Verified Document

Contrast Of Eb Tylor And James Frazier Accounts Of Religion Term Paper

EB Tylor and James Frazier Accounts of Religion In comparing and contrasting the accounts of religion offered by E.B. Tyler and J.G. Frazer, it is noteworthy to mention that they were not contemporaries of one another. Frazer's ideas on the history and evolution of religion were preceded by Tyler's. As such, there were certain tenets propagated by the latter that were incorporated into the ideas of the former which help to explain some of the similarities between these authors. The relationship between their conceptions is discussed at length in the initial part of Daniel Pal's Seven Theories of Religion. One of the crucial distinctions between the two works is the fact that whereas Tyler's account is based on the notion of animism and Frazer's largely explains religion as a progeny of magic is that the latter's ideas are more consistent with the major forms of religion dominating contemporary existence -- specifically the monotheistic religions of Christianity, Judaism, and Islam. A thorough analysis of this fact and others presented by the authors reveals that because of its relevance to modern religious practices, Frazer's account of religion is more credible.

It is extremely notable that Frazer's account of religion was subsequent to that of Tylor's for the simple fact that he utilized many of the same academic disciplines for his research as Tyler did. Actually, the fact that both authors chose to base their religion on various aspects of anthropology and history (and not much contemporary sociology) is the principle point of similarity between...

Tylor's accounting is largely based on the conception of animism, which is essentially the belief that all living things have a spirit within them that animates them. As Tyler points out, Native Americans were some of the chief propagators of this notion, and believed that virtually all things in existence had a spirit. The key idea behind animism is that the spirt that animates all things is decidedly human-like in nature. The author substantiated his claim by claiming that animism evolved from studying various aspects of death and dreams.
In comparison, Frazer's account of religion is based on an inception related to magic. The author believes that magic was initially conceived as a means of fighting to stay alive, and that early people engaged in elaborate rituals to obtain their necessities of life such as weather amenable to crops and favorable hunting expeditions. It is interesting that he chooses to primarily detail the aspects of magic that are pure superstition, and does not devote very much writing to actual effects engendered by true magic. However, his main premises is that people initially discovered that the entire system of magic was tenuous if not a complete farce, and that its place as an explanation for worldly and supernatural events was soon displaced by the concept of religion. The author propounds the notion that religion was a much more suitable alternative because it is decidedly more imperfect in its procedures than magic -- the key distinction that it depends on supernatural beings or Gods to…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Pals, Daniel. Seven Theories of Religion.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Contrasts of Phonological Therapy
Words: 1004 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

Phonological Therapy Dodd, B., Crosbie, S., McIntosh, B., Holm, A., Harvey, C., Liddy, M., Fontyne, K., Pinchin, B., & Rigby, H. (2008). The impact of selecting different contrasts in phonological therapy. International Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 10(5): 334-345. The purpose of the study was to determine how different contrasts in phonological therapy affected children who had phonological disorders. The authors were interested in the question because it affects a significant number

Contrast and Compare Essay Starry Night and the Scream
Words: 944 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

pain, Van Gogh had somewhat of a twin. Edvard Munch, the painter of the famous Scream and Vincent Van Gogh, the painter of the widely popular Starry Night, were both deeply affected expressionist painters that saw French impressionism and admired Gauguin's symbolic boldness and abstract qualities. By depicting nightmarish lithographs of depraved sexuality, some of Munch's images harkened back to Gauguin. However, the similarities between Van Gogh and Munch

Contrast of Content and Process Models of Human Motivation As It...
Words: 2821 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Motivation in Health Care Desire is inbuilt in man. Our life and its furtherance through breeding are dependent on desire. Achievement of desire is what motivates us. On different levels, one might consider motivators and incentives. Often, the expeditious and efficient completion of a project is associated with a bonus. Motivation theory is a field of study that has established formalism for one important aspect of human behavior -- fulfillment of

Contrasting Jobs and Fiorina at Leadership
Words: 745 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Leadership To contrast leadership styles, it might be instructive to take a look at two tech giants whose paths went in very different directions in the mid-2000s. One is Apple, which was wildly successful, and the other was Hewlett Packard, which struggled to keep up with the times. Apple under Steve Jobs was successful in large part because he was involved actively in the company's strategy, and in guiding his team

Contrasting Plato and Mcluhan Regarding the Medium and Truth
Words: 1308 Length: 3 Document Type:

Plato and McLuhan: Truth and the Medium McLuhan does not directly address the idea of truth or reality but does state that by understanding the structure of various media forms, we can become more aware of how it shapes our thinking and our environment. McLuhan's idea of truth is to reveal the structure of media and thereby not succumb to its effects. He offers different ways in which we can attempt

Compare and Contrast 2 Different Religions
Words: 2089 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

World Religions Compare and contrast 2 different religions World's Religions: Judaism and Buddhism For over centuries, the term religion has been used interchangeably in close relations with faith, set of duties, system or set of beliefs. In 2012, a global poll reported that approximately 62% of the world's population relies on religious beliefs while 38% are not religious (does not belong to any religion), including 10% who are atheists. Religion is a collection

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now