Criminal Justice Response
Cesare Beccaria (1963) wrote that everyone possesses free will, a rational manner and a rational self-interest. This makes human action predictable and controllable, largely matters of personal choice. The task of the criminal justice system is to predict and control these deviant acts that people with freewill might do to satisfy their own personal pleasures.
A strong believer in the social contract, Beccaria believed that individuals exercised their freewill in deciding to commit crimes. Therefore, in addition to the criminal justice system, government should also create a system of laws and punishment, so that law-abiding citizens could "be defended against private usurpation by individuals" (Beccaria 1963: 43).
In this case, Beccaria would first of all look at how the crime could have been prevented. Bobby may have been feeling looked down upon by his peers, because he did not the requisite pair of tennis shoes. Educators or alert school counselors could have helped to shore up Bobby's self-esteem, so he would not have to covet the shoes so much. An alert parent or counselor could also intervene, not only in the teasing/bullying but also when Bobby started hanging out with the kind of kids who knew how to manipulate sliding glass doors. These methods of informal deterrence would help to prevent Bobby's criminal behavior.
Since he already committed the crime, Bobby would certainly need to be punished. However, Beccaria strongly argued that punishment must not be cruel, and must fit the crime. Clearly, Bobby never intended to hurt the homeowner; he broke into the home when he knew she would not be there.
Depending on the amount of property stolen, Bobby would have to pay the consequences. If this is his first offense, Bobby could be sentenced to a public form of community service, such as picking up trash by the roadside. He would also have to regularly report to a counselor. Parents could impose a strict curfew. This mixture of informal and formal methods of deterrence would help to stop Bobby from engaging in more criminal behavior.
Works Cited
Beccaria, Cesare. 1963. On Crimes and Punishment. New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
The Argument for Environmental Influence The modern fields of criminology and sociology have also established significant direct connections between the external environment and the behavior that develops in the individual (Schmalleger, 2008). Regardless of the effects of physiology and biological processes, there is undoubtedly a tremendous influence in the experiences, formative relationships, and role models to which the individual is exposed (Schmalleger, 2008). Many forms of modern crime are largely products
Causes of Criminal Behavior Although crimes have been committed since times immemorial, a systematic study of the causes of criminal behavior (or why crimes are committed) is a relatively recent phenomenon. Various theories have been put forward and numerous research studies have been conducted to better understand the criminal mind in order to prevent or reduce crime. It is, perhaps, a tribute to the complexity of the human brain that most
Classical and Positivist School of Thought in Criminology The classical school of criminology as originally articulated by Cesare Beccaria was based upon a philosophy of human rationality: people would choose pleasant over unpleasant sensations. If there was no expected punishment for crimes, people would behave in a lawless fashion. If punishment was expected, people would strive to avoid pain in a utilitarian fashion. Beccaria's theories arose in a response to earlier
Women and the Death Penalty Analysis An Analysis of the Historical Effect of Gender and Race on the Application of the Death Penalty in the United States While the debate over capital punishment continues to rage in the United States, questions of why the death penalty is viewed as ethical by some, while others would view it as unethical become increasingly significant. In addition, there are new controversies concerning the ethical nature
Classical criminology was an idea formed because there was no formal understanding of what caused criminal behavior. In an attempt to make sense of what was deemed socially irresponsible behavior, Cesare Beccaria was determined to formulate a theory that not only helped explain criminal behavior, but also helped to streamline punishment. Before this theory was developed, crime was not studied and the enforcement of crime was very arbitrary. Many times
VI. DURKHEIM'S ANOMIE Another theory in criminology is known as 'Durkheim's Anomie' which was conceived by Emile Durkheim, a French sociologist who first introduced the anomie in the work entitled: "The Division of Labor in Society" in which the anomie was utilized in provides a description of a "condition of deregulation that was occurring in society." (Criminological Theory, 2001) This anomie was used to describe how that the mores' of behavior
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now