Verified Document

Bookseller Of Kabul, By Asne Reaction Paper

As sometimes the author hints, their lives are not their own, but their path in life is what their family and society directs. As with the teaching certificate that Leila is trying hard to obtain, the more she got into the Afghan bureaucracy, the harder the process is, until it become almost improbable. Selerstad offers the perspective of a world in which women and children have no or little say in their lives. What surprises is not the rules or customs that the Afghan Islamic world has, but the passivity of women, in this case. Although aware that things could and should be a bit more different, they do not act against the current because it is too hard. It seems that not only a sort of courage is missing here, but also a more common vision for the women in the Khan world for example. When a situation becomes more and more difficult, the women in Leila's family do not encourage her or help her in her courageous desires, but pull her back into the burka world. As Leila joins an English class, she discovers that in her class there are many boys. Her fear of talking without permission in public, her ingrained sense of humility makes her doubt her own capabilities and English knowledge. This, alongside with the pulling back mentioned before, make her quit another dream that she had.

One of the things that the author points in the book regarding family relations, with a strong effect on the societal relations, is therefore the weak or non-existent support that girl or young boys receive from family members. As Leila encounters a young man that also believes in her dreams of continuing education and working, her family does all that they can to push her away from a different type of life than the one inscribed on her. Mansur, her brother, works together with her mother, Sharifa, to push the young man...

Although the author describes only one family, one could extrapolate and think that if women in a relatively upper-middle class with a family head considered to be an intellectual with some liberal views are treated in this manner, than other women are treated worse. In the non-urbanized huge space of Afghanistan, were books, foreigners or electricity (to name a few) have not arrived in a proper manner, women, most likely have amazingly hard times. As many of the stories that the book describes, women can be humiliated, beaten up or even killed if they don't follow the traditional way of living. As a relative of the Khan family was caught to have been involved in a secret affair she was killed by her two brothers on the request of their mother. Another striking story is that of a girl that started to have a relationship with a young man and was almost killed by her family for that.
The wall that surrounds the free mind of Afghan women can be synthesized as the burka. They are covered as if their ideas, dreams or thoughts are to be kept inside. Their role and influence, as described by Seierstad, is limited to the boundaries of society and anything that is outside of this can be punished. The book does not tell only the story of a book seller from Kabul. It tells the story of how religion, society, dogmas and culture have an effect on what other cultures perceive as normality. It tells the story of how women and children are stuck in a system that keeps them inside their minds in a fearful and hopeless way.

Seierstad, Asne. The Bookseller of Kabul. New York. Back Bay Books. 2004

Sources used in this document:
Women, even in the liberated non-Taliban world, were not liberated at all. Although the author describes only one family, one could extrapolate and think that if women in a relatively upper-middle class with a family head considered to be an intellectual with some liberal views are treated in this manner, than other women are treated worse. In the non-urbanized huge space of Afghanistan, were books, foreigners or electricity (to name a few) have not arrived in a proper manner, women, most likely have amazingly hard times. As many of the stories that the book describes, women can be humiliated, beaten up or even killed if they don't follow the traditional way of living. As a relative of the Khan family was caught to have been involved in a secret affair she was killed by her two brothers on the request of their mother. Another striking story is that of a girl that started to have a relationship with a young man and was almost killed by her family for that.

The wall that surrounds the free mind of Afghan women can be synthesized as the burka. They are covered as if their ideas, dreams or thoughts are to be kept inside. Their role and influence, as described by Seierstad, is limited to the boundaries of society and anything that is outside of this can be punished. The book does not tell only the story of a book seller from Kabul. It tells the story of how religion, society, dogmas and culture have an effect on what other cultures perceive as normality. It tells the story of how women and children are stuck in a system that keeps them inside their minds in a fearful and hopeless way.

Seierstad, Asne. The Bookseller of Kabul. New York. Back Bay Books. 2004
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Reactions to Death
Words: 1544 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Aging Reactions & Meditations Upon Death To start, the paper must commence with acknowledgement that there are many beliefs and traditions surrounding the cessation of the physical body. This is a topic of great discussion and emotion in all of human history. This is a topic upon which humans reflect constantly, across culture, country, language, time and distance. In the West, there is a diversity of beliefs, but the predominant beliefs by

Reaction Beautiful Boy
Words: 1002 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Beautiful Boy Reaction to Part I and Part II: Beautiful Boy Stay up late According to David Sheff's memoir of his son's addiction entitled Beautiful Boy, "I tried everything I could to prevent my son's fall into meth addiction. It would have been no easier to have seen him strung out on heroin or cocaine, but as every parent of a meth addict comes to learn, this drug has a unique, horrific quality…He

Reactions in Parents of Children With Life Threatening Illness
Words: 1566 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Psychological Reactions: Parents of Children With Life Threatening Illness This article review will look at a research study that was conducted to determine more precisely what were the effects on parents who were recently given a diagnosis relative to their child that was potentially life threatening. As one might imagine, this can be a stressful situation for any parent. While a reaction that was based on acute stress might seem to

Reaction to Buck Documentary
Words: 733 Length: 2 Document Type: Reaction Paper

Personal Reaction to BUCK Documentary BUCK is a documentary that focuses on telling the real-life story of Dan Brannaman, who is commonly known as Buck throughout the film. Buck is a cowboy with seemingly magical capability to calm uncontrollable horses and travels the country 40 weeks out annually to host different four-day horse clinics. Through this film, Cindy Meehl provides a clumsy but seemingly uncannily story that focuses on the life,

Reaction to Schindler S List
Words: 1773 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Schindler's List is an Oscar-winning movie about World War Two. The movie won Best Picture and several other major awards. The basic premise is the true story of a factory owner, Oskar Schindler, who saves Jews from the Nazis. He employed them in his factories, which makes them important in the war effort for Nazi Germany. This is what saves them from being deported from Krakow to one of the

Reaction to Tweak
Words: 692 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Tweak There are a lot of books and movies about drug addiction and the toll it takes on a person and on their family. Many of these are fiction or biographies about another person. Nic Sheff's book Tweak is his autobiographical account of how he grew up in a household which allowed him to become dependent on drugs and alcohol, although the parents were not directly involved, and how it impacted

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now