Verified Document

Chief Seattle Speech Term Paper

Chief Seattle and the Tragedy of the Commons: Ownership vs. Stewardship

As capitalists first and Americans second, we believe strongly in the concept of ownership. We own and use the Earth and the material goods Earth's raw materials help us produce, and feel a proprietary command over them. When Communism developed as an alternative to the concept of unadulterated ownership, we responded with the fear and anger of one whose child had been taken.

Ownership of the land, its materials and its spoils are more integral to American society and thought than any other characteristics or facets. However, this concept is subject to the limitations and inevitable truth of the tragedy of the commons, and we will eventually be dupes to this incontrovertible logic.

The Tragedy of the Commons

The "commons" is any kind of resource which is divided up and shared by a group of people. Such things as the air we breathe and the water we drink derive from the commons. In many areas of the world, new physical land for farming and grazing land for farmers' stock, fish from the sea and wood for various fuels and housing are treated as commons, and owned by all.

The logic of the commons functions in this particular manner: Each household on Earth has the right to plunder resources from and deposit wastes into the commons. To accumulate wealth, resources and material goods, every household feels that it can acquire one resources unit or dump one waste unit while distributing one unit of cost across all households with which the commons itself is shared. In this manner, the gain to the household...

"Some households accumulate wealth more rapidly than others and this, in turn, gives them the means to access an even larger share of the commons." (Harding, 1997)
The logical error in the commons lies in our failure to realize and internalize that all households are attempting to accomplish the same exact thing. "Thus, on average, one unit of gain for a household actually produces a net one unit of cost for each household. However, selfish households accumulate wealth from the commons by acquiring more than their fair share of the resources and paying less than their fair share of the total costs. Ultimately, as population grows and greed runs rampant, the commons collapses and ends in "the tragedy of the commons." (Garrett Hardin, Science 162:1243, 1968).

The logic of the commons as described above collapses when resources decline and/or population grows too large. Consider the following example:

Fourteenth century England was set up as a loosely connected collection of villages, each with its own common pasture for villagers to graze horses, cattle and sheep. Each household attempted to gain wealth by placing as many of the animals on the commons as it could afford. As the village exploded in size and more and more creatures were located on the commons by the villagers, overgrazing destroyed the pasture. No livestock could be supported on the commons after that. As a direct ramification of population growth, greed, and the logic of the commons, village after village collapsed in medieval England.

An seemingly foolproof response to avoid…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Chief Seattle. 1854 Speech. http://members.tripod.com/~flo34/chiefseattle.html

Hardin, Gary. 1968. Science: The Tragedy of the Commons.

Hardin, Gary. 1997. The Commons.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Chief Seattle's 1854 Oration Tone
Words: 718 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

This indeed appears just, even generous, for the Red Man no longer has rights that he need respect, and the offer may be wise, also, as we are no longer in need of an extensive country. Clearly, Chief Seattle's tone, within his 1854 Oration, had become by necessity conciliatory about white encroachment upon his people and their lands. Yet his words remain wistful and poignant, reflecting, as they do on

Barack Obama and the Deracialization
Words: 8978 Length: 30 Document Type: Thesis

More precisely, "color blind racism created a paradox for presidential candidate Barack Obama. While he could not escape "race" his candidacy strategically figured "race" through color blind rhetoric that contained the threat of a black presidency. In spite of his campaign's efforts to avoid his racialization, "Obama" was alternately racialised and deracialized through his affective ties The tactics used by Obama through the application of the deracialization theory may have

Syringe in My Pepsi Can
Words: 2051 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

Yet, the benefits of the technique above could have turned into disadvantages if the spokesperson lost his temper, didn't know what to answer or provided details that shouldn't have reached the media. Fourthly, the corporation established non-stop toll-free numbers. These offered two major benefits: the softening of the corporate image (PepsiCo appeared as an entity open to dialogue and concerned about the safety of its consumers) and the permanent feedback

Character Sketch of Joe Provenzano
Words: 639 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Oh, we just came back from a shoot-out. I participate in the Single Action Shooting Society where I go by the name Tex Fiddler," Joe said. How in the world did you come up with Tex Fiddler?," I asked unable to repress my curiosity. Well, I am from Texas and I love to play the fiddle. It is one of my hobbies," he said. After this awkward introduction, we invited Joe and his

Sound Reforms in the Operations and Structure
Words: 1904 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

sound reforms in the operations and structure of United States Congress. The paper also discusses the reasons why reforms are needed in this powerful institution of our country. REFORMING THE CONGRESS Congress may be the most powerful institution in the United States government but it is certainly not the most efficient. The powers that Constitution has granted this body have resulted in the creation of an oversized inefficient institution, full of

Teaching Today: An Introduction to
Words: 5989 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

There are some papers that are to be released and referred to by her in the above article. In the first of those papers, the belief is that the present result of the aptitude tests of the teachers today is the same as was the case a generation earlier, but the best among them are not likely to become teachers. In the second paper, the result shows that the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now