Verified Document

Canadian Senate Essay

Canadian Senate Politics in all its varied forms and nuances across both the free and undemocratic world share a common feature. In all its forms, politics is complicated. This is perhaps especially so for political leaders and entities whose function has become either redundant or unclear over the centuries of their existence. In addition to the general pitfalls of corruption and ineffective leadership, some entities face becoming obsolete in the face of current needs and structures within their states. One such entity is the Canadian Senate.

Over the past decades, there have been increasing public and academic debates about the continued validity, or lack thereof, of the Canadian Senate. Indeed, if reports in recent news are to be taken at face value, there appears to have been a recent increase in the scandals and general embarrassment among members of the Canadian Senate, which have resulted in an increase in calls for abolishing the institution.

While some have debated for the reform of the Senate, there have been increasing calls for its abolishment, based on the fact that the institution is fundamentally undemocratic, has been ineffective in its leadership, and has weathered an increase in personal and financial scandals.

To examine the current functioning of the Canadian Senate, Thomas (2013) refers to its history. During the U.S. Civil War, the Fathers of the Confederation were deeply enmeshed in an attempt to not only manage the war, but also to understand and possibly discourage the mindsets and viewpoints that caused it to begin with. One of these was what Sir John A. Macdonald, one of the Fathers, believed to be "mob rule" and "presidential despotism," the explosive combination of which caused the War.

Hence, in response, the Canadian Senate was an effort to derail the evils of particularly "mob rule," or indeed democracy. To do this, certain requirements were put in place, and remain in place today for a person wishing to secure a seat in the Canadian Senate. Interestingly, one of these is to be a property owner. Originally, the justification behind this was that the "responsibility" of voting should be left to...

In this way the "dangers" associated with the "unreasoning" masses are removed from government. Hence, those who expect to lead the country effectively through their membership in the Senate must also be property owners. This remains a qualifying requirement within the Canadian Senate today (Thomas 2013). This, however, is not the only outdated element retained within the Senate. Indeed, according to Thomas (2013), the "unelected assembly" of individuals serving within the institution simply ignore commonly held democratic principles. An example of this is laws passed by a House of Commons majority being denied by the Senate.
On the other hand, when the Canadian Senate is not in the process of violating the rights of he citizens it serves, it has little to occupy its time. According to Wherry (2013), the Senate has played a far less than prominent role in Canadian politics since the centralization of power into the Prime Minister's Office. Hence, it is not only in principle that the Senate has lost its viability, but also in fact.

Overall, an increasing number of citizens are beginning to feel that the Canadian Senate is highly ineffective due to its outdated principles and modes of operation. These, however, are not the only bases cited to call for its abolishment. The Senate has a significantly less than proud history of corruption, embarrassment, and "cronyism" within its walls.

Wherry (2013), for example, makes particular note of the various embarrassments and cases of corruption within the Senate. He cites the 1930s Beauharnais scandal, which saw two Liberal senators as personal beneficiaries of a government constructed hydro dam. This trend is evident in more recent scandals as well, where Senators' personal finances as benefiting from the public purse has come under significant and public scrutiny. This has severely eroded what was left of the Senate's reputation in the public mind, and has further fueled calls for its dissolution.

Indeed, even political officials such as Premier Brad Wall refers to the Senate as and "anachronistic, completely…

Sources used in this document:
References

De Souza, M. (2013), Jul. 23). Abolish the senate because reform is 'never going to happen': Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall. National Post. Retrieved from: http://news.nationalpost.com/2013/07/23/abolish-the-senate-because-reform-is-never-going-to-happen-saskatchewan-premier-brad-wall/

Macfarlane, E. (2013, Jul. 22). What do we really want to do with the Senate? Macleans. Retrieved from: http://www2.macleans.ca/2013/07/22/what-do-we-really-want-to-do-with-the-senate/

Thomas, G. (2013, Jul 29). If Canadians vote to abolish the Senate, politicians must listen. The Star. Retrieved from: http://www.thestar.com/opinion/commentary/2013/07/29/if_canadians_vote_to_abolish_the_senate_politicians_must_listen.html

Wherry, A. (2013, Mar. 8). Why the Senate should be abolished. Macleans. Retrieved from: http://www2.macleans.ca/2013/03/08/why-the-senate-should-be-abolished/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Canadian Politics Canada Is a
Words: 2275 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

A head of state could be chosen by indirect election by parliament, as one example. This is similar to the current process, however, in the new process, the Governor-General would be made by provincial or federal legislatures as opposed to being selected by the Prime Minister and then formally appointed by the Queen. Another way to go would be to have the head of state chosen by indirect election by

Canadian Federal Elections Low Voter
Words: 3346 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

but, the one thing Pammet and LeDuc note that given the analyses in their report, it is suggested that the decline in voter turnout is likely to continue for some time. When those that indicated that they hadn't voted were asked "What was the main reason you did not cast a ballot?," Pammet and LeDuc received a variety of responses. Some of the answers they received concerned a decrease interest in

Canadian Human Rights and Civil
Words: 1385 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

They always expect the court decisions to be consistent with the objectives on social and economic policies. However, in any given case, the Supreme Court is persistent as to the inherent uncertainty of any result. Although the public's opinion is correct, the Supreme Court has the right and duty to uphold its unbiased decision. Another question that may arise is - "Is the Charter applicable only to Canadian citizens?" In

Canadian History Ten Thousand Years Before Europeans
Words: 989 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Canadian History Ten thousand years before Europeans set foot on the vast territories now known as Canada, indigenous peoples resided there. In fact, the name "Canada" derives from a native word meaning "village." The first Europeans to land on Canadian soil were Nordic Vikings from Greenland who accidentally discovered the richly forested regions of northern Newfoundland before 1000 and set up small settlements specifically to harvest lumber for their homes in

A Key Element Impacting Canadian Healthcare Has Been Long Term Care...
Words: 1988 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Long-Term Care Sustainability as a Major Issue Affecting Canadian Healthcare System The Canadian Health Act (CHA) provides that provincial governments should cover the entire cost of hospital and physician services. There are however two components that the CHA doesn't require provincial governments to pay for including two other components of healthcare; drug costs and non-acute care provided in nursing homes and other kinds of long-term care facilities. Thus, it is up

Canadian Canada Is One of the Largest
Words: 1775 Length: 6 Document Type: Capstone Project

Canadian Canada is one of the largest countries in Northern America, covering more than 9 million square metres. It has a population of over 31 million people. Even though the country is ethnically diverse, two main languages the people use are English and French. The Canadians use these two official languages. This makes it a bilingual country. People whose ancestry is British make the largest percentage of the people who

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now