Verified Document

Constructivism And Feminism Ideas Identity And Gender Article Review

Feminism and International Relations Tickner discusses Morgenthau's 'six principles of political realism', refuting the notion that international politics is a realistic, masculine domain. Tickner offers a feminist perspective on Morgenthau's theory. She believes that the fundamental flaw in Morgenthau's article is that it is defined by masculinity. She argues that men are overrepresented in the upper levels of international politics, specifically the realms of the military, diplomacy, and science. Women are making strides but not enough are advancing to the upper echelons. If a woman were to advance high enough, she would find herself in a hostile environment. Tickner (2012)writes on why international politics is dominated by men, she argues that the language is masculinized, women are portrayed as more apt to domestic interests, and that the world of international politics and academia is inhospitable to women.

Tickner (2012) summarizes Morgenthau's six points. The first point is that politics is ruled by objective laws. Second, interest is defined in regards to power, and it injects rationality into politics and negates the necessity of emotion. Third, power is the control of one man over another and is also an objective concept. Four, there is strain between morality and the necessities of political action. Five, morality is universal but self-interest is necessary at the state level. Six, human nature a pluralistic...

After summarizing his points, Tickner (2012) makes the argument that his principles including his language are an incomplete description of international relations. She believes that his assumptions also benefit masculinity. Feminists, according to Tickner (2012), believe knowledge is socially constructed. She says that knowledge is socially constructed and that language transmits knowledge, making it vital to critique the words of Morgenthau. Objectivity, at least how Morgenthau presents it, is associated with masculinity, something absolute while subjectivity is feminine and irrational. Tickner says "women are socialized into a mode of thinking which contextual and narrative rather than formal and abstract" (Tickner, 2012). It is important to note how objectivity is a fundamental aspect of realism.
Morgenthau's ideal politician ("political man") is immoral and objective. He is unchained by the constraints of morality. This indicates Morgenthau's acceptance of Hobbesian competition for power between states on an international level. Yet, according to Tickner these bleak view on humanity and international relations ignores the role of cooperation and collective self-reliance. These concepts are not masculine, but more in tune with the feminist approach to international relations. Toward the end of the article, Tickner acknowledges Morgenthau's arguments; she is simply adding a…

Sources used in this document:
References:

Wendt Alexander. (2012). Anarchy is What States Make of It. In Robert, J. Art & Robert, Jervis (Eds.), International Politics: Enduring concepts and contemporary issues (11th ed., pp. 65-72). Boston: Pearson.

Tickner, Ann. (2012). A Critique of Morgenthau's Principles of Political Realism. In Robert, J. Art & Robert, Jervis (Eds.), International Politics: Enduring concepts and contemporary issues (11th ed., pp. 22-32). Boston: Pearson.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

How Gender Identity Is Construed Today
Words: 3403 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Gender Identity What is gender? Is it a biological condition or a social construction? In today's modern world, it appears that it can be one or the other or even a mixture of both. Transgender people like Caitlyn Jenner (formerly Bruce Jenner, an Olympian) have raised awareness about the issue of gender, and so have others, like the Wachowski siblings, famous Hollywood directors, who have brought attention to the issue

Why an Essentialist View of Gender is Outdated
Words: 2931 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

Essentialist vs. Constructionist Views of Gender and Sexuality During a period in history when gender lines and blurring and conceptualizations of sexuality are changing, identifying how these trends affect modern society has assumed new importance and relevance, especially given the legal implications of these trends for Americans today. It is also important to note, though, that these same trends occurred in many ways in some parts of the ancient world where

Media in Contemporary Culture Gender Roles in Sex and the City
Words: 1791 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Media Communications Representation of characters and role models in different media outlets is based on perceptions and preconceived notions held by the producer, co-producers, and audiences at large. Only those representations are drawn that largely resonate with current meanings given to people, characters, places, and objects.The paper presents two theoretical approaches to study media and its impact at large. Theory of social constructivism provides framework to assess the meanings given to

Ontology, 1-3 Epistemology and Methodology
Words: 3653 Length: 10 Document Type: Assessment

The research too has to be reliable and valid cohering to an internal and external scientific definition of reality that is more physical and eschews the metaphysical and the abstract. Ontological Basis Positivism accepts a certain reality of existence and insists that this reality can be discovered by universal and immutable scientific / mathematical principles (Tribe, 2009) . Epistemological Basis The researcher has to distance himself as much as possible from his research

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now