Verified Document

Art Analysis: Landscape With The Essay

While Williams writes of the "tingling" of the new year, the "tingling" is not merely natural, not simply the world sprouting into rebirth. It is a very human, manufactured kind of celebration of the world's bounty. Thus to read the painting as a kind of a mockery of Icarus and the artist's desire for transcendence may not be entirely fair. Brueghel, after all could have just shown Icarus falling into the hungry sea, unnoticed by nature. The key to a more nuanced interpretation of the painting is evident in Brueghel's deliberate choice of a perspective. According to David Cole, this is a "crucial aspect" of understanding the poem (Cole 2000). "The landscape and the action are seen from above -- from the viewpoint, in other words, of Daedalus. The force of the picture is thus, I think, to move the viewer not only to recognize the unconcern for catastrophe inherent in the preoccupation of ongoing life, but also to register a horrified protest that it should be so" (Cole 2000). It is Daedalus, after all, who is the real artist, the creator of the wings, not his son. The father sees what his creation has done to his boy. The artist protests the uncaring attitude of the world by showing the world from the father's perspective. The painting is an act of exposure: by making Icarus not central to the poem, the poem is even more horrific and more damning of ordinary people's attitudes towards a suffering artist who is trying to transcend the restrictions of common humanity.

"Perspective allows the painter to make this protest. How is the poet to do it?.... matter-of-fact language, the absence of any punctuation (which I take to indicate an absence of expressive inflection), and of course the explicit assertion of the event's insignificance, all work to understate, if not undercut, the pathos of Icarus's headlong plunge to death [just like the painting]....

And yet the last words of the poem are 'Icarus drowning.' The words resonate, and the splash is not quite unnoticed. The reader is forced to take notice, forced paradoxically not only to see but to feel the painful irony of death in the midst of life" (Cole 2000). The painting forces the reader to be shocked at the lack of concern shown for Icarus' death -- even to be ashamed his or her own initial lack of notice of Icarus' death in the painting. "Williams' remarkable, forceful understatement brilliantly captures the protest expressed through the perspective of Brueghel's painting" (Cole 2000).
From a conceptual art perspective, the poem and the painting are complementary in the way they present Icarus: both painting and poem are unsentimental, yet both are also damning of the discounting of Icarus' Quixotic efforts to fly. "The irony of the death of Icarus, who has always been an emblem for the poet's upward flight that ends in tragedy, is that his death goes unnoticed in the spring -- a mere splash in the sea. The fear of all poets -- that their passing will go 'quite unnoticed' -- is an old and pervasive theme. That Williams reiterates the theme is significant in the life of a poet who always felt the world had never fully recognized his accomplishments' (Roberts 1996).

Works Cited

Cole, David. "William Carlos Williams." The Explicator, 58.3 (Spring 2000).

Excerpted April 2, 2010 at http://www.english.illinois.edu/maps/poets/s_z/williams/icarus.htm

Delahunt, Michael. "Conceptual art." Art Lex. 1996-2010. April 2, 2010.

http://www.artlex.com/ArtLex/c/conceptualart.html

Rodgers, Audrey T. Virgin and Whore: The Image of Women in the Poetry of William Carlos

Williams. 1982. Excerpted April 2, 2010 at http://www.english.illinois.edu/maps/poets/s_z/williams/icarus.htm

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Cole, David. "William Carlos Williams." The Explicator, 58.3 (Spring 2000).

Excerpted April 2, 2010 at http://www.english.illinois.edu/maps/poets/s_z/williams/icarus.htm

Delahunt, Michael. "Conceptual art." Art Lex. 1996-2010. April 2, 2010.

http://www.artlex.com/ArtLex/c/conceptualart.html
Williams. 1982. Excerpted April 2, 2010 at http://www.english.illinois.edu/maps/poets/s_z/williams/icarus.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Orlando Museum Art Analysis: The
Words: 728 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Proposal

Burnham spent most of his life in the early, expanding West in Detroit, Michigan. He worked as sign painter as well as a popular artist of portraits, landscapes, and genre scenes like the Young Artist. Burnham did the Lewis and Clark Expedition from his imagination, and many of his works are stylized and idealized types of Americana. The charm of the young boy drawing on a beer barrel to

Post WWII Art Analysis the Piece of
Words: 658 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Post WWII Art Analysis The piece of art that the paper will analyze is "Sleeping Girl." Roy Lichtenstein painted "Sleeping Girl" in 1964, as part of his work in pop art & pop culture. Another artist who painted in the style of pop art was Andy Warhol, just to add context with whom Lichtenstein kept artistic company. "Sleeping Girl" is a seminal work in a series of paintings in comic book

Landscape With The Flight Into Egypt By Annibale Carracci Baroque
Words: 2325 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Essay Topic Examples 1. The Evocation of Emotion in Annibale Carracci's "Landscape with the Flight into Egypt": Exploring Baroque Sensibilities ����This essay would delve into the emotional landscape that Annibale Carracci creates in his painting "Landscape with the Flight into Egypt" and how it exemplifies key aspects of Baroque art. The description of light, shadow play, and the drama depicted in the artwork will be central to understanding how Carracci evokes a

Art History Certainly, After Proceeding
Words: 1299 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

The above perception of the insanity of life is not at all apparent in the second painting of Georges Seurat. While it is mystical, it gives too much quiescence that is there with the impressionistic style. This like Picasso's painting above is a happy trip and does not exhibit as much negative energy as Picasso. He also does not seem to be trying to summon any primitive energies. Rather Seurat's

Art Currently on Loan From the Frick
Words: 1980 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Art Currently on loan from the Frick Collection in New York, Hans Memling's "Portrait of a Man" is unique among paintings in the Norton Simon Museum, which does not otherwise boast a collection heavy in Flemish art. The Memling portrait is executed in oil on oak panels, and completed in the mid-1470s. It is relatively small in scale, at just over a foot high and nine inches wide. The museum's description of

Art of Colonial Latin America
Words: 1933 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

Admittedly, these two teams were faced with a daunting challenge in acquiring and interpreting those works of art that were most appropriate for their exhibition goals, and interpretive efforts must use some framework in which to present the resources in a fashion that can be understood and appreciated by the targeted audiences. Nevertheless, there is little or no discussion concerning the fusion of artistic styles in the two catalogs, with

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now