United Nations (U.N.) has issued an official position opposing capital punishment on principle. Notwithstanding the fact that U.N. policy lacks the weight of binding legal authority, it serves as a benchmark for global social trends (Lancet, 2008). On the other hand, some of the same nations that have shifted away from the death penalty still sanction very harsh forms of criminal sanctions, including many that would constitute bona fide torture under any objective definition as well as under U.S. law, not to mention other civil rights violations incorporated into U.S. law.

The U.S. Constitution already prohibits violations of moral principles that give rise to the problems associated with capital punishment in the U.S. Therefore, the solution is not to re-evaluate the concept of capital punishment entirely, but rather, to legislate the necessary changes in criminal procedure to ensure that: (1) the methods of its implementation are capable of greater resistance to error; (2) all criminal defendants receive comparable legal representation and treatment; and (3) procedural rules and standards of proof are adjusted to reduce the possibility of error to an absolute minimum, particularly in capital cases.

References

Dershowitz, a. (2002). Shouting Fire: Civil Liberties in a Turbulent Age. New York: Bantam Books.

Friedman, a. (2005). A History of American Law. New York: Touchstone.

Kaveny, C. (2008). Justice or vengeance: is the death penalty cruel and unusual?

Commonwealth; Feb 18/08.

The Lancet (2008). "Death Knell for the Death Penalty: A healthy advance"; Jan 5-11.

Schmalleger, F. (2007). Criminal Justice Today: An Introductory Text for the 21st Century. Hoboken, NJ: Prentice Hall

Zalman, M. (2008). Criminal Procedure: Constitution and Society, Fifth Edition.

Princeton, NJ: Pearson.

Sources used in this document:
References

Dershowitz, a. (2002). Shouting Fire: Civil Liberties in a Turbulent Age. New York: Bantam Books.

Friedman, a. (2005). A History of American Law. New York: Touchstone.

Kaveny, C. (2008). Justice or vengeance: is the death penalty cruel and unusual?

Commonwealth; Feb 18/08.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Criminal Justice the Problem of How to
Words: 1234 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Criminal Justice The problem of how to treat and processing juvenile offenders through the court system has been an issue before the establishment of the first juvenile court in 1899. Before it was recognized that minors needed their own court system, they were processed through the adult court and often received harsh punishment. Separate juvenile courts became evident within all states by 1945. However, the juvenile court system was based upon

Corrections/Police - Criminal Justice Contemporary Problems Within...
Words: 952 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Corrections/Police - Criminal Justice Contemporary problems within the U.S. correctional system The rate of lock ups has greatly increased in America at a rate that is higher than most developed nations around the world. According to the human rights watch article, privately run services spiked up in the year 2000 due to the fact that federal prison systems were extremely overcrowded housing more prisoners than any other country in the world. The

Criminal Justice Trends the Trends of the
Words: 1924 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Criminal Justice Trends The trends of the past, present and future that outline the borders connecting the criminal justice system components and their links adjoining the society is, beyond doubt, an authentic relationship that the law and society have established. Criminal justice has been affected by various trends in the times gone by. This is because trends keep changing with the passage of time. Therefore, it is exceedingly important for the

Criminal Justice System Normally Refers to the
Words: 1488 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Criminal justice system normally refers to the compilation of the prevailing federal; state accompanied by the local public agencies those pacts with the crime problem. These corresponding agencies procedure suspects, defendants accompanied by the convicted offenders and are normally mutually dependent insofar as the prevailing decisions of the single agency influence other supplementary agencies (Cole & Smith, 2009). The fundamental framework of the underlying system is normally granted through the

Criminal Justice Policies Criminal Justice
Words: 2044 Length: 5 Document Type: Discussion Chapter

Other Implications If the issue of pant sagging is not addressed, it will lead to public dissatisfaction, especially from people who have raised concerns. It will also continue the implications on black men as being disrespectful gangsters, or as Cosby says (middle class blacks who are disrespected and despised gangsters, whose egregious behavior is sagging pants). It will also continue the implication that the black represent some unified community which is

Criminal Justice It It Is Becoming Very
Words: 1275 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Criminal Justice IT It is becoming very clear how much of an impact the newest technological advances have on the world. For example, consider how quickly the information spread via the social media about Osama bin Laden's death. Technology innovations are also greatly impacting the criminal justice system in the U.S. By providing significant improvements in the way that agencies find, process, share and utilize information. With the present speed of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now