Verified Document

Cloning Is No Longer The Stuff Of Term Paper

Cloning is no longer the stuff of science fiction, but is a reality that has become a serious subject of hot debate around the globe. At issue are the ethical, scientific, moral and economic implications of cloning. In October 2004, David Stevens, Executive Director of the Christian Medical Association confronted scientific duplicity and specifically challenged the International Society for Stem Cell Research asking to stop misleading the public and the media by changing human cloning nomenclature (Christian Pp). Stevens was referring to a September 2004 statement by ISSCR president Leonard Zon encouraging researchers and the media to stop using the term, "cloning" because of its negative connotations (Christian Pp). Zon said, that "nuclear transfer" be used instead of "therapeutic cloning" because the term "cloning" does not accurately describe this biological process, whereby "cells generated by nuclear transfer are by no definition a clone of the donor of the transferred nucleus" (Christian Pp). Stevens charges that researches are trying to obscure the fact that they want to clone human embryos to get embryonic stem cells, and claims that "history has shown that verbal engineering facilitates social engineering...they simply change the terminology" (Christian Pp).

On November 18, 2004, it was reported that Italy had offered a compromise on human cloning allowing common ground among United Nation member states that are:sharply divided over competing treaties to ban the practice" (Wadhams Pp). Although it is too early to know whether the compromise will help, Belgian diplomat Marc Pecsteen said that progress was being made, however, "We need some more playing with words to find the compromise we need" (Wadhams Pp). The issue of a global treaty on human cloning has created a sharp rift in attitudes of the member states (Wadhams Pp). For example, a proposal from Costa Rica would ban all human cloning, while another from Belgium would ban reproductive cloning yet allow use of embryos for stem cell and other research (Wadhams Pp). The Costa Rican document has sixty-two co-sponsors, including the U.S. And Italy, while the Belgian proposal...

The draft declaration calls on nations to ban attempts to create "human life" through cloning (Wadhams Pp). The Belgian supporters are seeking language that would ban cloning to create human beings, "a crucial difference because many opponents of cloning believe embryos are human life, but not human beings" (Wadhams Pp).
Although there is no scientific reason to link reproductive and therapeutic cloning, they would each involve essentially the same initial technology to produce early human embryos, only the aims would be different (May Pp).

In reproductive cloning the embryo would be implanted in the womb to bring about the birth of a child, whereas in therapeutic cloning, the early embryo would never develop beyond a microscopic ball of cells and would be used to explore stem cell treatments for diseases such as diabetes and Parkinson's (May Pp).

There is an overwhelming international consensus that exists in the scientific and medical communities that any attempt at human reproductive cloning would be scientifically unsound and medically unsafe (May pp). Animal experiments have highlighted the dangers that reproductive cloning would pose to fetuses and mothers, and the majority of the public considers it unacceptable, therefore a worldwide ban on reproductive cloning would be supported by international scientists, doctors, and the public (May Pp).

However, there appears to be no legal reason why the U.N. should ban both reproductive and therapeutic cloning, for they can be treated separately in law.(May Pp). In 2001 Britain introduced primary legislation against reproductive cloning, an action taken after it had extended the existing rules governing licenses research on early human embryos to include therapeutic cloning (May Pp), To date the United States does not have primary legislation against wither reproductive or therapeutic cloning, yet by backing the Belgian proposal, it would retain the freedom to ban both and help ensure a worldwide ban on reproductive cloning (May Pp).

Many scientists believe that some day it may be possible…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Christian Medical Association Doctors Assail Plan to Lead Public and Media

Away from Truth on Human Cloning." Business Wire. 10/1/2004; Pp.

Wadhams, Nick. "Italy offers possible way out of divisive U.N. cloning dispute."

AP Worldstream. 11/18/2004; Pp.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Human Cloning the Subject of Human Cloning
Words: 2195 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Human Cloning The subject of human cloning was once the stuff of science fiction novels and television programs. As technology and science improves, the creation of clones has become, potentially, a real likelihood in the impending future. For the follow, the definition of human cloning is that which has been designated by the American Medical Association: The term "cloning" will refer to the production of genetically identical organisms via somatic cell nuclear

Ethics of Human Cloning Genetic Engineering and
Words: 1707 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Ethics of Human Cloning Genetic engineering and cloning have played important roles in agriculture for many generations. Bananas and seedless grapes, for example, are, quite literally, living genetic clones (Krock, 2001). Prior to the last decade of the 20th Century, human cloning was purely a subject of science fiction, but by the dawn of the 21st Century, researchers had already cloned several mammals successfully. In 1978, medical science had progressed to the

Chemistry and Biology on Christian Mind
Words: 2557 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Chemistry and Biology on Christian Mind The Effects Chemistry and Biology on Christian Mind Science and Christianity share a very conflicting relationship. There are different faces of this relationship and we can determine this relationship by using different models. One of such models suggests that science and Christianity are in conflict with each other. Though both of these areas ask you the same question but the answers which they seek are

Higher Education at the University
Words: 839 Length: 3 Document Type: Admission Essay

Nonspecific staining in both the control and experimental groups rendered any possible findings virtually invisible, but ultimately the opportunity to participate in the research process from hypothesis through to data presentation was a tremendous opportunity for me, and I highly value the experience. My taste for research had only just been awoken by my experiences in my third year as an undergraduate, and after completing my degree I signed on

Released by the FBI and
Words: 17274 Length: 65 Document Type: Research Proposal

" Human development- behavioral shifts in human being that tae place during the course of an entire lifespan ("Human Behavior"). Risk Analysis- the activity of determining and analyzing the dangerous natural and human caused negative events. This analysis takes into consideration the risks these event pose to businesses individuals and governments. Within the domain of information technology risk analysis reports are utilized to tailor technology-related objectives with a an organization's business objectives.

Animal Research Following the Precedent
Words: 2022 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Our survival, as well as the ecosystem of the planet, depends on our stewardship and that stewardship is the price of our research. One must finally wrestle with the issue of survival on a personal level in order to understand this issue. Coming down from the macrocosmic view, if it were a matter of your child having leukemia and suffering for years before dying or a laboratory rat suffering

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now