Verified Document

British Literatures Essay

¶ … Modest Proposal Jonathan Swift's satirical work A Modest Proposal is particularly successful at lambasting careless attitudes towards the poor because Swift's proposal that poor children be sold as food for the upper classes is rendered in the language of pseudo-scientific argument and economics. When deployed elsewhere, this combination of tone, appeals to authority, and abrogation of evidence is precisely the kind of language used to support various misguided, outdated, or bigoted ideologies, such as any number of various "scientific" works purporting to demonstrate the superiority of whites over blacks, or men over women, for example. In Swift's case, however, the tone he adopts and the logical fallacies he engages in function precisely to reveal themselves, so that Swift's use of these common tactics is a means of pointing them out and revealing that they are in fact tactics, or rhetorical methods used to support an otherwise insupportable argument. By performing a close reading of the beginning of Swift's essay, one can see how the particular tone the narrator adopts, the inclusion of numbers and statistics without any evidence, and appeals to upper class authority are meant to criticize the mode of argumentation so frequently deployed by those seeking to promote insupportable arguments; thus, Swift's goal is not only to shed light on the plight of the urban poor, but also to directly challenge the means by which that plight is perpetuated through pseudo-scientific discourse.

The first crucial thing to note about A Modest Proposal is the sanctimonious tone adopted by the narrator which serves to reveal the true concerns of both the narrator and the upper class of which he is ostensibly a part....

A cursory reading might suggest that the narrator is concerned with the difficulties of the poor, but a closer examination reveals that the narrator's concern is wholly for the observers "who walk through this great town, or travel in the country," and whose experiences are marred by the "melancholy" they feel at the site of beggars and impoverished children (Swift 1). The problem is not that these people are poor and starving, but rather that their poverty and starvation mars the aesthetic experience of the country. Thus it is only natural that the solution proposed by the narrator does not have anything to do with combating the underlying causes of poverty, but rather concerns itself with making poverty less visible and using the poor in a way that more directly benefits the upper classes. However, by describing the image of beggars and their children in stark detail, the narrator is able to effectively pretend that his forthcoming proposal is oriented towards their well being, in the same way that discriminatory practices and policies are often proposed as being "in the best interest" of the group being discriminated against.
Following the narrator's vivid description of the poor in Ireland and the adoption of a disingenuously compassionate tone, the narrator begins to discuss the situation in pseudo-scientific and economic terms, claiming that "having turned my thoughts for many years, upon this important subject, and maturely weighed the several schemes of our projectors, I have always found them grossly mistaken in their computation" (Swift 2). He begins claiming that a child may be supported by its mother's milk for up to a year "with little other nourishment: at most not above the value of two shillings" (Swift 2). That he begins by quantifying the cost of raising a child up to a year old not only hints at the full-blown commodification of children that will occur over the course of the essay, but also demonstrates the comedic incongruity between the feigned concern discussed above and the perceived objectivity that comes from the inclusion of numbers. Thus, the narrator begins by playing on the reader's emotion in order to catch his or…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Swift, Jonathan. A Modest Proposal. New York: Forgotten Books, 2008.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

British Literature What We Can Do for
Words: 2089 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

British Literature What we can do for another is the test of powers, what we can suffer for another is the test of love." This I believe is the underlying theme, the thesis, if you will, that lingers in the mind long after reading Oscar Wilde's An Ideal Husband and Robert Lewis Stevenson's The Beach of Falesa. They are literary masterpieces that play on human emotions, that build on human relationships, that

British Literature an Elephant Shooting
Words: 461 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

E.M. Forster's the Life to Come, on the other hand, is a tale divided into four parts: Night, Evening, Day and Morning. Its main character is a young missionary by the name of Paul Pinmay who is sent to spread the word of Christ to the native people. All prior attempts to proselytise these people have failed. During his attempt he meets with the tribal chief, who approaches him to

British Literature Geoffrey Chaucer's Canterbury
Words: 3052 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Neither lust, nor greed, nor vanity, is necessary to account for betrayal: it is the simple and inevitable reflex of the changeability that is the very life of human beings."(Mann, 19) Thus, the discourse of the Wife of Bath should be seen rather in this light, than as an antifeminist one. In fact, her prologue is to be read rather like a purposeful unmasking of the many antifeminist stereotypes circulated

British Literature Romanticism to Present
Words: 580 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

British Lit. Romanticism to Present Following the liberating Age of Reason, the Enlightenment, the age when humanity was triumphing through literature and Rousseau's philosophy was inspiring revolutions, the age of Romanticism saw the birth of some genius writers of its own. Among them, Lord Byron, a man who lived his thirty-six years with the intensity of one who wants to know it all and do it all, was a prolific writer

20th Century British Literature. Specifically
Words: 2023 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

In fact, all these novels are concerned with the psychology and attitudes of the characters, and use them to represent the fragmentation and uncertainty in society. The characters own lives are uncertain and fragmented, and this represents these themes in society at large. Rhys also wanted to confront areas of British society that remained hidden and unacknowledged in her novel. In "Jane Eyre," the character's madness is simply alluded to,

Literature Drama
Words: 1189 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

records court transcripts from "The Trials of Oscar Wilde," when the opposing council at the trial asks the defendant, Oscar Wilde, if he kissed one of the boys whom Wilde was supposed to have engaged in homosexual practices, Wilde appears unfazed. When asked if he kissed the boy, Wilde, with customary wit, responded that he did not, because "he was a very ugly boy." This kind of exchange forces

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now