Verified Document

Cliff Is Assuming Decreases In Revenues Are Case Study

Cliff is assuming decreases in revenues are decreasing needed revenue for new projects. With a new product launch, the company would be able to regain market share and revenues. Pat is assuming a new product to identify customers by retinal scan, track information about customers, and deliver real time reports would give substantial ROI and provide revenues for the future, the product could be launched on the $400K budget with refined features, should be implemented by the August deadline without problem, a prototype product with incomplete features will still satisfy customers, Kelly is set in his ways and refuses to change, and Kelly is not being realistic about the capabilities of his existing employees.

Kelly is assuming the company is not equipped to do the product launch and still serve existing customers with the reduced staff, continually holding meetings is a waste of time because of arguments, can only create one feature and make it work by the deadline, and the product launch would take away from existing customers.

d. Chris assumes extreme action is needed due to the decrease in revenue and the new product launch is essential for the company's future.

2. Arguments

a. Cliff argues the company is experiencing a decline in revenues and market share and the new product launch would increase revenue and market share creating revenues for additional projects.

b. Pat argues the new product launch would increase revenue for the future and argues a substantial ROI on the proposed budget.

c. Kelly argues that company is not equipped to produce the product with existing short staff and claims they are only capable of creating one workable feature by the August deadline.

d. Chris argues that extreme action is needed to regain revenue and claims...

Argument Evaluation
Cliff's argument is sound because in order to build revenue the new

Product launch would create more revenue. Both premises are true and the conclusion follows the premises (In Logic, What Are Sound and Valid Arguments?). This is logical in nature because it is has true reasoning behind the argument (Kies). Pat's argument is unsound because there is no guarantee of success with the project. Her argument is emotional in nature because it has no reasoning and plays on the emotions of others. Kelly's argument is sound because the true conclusion follows the true premises. His argument is logical in nature because it contains reasoning. Chris's argument is sound because a true conclusion follows the true premises. It is logical in nature because it contains reasoning.

4. Fallacious Arguments

1. Pat: "… I don't see why we can't produce by August with it. From what I've seen, our programmers are the best!" is an appeal to emotions (Copi, 2009).

2. Pat: "When do you want to get together?" is an appeal to force.

3. Pat: "…why can't we put together some kind of prototype by August that includes all of the features? So what if they're not complete…" is a red herring fallacy.

4. Pat: "…come on Kelly, I talked to one of the programmers last week and explained what we're trying to do…" is an attack on the person.

Conclusions

There is…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Copi, I.M. (2009). Chapter 4. In I.M. Copi, Introduction to Logic (pp. 118-177). New York, NY: Pearson Custom Publishing.

In Logic, What Are Sound and Valid Arguments? (n.d.). Retrieved from Wise GEEK: http://wisegeek.com/in-logic-What-are-Sound-and-Valid-arguments.htm

Kies, D. (n.d.). Using Logic in Composition. Retrieved from HyperTextBooks: http://papyr.com/compl1/logic.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Kelly Has Made Many Assumptions That Pat
Words: 1634 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Kelly has made many assumptions that Pat does not know anything about how the iScanner product works and the basics of quality control. He thinks that Pat is trying to undermine him by talking to one of his programmers and appears to be basing, in part, some of the requirements for the retail product on products used at airports that may require higher security features. Pat assumes that Kelly and his

Acu San Case Study the
Words: 1470 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

Arguments for the assumptions: Pat's and Chris's suggestion that the company develop new products and launch them onto different markets is based on the fact that the recent statistics received from the Marketing Department are unsatisfactory. Evaluating the arguments: The unsatisfactory statistics received from the Marketing Department make a sound argument as the leading position of AcuSan on the market is being challenged by competitors' intense efforts to elaborate new strategies. Another

Forecast and Valuations of Black and Decker
Words: 1271 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Black & Decker Forecasts Since the merger with Stanley, Black and Decker has seen a steady increase in its revenues, gross profit and net income. The different elements of the new company are still being integrated, underperforming divisions are being shed, and synergies between the different components are still being developed. As the company continues to make internal improvements, it can expect that it will continue to grow both its top and

Contrarian Investment Strategies Over the
Words: 26080 Length: 73 Document Type: Thesis

" This is significant because it shows how some critics of contrarian investing will often point to the various instances of speculation and assume that it is contrarian investing. In some cases the psychology of consumers can become so extreme, that the definition of what is speculative expands greatly. As a result, using contrarian investing in conjunction with other indicators / tools can help prudent investors and traders, be able to

Financial Resources Performance the Managing Director, King
Words: 2383 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Financial Resources Performance The Managing Director, King Edwards Electronics, Manchester, U.K. INTERNAL REPORT. FIXING RISK, UNCERTAINTY AND CASH FLOW DISCREPANCIES Dear Sir, In making investment decisions we are dealing with; and actually shaping; the firm's future, but the future is not certain and investment decisions, whether personal or corporate, are invariably undertaken with imperfect knowledge about the future. The future may turn out to be better or worse than expected. For the corporate firm, the objective

Global Financial Crisis: An Examination of One
Words: 2319 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Global Financial Crisis: An Examination of One Company's Performance Indicators The global financial crisis of the recent past has been the subject of much commentary, investigation, and debate from people around the globe and from all walks of life. Despite the fact that politicians and armchair policy makers have gone round after round in debates regarding the causes and the ultimate effects of this worldwide economic downturn, the real effects

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now