Verified Document

Course Project From Hell Term Paper

Journalistic news media tend to present themselves as objective entities within out democratic society that ensure that citizens remain informed of important public issues and events, however, also as guardians who keep public officials honest. Ideals integrity, objectivity, and truthfulness are often cited as standards that govern how journalists, with respect to news stories, do their job. However, editorials are a whole different story. There is no claim of fairness or impartiality here. Instead of a reporting of substantiated facts, figures, and events, editorials are predominantly the opinions of writers (with the political slant of the publisher determining much of the content of what appears in editorial pages). This is not to say that editorials have no positive qualities. Editorials are often entertaining, and many individuals tend to favour a particular editorialist or editorial page that reflects their own beliefs, principles, etc. However, editorials are often characterized by the presentation of biased, opinionated, and speculative tirades that lead to many errors in logic and sound reasoning. In the course of this paper, I shall use a recent editorial by George Will in the Washington Post as an instance to analyze. The overall conclusion of the Will's editorial is two-fold. Firstly, Will concludes that the parents of students at Bedford Central were silly to attempt to resolve what they perceived as problematic state of affairs through litigation (in both the extent of what they viewed as problematic, and the route taken to resolve the state of affair). Secondly, Will concludes that the legal decision...

On Will's view, it was these respective silly acts that led to an overall silly state of affairs.
The arguments presented in Will's editorial can be summarised and linked in the following way. Will begins by summarizing Judge Brieant's findings in the case [argument 1]:

If parental complaints about pedagogical practices are unreasonable (i.e., a reasonable person would find no overt problem with the practices), then such complaints deserve to be given short shrift [premise]

Judge Brieant finds that parental complaints are unreasonable [premise]

Therefore, Judge Brieant give short shrift to most of the parent's complaints [conclusion]

However, Will challenges this finding by putting forward the following argument [2]:

The rejection of parental complaints was warranted because the examples they cite were not in fact religious in nature [premise]

There inclusion of an 'international enrichment' week (where models of Ganesha were made by students) constitutes a religious event in the curriculum [premise]

Therefore, the identification of what constitutes a presence of religion in the curriculum challenges what a reasonable person would view as a problematic practice [conclusion]

Will continues [argument 3]:

If Judge Brieant finds 'subtle coercive pressure' in making images of Ganesha (and other such events), then he finds that such actions are devoid of any educational justification [premise]

If Judge Brieant finds coercive pressure and a lack of educational justification in making images of Ganesha, then he is able to provide a demarcation between justified and unjustified educational practices [premise]

Judge Brieant makes a finding than certain education practices are justified (e.g., do…

Sources used in this document:
References

Colin Allen and Michael Hand, Logic Primer (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1992)

Altman et al. v. Bedford Central School District 45 F.Supp. 2d 368 (S.D.N.Y. 1999)

Stephen Barker, The Elements of Logic, fifth edition (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1989)

George F. Will, 'Judicial Silliness,' Washington Post, Thursday, June 3, 1999; page A27
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Conceptions of Hell: Dante's Inferno
Words: 1323 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Upon entering a place that appears to be hell, though it looks oddly like a coldly modern, windowless hotel, each of Sartre's characters expects to be tortured for his or her supposed sins. The wait; however, turns out not to be for the arrival of some "other," but rather the discovery that one's own self, and one's fellow human beings, perform the job perfectly well. Garcin, like Judas, is consumed

Emotional Recognition Project of Shakespeare's
Words: 537 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Hamlet feels anger toward Gertrude when he finally confronts her about her quick marriage to Claudius. He says: What devil wasn't That thus hath cozened you at hoodman-blind? Eyes without feeling, feeling without sight, Ears without hands or eyes, smelling sans all, or but a sickly part of one true sense Could not so mope. O shame, where is thy blush? (III.iv.86-91) Hamlet experiences fear when he contemplates suicide in Act 3 Scene 1. His fear is

Ethics Project
Words: 4363 Length: 10 Document Type: Book Review

Life and Death: The Life Support Dilemma by Kenneth E. Schemmer M.D Kenneth Schemmer in his thorough, thought provoking book brings to life the controversial subject of the life support issue. For years, many all over the country have pondered, "What if a person were in some kind of an accident and the physicians told them that they were not going to make it?" And all that he or she

Engineering Challenges on the Golden Gate Bridge
Words: 3103 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Figure 1. Golden Gate Bridge's Safety Net Source: http://www.zingarate.com/network/san-francisco/files/2012/11/safett_net.jpg The safety net was an essential risk management feature for the bridge project because the bridge needed to be 220 feet tall to accommodate commercial and naval vessels and falls from this height would certainly be fatal (Design and Construction 4). Unfortunately, this turned out to be the case during the final phases of construction. Despite this expensive security precaution, a catwalk collapsed

Collapsing Certainties Theme of Collapsing Uncertainties the
Words: 4291 Length: 15 Document Type: Capstone Project

Collapsing Certainties Theme of Collapsing Uncertainties The Collapsing Birth Rate in the Developed World Human beings perceive events, individuals, and objects in different manners in relation to the circumstances and understanding. This is vital towards the development of concept of reality with the aim of continuous leadership, caring, and forms of goodness. This is an indication that human beings believe in whatever they see and purport to be ideal thus generation of

Apple Inc. The Apple II Company Background
Words: 1974 Length: 7 Document Type: Capstone Project

Apple Inc. The Apple II Company Background Mission & Vision Apple's Five Force Model Current Rivalry Threat of New Entrants Bargaining Power of Suppliers Bargaining Power of Buyers Threat of Substitute Products Apple Inc. is the world's most formidable company. The company has grown to become one the world's most admirable companies through a deep dedication to innovation. The strategy in the last decade has revolved around the "digital hub" strategy that places the computer in the center of a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now