Verified Document

Business Law And The Movie Philadelphia Book Review

Philadelphia The managers at the law firm were confronted by the dilemma regarding Beckett's AIDS. There are two elements to the dilemma. The first is the question of whether Beckett's illness was going to challenge his competency. The second is how they should approach the issue of his AIDS and homosexuality, which seems to have been a problem for some of them. Wheeler has been a valuable asset to the firm, so there is a dilemma related to their desire to fire him and the duty of care that they owe him for his service to the firm.

The managers were not justified in firing Andrew. This is an ethical decision, rather than a legal one. Neither the Civil Rights Act of 1964 nor latter statutes...

The Americans with Disabilities Act, however, might cover Beckett. Ethically, however, I believe that a Kantian approach is appropriate, because there is no particular harm that would come to anybody other than Beckett as a result of either choice. The avoidance of doing harm is a good imperative to follow here.
3. That Beckett concealed his illness is important. If he has any protections, they are under the ADA. However, if the firm did not know that he had an illness -- whether that qualifies him under the ADA or not -- then they could easily argue that he was fired for performance or homosexuality. Either one would have been legal. Beckett's illness can only be a defense if he can argue that the firm fired him because of it -- if they did not know about it then that line of argument evaporates.

4. Miller is morally obliged to accept Beckett's case because he is a personal injury lawyer, and because he knows Beckett. Miller has a duty to take on such a case because of what it represents in terms of the law -- the opportunity to break new ground. Miller may also feel a sense of obligation to a fellow lawyer who has not been treated fairly.

5. Miller finally accepts the case in part because of…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Movie Scene Analysis of 12
Words: 1862 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

The way the racist juror was dressed and groomed indicated a lack of class and personal pride. He was an ignorant man who had worked hard all his life, had risen to a level in society where he was above minorities and other impoverished Americans, but still not as well off as he would like to be. He had a deep seeded anger at his position in society which

Firm Australia Business Philippine. Some Risks Considered
Words: 3597 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

firm Australia business Philippine. Some risks considered Philippine;, business environment Philippine specific firm. It . A marketing assignment format, focus specific firm. Topic: The firm work a business analyst strongly interested expanding current manufacturing sales ( domestic export) activity markets. Globalization is an obvious trend that is catching on all over the world. Australia has also not been left behind in this. This has led to some Australian firms turning

Coca-Cola Business and Operations
Words: 2707 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Coca-Cola leads the world's beverage industry with as many as 400 products and has its presence globally in more than 200 countries. In addition to this, Coca-Cola collaborates with some 320 licenses to produce more than 10000 products in 57 countries. Products range from fashion apparel to holiday decorations and even a Coca-Cola Picnic Barbie doll. Every year, licensees sell 50 million licensed Coca-Cola products. Internal Business Environment Core Activities For over 100

SLP and International Business Analysis
Words: 11586 Length: 34 Document Type: Essay

political scenario illustrated that governments all over the globe are making their immigration rules more stringent because of the rise in terrorism; the implication of this phenomenon is a decrease in international traveling, which endangers continuance of a number of airlines, including Nigeria's Arik Air (Eze, 2010). Hofstede's power distance dimension denotes the degree to which unequal distribution of power is anticipated and accepted by the lower ranking members

Silhouette of America's Dream: Negro
Words: 6280 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

") When Johnson defeated Jeffries, however, it unleashed white violence against blacks nationwide. "In Washington, D.C., the Washington Bee reported, 'White ruffians showed their teeth and attacked almost every colored person they saw upon the public streets'." Similar events occurred in New York City and tiny towns in the deep South. By the time Jackie Robinson left the Negro Leagues, the backlash was not nearly so pronounced. Arguably, the Negro Leagues kept

Applying to Medical Schools in the North East
Words: 15719 Length: 56 Document Type: Admission Essay

Essay 2: In what collegiate extracurriculars did you engage? (400 characters) As Vice President of Phi Kappa Sigma, I co-managed the annual $30k budget, participated in 100+ hours of community service, volunteered for the Rutgers Dance Marathon, raised funds for the Embrace the Kids Foundation, and organized the annual Phi-Esta fundraiser for the Eric Legrand’s Foundation with several other fraternities. I also volunteered for the Leukemia Lymphoma Society. Essay 3: Did you

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now