Verified Document

Child Rearing And Personal Autonomy Essay

¶ … SOCIAL SCIENCE. The topic file I upload, I upload 2 lecture outlines. *The kit reading "Individual Autonomy Social Structure" Freedom Culture. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall,1959 PP.5-14 LEE, DOROTHY. The key social problem that Dorothy Lee is addressing is the relationship between personal autonomy and the structure and characteristics of the society of which the individual is a part. In particular, she looks at how "personal autonomy is supported by the cultural framework." As Lee points out at page 9 of her work, the relationship between personal autonomy and structure or the cultural framework, perhaps not obvious at first, is given by the way the latter determines the first.

Indeed, as her eloquent example of the Burmese novices points out, personal autonomy is often determined by the cultural framework. In other words, the individual determines his degree of personal autonomy based on the existing structure of the society he is part of. At the same time, the cultural framework sets tacit rules that determine his area of independent action.

In the same manner, successful societies and cultures appear to be able to properly and efficiently regulate individual action. On one hand, individual action is beneficial to a society, leading to progress and to the further consolidation of societal action. At the same time, however, chaos in societies are often the result of improperly understand autonomy...

Lee shows that this type of chaos and lawlessness is usually the result of a "structural vacuum."
In the case of the structural vacuum, it is usually an individual or group of individual that bypasses the existing cultural framework in order to expand the level of personal autonomy. Lee points out that this is usually the type of situation that eventually produces a dysfunctional society that Lee assimilates to one where lawlessness and chaos is present.

One of the most interesting examples that Lee discusses is that of child rearing. Lee looks at child rearing in the Navajo society and determines that personal autonomy is something that the Navajos groom and encourage from an early age. This is done through the education that the mother gives the children and the freedom she allows them in growing up.

This education includes not removing dangerous objects from their area, including fire or knives. The personal autonomy is shaped here through trial and error: if the child is a little hurt, he will learn from his mistake and will be able to avoid it in the future. Lee, citing another study, concludes that this makes the children more independent and ready to successfully perform tasks at an early age.

This approach to child rearing also comes to the perception that Navajos apply in their society that there is little differentiation between a child and an adult, both…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Autonomy and Pregnancy Personal Autonomy Lies at
Words: 2073 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Autonomy and Pregnancy Personal autonomy lies at the heart of the pro-choice movement and is an issue that impacts every pregnant woman. Any person who has been pregnant can tell you that pregnancy has consequences to the individual, both short-term and long-term. Some of those consequences are seemingly minor, but others can be literally life-threatening. However, while the pro-choice anti-choice debate focuses on maternal rights and fetal rights, there is little

Child Psychology Child Development Is
Words: 5209 Length: 18 Document Type: Term Paper

The most fundamental theorist in this area is Jean Piaget. Additionally, Piaget demonstrated one of the first scientific movements in the filed, with the utilization of direct observation as the best tool for understanding. (Piaget, 1962, p. 107) Piaget also believes, and his theories reflect that children play a very active and dynamic role in development through interaction with their environment and active role imitation. (Piaget, 1962, p. 159) Sensory-motor

Personal Portrait the Course of
Words: 2852 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

According to the Kohlberg theory, the post-conventional level is when a person develops social contract orientation and becomes principled. I believe I felt that I owed society an obligation to work and try to make it better, so I sought public welfare work (Fowler, p. 56). Eventually, a better job opportunity came to me in the form of a state job in the Department of Youth and Family Services, so I

Raising Children in the U.S.
Words: 4137 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Proposal

This often creates a frustrating situation within the home, as children and parents may clash over these ideas. Of course, cultural issues are not the only differences in parenting in the United States. Phegley (2009) states that parents can easily identify what they want in their relationships with their children -- they wan the best. The best, she argues, "is entirely up to an individual's perception" (para. 2). Thus, parents

Family Development Child Care Advice
Words: 3295 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

2007). Further, if child care hours increased between three and 54 months (4 1/2) years, their vocabulary scores are lowered by the time they reach 5th grade (Belsky et al., 2007). This suggests that long-term child care use has important implications not only on children's socio-emotional functioning but on academic achievement as well. Knowing this, it becomes more evident that parents cannot overlook the importance of choosing high quality child

Cultural Assessment of a Child Aged Three
Words: 2934 Length: 10 Document Type: Assessment

The Psychological Development of VLIntroductionThis paper describes the psychological development of a young girl named VL. At the age of 3 years and 11 months, VL is vibrant, talkative, curious, engaging and enthusiastic. She has boundless energy, and is part of a Jamaican family. She also has an older brother who is 7 years old and has been diagnosed with autism. The purpose of this paper is to evaluate VL\\\'s

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now