Verified Document

Argument Classical Arrangement Term Paper

¶ … Court Was Correct: Silva Deserves to Teach Exordium:

OJ Simpson was one thing; this time, the courts got it right. Professor Silva used questionable teaching methods, yes, but the federal court's decision was correct: Any possible improprieties did not amount to sexual harassment, and indeed fell into the category of protected speech under the First Amendment of the United States Constitution. As a result, exonerating Silva and reinstituting him with pay is the only possible correct result.

Narratio:

J. Donald Silva was a tenured Communications professor at the University of New Hampshire's Thompson School of Applied Science. (Court, 1) In his lectures in class, Silva once compared writing's focus to sexual activity, and on another occasion elucidated the meaning of a simile with a famed belly dancer's description of her craft. (Greve, 12)

Several female students complained that Silva's comments were inappropriate, and the University Appeals Board suspended him without pay for a year and asked him to begin counseling. The sanctions stemmed from the fact that he was in violation of the University's Sexual Harassment Policy.

Silva sued, and the court found that the University violated Silva's right to free speech and reinstated him to his position with full pay.

Partitio

Silva did not sexually harass anyone by making the "offending" comments in class. Sexual harassment has ceased to focus on harm to individuals, and has instead begun to implicate any impropriety at all, and this is unjustified.

Also, Silva has a constitutional...

Silva used the sexual analogies well within his pedagogical style, and they served to advance his lectures and discussions. As a result, he did nothing wrong, and his free speech rights remain paramount.
Finally, firing Silva would set a very dangerous precedent for university professors nationwide. Certain topics do justify and necessitate frank sexual discussions, and forcing the professors to skirt the issues only harms the students in the long run; and in some occasions may even preclude the professors from doing their appointed jobs: Sexual discussions are often necessary to understand complex texts or sociological phenomenon, and simply disallowing free speech because it is of sexual nature in the classroom is too draconian a solution.

Confirmatio

Linda Hirshman is not at all thrilled with the district court's decision in Silva's case. She, though for a long time skeptical of sexual harassment suits, is of the firm belief that professors and teachers often use their exalted status simply to sexually harass: "Yet the more I know about the offending teachers, the more I realize that what really matters to them is the privilege of sexual abuse. The academics' attachment to acting out has made me realize the importance of this issue." (Hirshman, 511)

In fact, Hirshman even cites that her professors managed to teach their classes without sexual references. Michael Greve responds by saying, it seems, "Congratulations." He believes that the lines have been blurred between harmful and innocuous speech: "The current legal rules, which define a 'hostile environment' on the basis of a case-by-case, multifactor analysis and with reference to the perception of a 'reasonable person,' are exceedingly vague. By that very virtue, they deter not only genuine harassment but also harmless and desirable speech; faced with legal uncertainty, individuals will avoid any speech that might be interpreted as creating a hostile environment." (Greve, 512)

Jeffrey Tobin agrees. He cites Paula Jones' and Monica Lewinsky's cases and notes that sexual harassment is no longer about harm to the victim; it is actually now about simple impropriety. To punish for impropriety is far too close to punishing for bad morals, or bad thoughts. Indeed, that is a very logical extrapolation of the…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Pop Is Tomorrow's Classical- Paul Mccartney. Discuss
Words: 3141 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Pop is tomorrow's Classical"- Paul McCartney. Discuss this contention within the context of rock/classical music collaborations since the early 1950s. Classical Rock and Popular Prophecy To the average music-listener, musical genres are easily divided into homogenous groupings without any danger of overlapping one another. Certainly, there are rare occurrences of "cross-over" hits on the radio that find airplay on both Adult Contemporary and Country stations, or those releases which find an

Development of Classical Conditioning by Pavlov and Its Current Use...
Words: 5439 Length: 11 Document Type: Research Paper

classical conditioning by Pavlov and its current use in treating anxiety The paper focuses on the development of classical conditioning being used, as suggested by Pavlov, in treating anxiety through using fear-induced techniques. The paper talks about the past experiments that were done on animals and human, those who were suffering from anxiety and those who weren't, and highlights how anxiety is treated through fear induced conditioning. Combination of neutral stimulus

Democracy the Classical Features of
Words: 3340 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

15). He argues that there is a duty resting on convention, which he considers in a deep and morally weighty sense, based on an implied but nonetheless binding contract between the individual and the state: It is a fact, then," they would say, "that you are breaking covenants and undertakings made with us, although you mad them under no compulsion of misunderstanding, and were not compelled to decide in a limited

Youthful Offenders in British Legal
Words: 2150 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

" (Social Services Policy Center - Britain, 2005) Further stated is that "Most offenders in the UK are dealt with by non-custodial sentences. Custodial sentences for indictable offences by adults account for less than one sentence in five, while fines cover more than a third of all offences. About a fifth are given intermediate sentences like probation or community service. The Probation Service (in England and Wales) administers supervision in the

Central Banks What Criteria Are,
Words: 10788 Length: 35 Document Type: Dissertation

Under the arrangement, moreover, a country with efficient production and a favored competitive position (including as enhanced by new capital goods) is rewarded with rising income and reduced unemployment. No grand scheme of state or international planning and direct control is required. Exchange rates are for the most part fixed under the classical gold-flows mechanisms (say, $/£ const. within fixed limits), as stated, and adjustments to trade imbalances

Financial Systems, Economic Growth, and
Words: 2741 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

This aspect of the study were inclusive of works of "economic historians on the development of financial systems" most particularly the "banking systems" worldwide and exactly what the resulting impact will be. (Rousseau & Sylla, 2001) While the two identified "strands of literature" one dealing with domestic and the other international developments, are no always related to one another" but are however, both elements of the story called financial

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now