Verified Document

Case Scenario Ethics Essay

Ethics State Regulations and Nursing Standards

There's a clear nursing standard of practice that needs to be upheld in this case which is the act of following federal laws, largely the Patient Self-Determination Act (PSDA). Passed by Congress in 1990, "the law mandates that in healthcare institutions that receive Medicare or Medicaid funding, patients must be informed in writing upon the admission of 1) their right to accept or refuse treatment, (2) their rights under existing state laws regarding advance directives, and (3) any policies the institution has regarding the with-holding or withdrawing of life sustaining treatments (Ulrich, 1999, p.9).

Thus, the implications as a result of the Patient Self-Determination Act are clear: Patients have the autonomy and independence to steer the direction their care takes if any at all. Medical professionals have an ethical, though more importantly a legal responsibility and requirement to obey the wishes of the patient. Mr. E's advanced directive should have been addressed immediately and been honored from the start. Much of the drama and unnecessary speculation of the subject could have been rightfully addressed from the start.

3. Code of Ethics

Self-determination and autonomy apply directly to this case, as elements of the code of ethics that directly connect to this case. Self-determination and autonomy refer to the right of the patient to decide precisely how his map and protocol of care will unfold. An advanced directive authorizes people to state precisely the directions and exactions of the type of medical care they want if their mental and physical health reaches a state where they can't make decisions...

Advanced directives also act as a form of direction for family members and doctors so that they can thus make decisions about the patient's care with a clear conscience (Mitty & Ramsey, 2008). From a legal standpoint this is essential as well, as it prevents decision-makers from becoming criminally liable when they were actually just following the terms of an advanced directive (Mitty & Ramsey, 2008).
4). Impact of the Code

Thus given the importance of honoring the ethical elements of autonomy and self-determination should not be underestimated; they're absolutely fundamental elements of decent care. Thus, in this decision, honoring the advanced directive that the patient made ahead of time is of the utmost importance. It doesn't matter if the health care professionals disagree with it or find it objectionable; not every course of treatment for a patient has to be found agreeable to medical professionals. The issue of the most fundamental and absolute performance is that the legal plans that the patient created to guide the trajectory of his treatment be honored.

5. The ethical implications of putting the patient on the ventilator are staggering. While clinicians likely believe their upholding the ethical code of beneficence, this is just illusory. The reality is that they're violating the patient's autonomy and self-determination. Ultimately, the health care professionals are developing a state of malficence, something that should be avoided at all costs. The patient had an advanced directive: Classic examples of advanced directives are power of attorney and living wills. Thus,…

Sources used in this document:
References

ANA. (2001). Code of Ethics for Nurses With Interpretive Statements. Silver Spring: American Nurses Association.

Mitty, E.R. (2008, March). Advanced Directive. Retrieved from Consultgerin.org: http://consultgerirn.org/topics/advance_directives/want_to_know_more/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Security Breach Case Scenario 1: Security Breach
Words: 1969 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Security Breach Case Scenario 1: Security Breach Hospitals have the opportunity and responsibility to integrate sound policies and procedures in relation to the protection of the confidential client information (Rodwin, 2010). St. John's Hospital in no different to this notion has the organization seeks to enhance the security and confidentiality of the information of its clients. The organization is a role model to other institutions within the geographical area on the essential

Ethics in Business Has Become
Words: 2102 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Training is part of this process, so that people explicitly understand the ethical culture of the company. Ethical cultures tend to be self-perpetuating because the people within the organization will hold themselves and their co-workers accountable. When you look at a company like Enron, large parts of that company were devoid of ethical standards, so it was much easier for the frauds to occur. Enron also highlights the need

Ethics Personal Differences and Preferences
Words: 1464 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

She has two strong motivating reasons to not report the bribery. She could lose her work status in the United States and she would jeopardize her ability to receive her education. She owes herself and her partner a duty of care as well, to place value on her education and her ability to live in Chicago and therefore maintain the relationship. For Valerie, these considerations are powerful, since Waters'

Ethics Review Committee -- Crisis Management Ethics
Words: 1542 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Ethics Review Committee -- Crisis Management Ethics Review Committee Relative Values of Proactive and Reactive Thinking in Determining an Action Plan The first consideration is to limit immediate and future damages to the firm. Two courses of action must be undertaken: Crisis communications and client relationship management. Both action plans will require consultation with the Legal Department and the Compliance Department. Crisis Communications A position of managing the company's reputation and ensuring it survival must

Ethics of Legalizing Marijuana in Recent Years,
Words: 2473 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Ethics of Legalizing Marijuana In recent years, there has been a significant amount of debate as to whether or not the possession and usage of marijuana should be legalized. Several issues revolve around this topic, not the least of which are the perceived and actual effects of this particular narcotic in a psychological, physical, economic, and even social sense. Perhaps one of the best methods for determining a prudent choice of

Ethics and Advance Directives Ethics
Words: 3485 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

According to this second view, contemporaneous autonomy trumps precedent autonomy because honoring precedent autonomy imposes preferences and values of a different person, the formerly competent self (Buccafumi, p. 14). The role that patient's families, doctors, health aides, pastors, chaplains and administrators, health educators and others play is crucial. Few people have executed an advanced directive, much less appointed a healthcare power of attorney by the time they enter a hospital

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now