Verified Document

Bardach's Eightfold Path Lays Out A2 Coursework

This model of writing, editing, and producing various types of texts requires that each significant point-of-view on an issue be represented fairly. Initially, this would seem to be an excellent policy: After all, the marketplace of ideas (as the Supreme Court has reminded us) is strengthened by adding more ideas, not by subtracting problematic ones. However, when one moves from the abstract to the particular and concrete, the problems with such a strategy become immediately clear. To understand the depths of such a problem, one can consider the current political situation in Libya. A neutral point-of-view would require that a description of what has been happening in February in Libya include Muammar Gaddafi's assessment of what has been happening in the nation that he has ruled for over forty years.

That viewpoint has shifted to some extent from day-to-day, but in general the military leader has argued that Al-Qaeda, Israel, and the United States are drugging young Libyans into attacking their government. The rebels, meanwhile, argue that they are fighting for a more democratic, less corrupt nation. Western nations, as well as some of the other Arab nations, have in general sided with the viewpoint of the rebels, acknowledging the tyranny of Gaddafi's reign. No credible source from the West has suggested that Libyan youths are being drugged by outside forces.

A neutral point-of-view would require that Gaddafi's viewpoint be...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

After all, he is a central figure, someone who has access to a wide range of information, indeed far more information than Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, for example. However, it should be immediately clear that there is a problem with giving equal weight to all significant perspectives. Of course, one can retrospectively fiddle around with how one defines "significant" or "valid" in terms of whose perspective should be considered valid.
But to decide which perspectives to include only after one has determined which of the perspectives is acceptable is to violate the core concept of a neutral point-of-view. To support this model, the person collecting the information must provide all perspectives to the reader and let her audience decide on the relative validity. This happens all too often in journalism when it is being shoddily performed.

The alternative is a process in which an editorial hand is used to weight different perspectives by how reliable they are likely to be. The editor or writer has to be willing to take on the responsibility of determining which viewpoints must be given greater prominence. This can be an uncomfortable position; it is often tempting indeed to make other people do all the decision-making. But one can push the limits of neutrality only so far. At some point, one has to take responsibility for the information that one passes on to others.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Hillary Clinton and Leadership No Other First
Words: 2632 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Hillary Clinton and Leadership No other First Lady in recent history has been as admired and vilified as Hillary Rodham Clinton. Breaking from the mold of her immediate predecessors, Clinton has more in common with her earlier counterparts, like Eleanor Roosevelt, Dolly Madison, Abigail Adams or Mamie Doud Eisenhower. However, many of her predecessors wielded a tremendous amount of power simply through their access to the president. Nancy Reagan, for example, would

Hillary Clinton Personality a Person Cannot Develop
Words: 964 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Hillary Clinton Personality A person cannot develop apart from what they were initially given and what happens to them on a day by day basis. The subject of this report is no different in that respect, but she is very different from most with regard to her ambition and life course. Hillary Clinton was the First Lady of the United States when her husband Bill Clinton was president from 1993 until early

Hillary Clinton Texas As a
Words: 1513 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Standing strong on important issues like universal health care and putting a stop to the war in Iraq, Clinton led a strong presidency that only seemed to fall apart after Super Tuesday, when Obama's lead left Clinton in the dust. But it is Clinton's unlikely victory in Texas that best represents the female candidate's struggle. A unique mixture of success and failure in the state and in the nation

Hillary Clinton Is Now Touted
Words: 999 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR): Bush administration has been criticized for favoring drilling operations in the Wild Life Refuge while Hillary Clinton has not been in favor of drilling there. She has called for limited (safe) drilling and injecting more money and efforts into research for of renewable energy, energy efficiency and other alternates. Gay Marriage: Hillary Clinton is a popular candidate among the gay circles. She has been

Hillary Clinton's Speech Hillary Clinton's
Words: 428 Length: 1 Document Type: Essay

There are many pleas for convincing the audience that she truly wants them to support Obama, but the most powerful is: want you to ask yourselves: Were you in this campaign just for me? Or were you in it for that young Marine and others like him? Were you in it for that mom struggling with cancer while raising her kids? Were you in it for that boy and his mom

Encomium on Hillary Clinton in Recent History,
Words: 640 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Encomium on Hillary Clinton In recent history, no other First Lady has engendered as much admiration and criticism as Hillary Rodham Clinton. While her immediate predecessors were content to wield their influence indirectly or to busy themselves with uncontroversial social projects, Clinton follows in the footsteps of their earlier counterparts. Indeed, Clinton has much more in common with first ladies like Abigail Adams, Dolly Madison and the outspoken Eleanor Roosevelt. Unlike First

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now