Verified Document

Christians Struggle With The Dichotomy Term Paper

Related Topics:

According to the author, the passage indicates that the authors of the Bible wrote under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, but that they did not receive exact dictation from God. They were inspired to write as they wished, but the outcome was still determined by God's ultimate will: "For the prophecy came not in old time by the will of man: but holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Ghost." (2 Peter 1:21). In the same way, the words of the prophets were their own, but the message behind these words was inspired by God. This is the nature of the interaction between God's will and human freedom in terms of the Bible. In this way, Feinberg uses the Bible to substantiate everything he says about divine and human will, and I am therefore convinced that his arguments are superior to those of Reichenbach in terms from a biblical viewpoint.

In contrast to Feinberg, Reichenbach approaches the topic from a philosophical rather than a biblical viewpoint. The central argument of his article is that, in order to allow choice and free will on earth, God is inclined to limit his power. Reichenbach argues that causal elements are not sufficient to determine the actions of a person if such a person is indeed free to choose. He denies that any internal or external forces should have an impact on how a person acts. Only in such a case, according to Reichenbach, does human freedom exist. This argument is based not upon biblical evidence, but rather upon an intuitional philosophy: Reichenbach holds that human beings "feel" that they have a choice to act, and that they have the ability to be either wrong or right in these choices (Reichenbach 104).

This position...

The way in which he handles this dichotomy is however decidedly unbiblical. In order to provide human beings with the freedom that is clearly evident in the world around us, according to Reichenbach, God limits his sovereignty and his omnipotence. Human freedom, according to this view, cannot exist simultaneously with divine sovereignty and omnipotence. If this were the case, human life, as mentioned above, would be simply a number of predetermined actions with people being little more than drones. Since this is clearly not the case, Reichenbach attempts to form an entirely unbiblical concept of God's nature. As such, the author claims that God indeed does not know everything, as he is not aware of the choices that people will make. The reason for this is that God has granted human beings with complete freedom of choice. According to the article, this is God's self-imposed limitation.
When regarded from the biblical viewpoint, the above claim is certainly not true. The Bible makes repeated references to God's sovereignty and omnipotence. Clearly, passages such as Psalm 115:2-3 indicates that God imposes no limitations upon his own power or knowledge even in the face of non-belief: "2 Why should the Gentiles say, / 'So where is their God' / 3 but our God is in heaven; / He does whatever He pleases." Psalm 139:16 states that God knows absolutely everything regarding the outcome of events: "...in Your book they all were written, / the days fashioned for me, / When as yet there were none of them."

Surely what Reichenbach attempts to prove is directly in contradiction to the above. In the light of this, therefore, I believe that Feinberg presents a much stronger biblical argument for the manifestation of human freedom and its interaction with God's will. The Bible contains no passages that indicate God's limitations; either self-imposed or otherwise. In contrast to Reichenbach, Feinberg accepts God's unlimited knowledge and power and basis his philosophical arguments upon this rather than attempting to contradict biblical…

Sources used in this document:
references to God's sovereignty and omnipotence. Clearly, passages such as Psalm 115:2-3 indicates that God imposes no limitations upon his own power or knowledge even in the face of non-belief: "2 Why should the Gentiles say, / 'So where is their God' / 3 but our God is in heaven; / He does whatever He pleases." Psalm 139:16 states that God knows absolutely everything regarding the outcome of events: "...in Your book they all were written, / the days fashioned for me, / When as yet there were none of them."

Surely what Reichenbach attempts to prove is directly in contradiction to the above. In the light of this, therefore, I believe that Feinberg presents a much stronger biblical argument for the manifestation of human freedom and its interaction with God's will. The Bible contains no passages that indicate God's limitations; either self-imposed or otherwise. In contrast to Reichenbach, Feinberg accepts God's unlimited knowledge and power and basis his philosophical arguments upon this rather than attempting to contradict biblical truth. The latter author's argument is therefore stronger in biblical terms.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Dichotomy of Our Gender System
Words: 2356 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

" Following on the heels of Michel Foucault, Butler situates the dichotomous conceptualization of gender as a product of discourse, just as Foucault (1990) realized that homo- and heterosexuality were both discursive products. The maintenance of coherent norms in the realm of gender through cultural discourse is intertwined with the positing of heterosexuality as the norm. This is why, for example, when a young boy "dresses up" as a girl and/or

Bad & Good and The
Words: 1160 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

What is intrinsic regarding this definition of evil is the value that ressentiment has upon it. Ressentiment is a term widely used by Nietzsche and other philosophers (such as Kierkegaard) to refer to the notion of resentment -- which can take many forms including jealousy and other forms of subjugation -- influencing a particular moral perception. Because the weak were oppressed by and opposed to the depredation of the strong,

Counseling Model a Practical Pastoral Counseling Model
Words: 3760 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

Counseling Model A Practical Pastoral Counseling Model Counseling Setting Where Will Counseling Take Place? Boundaries for Safety and Security Relational Style Relational/Communication Style Structure/Strategy Sessions Summation Supportive Feedback God's Riches at Christ's Expense Annotated Bibliography A Practical Pastoral Counseling Model This is an overview of the counseling position that I will take when working with clients/parishioners. I realize that this cannot encompass every eventuality that may occur during a counseling session, but it should be comprehensive enough to account for most of the possibilities

Origen Remains One of the
Words: 4907 Length: 18 Document Type: Thesis

260). This cosmological discussion is one reason Origen is said to have "created, indeed embodied, the first model of a scientific theology;" his approach to the notion of metempsychosis, like nearly all of his theological work, is rooted in a steadfast determination to distinguish "between the dogmata of the church tradition and the problemata which were to be discussed" according to reason, logic, and a prototype of the scientific

Boudon 2001 and Eskensberger 2001
Words: 1185 Length: 3 Document Type: Thesis

Their anticipated and desired results for their education, personal or practical, may vary widely in unpredictable ways. The attitudes towards educational processes may differ due to the greater and more diverse social and life experiences that color perceptions of classroom life, even more so than the raw educational materials used in the classroom. The teacher must balance addressing individual needs through conferences, personal contacts, and allowing for more independent

Film Being John Malkovich Sexuality
Words: 3487 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

His stance is also one of superiority as he presents himself as the victim of his own vision and artistic expression. In this context, the generic pronoun "they" symbolizes Craig's detachment from the world around him as he feels superior which he believes, is what causes his isolation. Craig's wife, Lotte, is perhaps the most radically changed as a result of traveling through the portal. She becomes convinced that she

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now