Verified Document

App Fallacy, A Columnist New York University's Essay

¶ … App Fallacy," a columnist New York University's Washington Square News argues wisdom Common Application college application process. You read essay college newspaper; opportunity responds. The fallacy of "The Common App Fallacy"

The Common Application is a standardized application that makes it very easy for college students to apply to a multitude of schools, all of which use its basic format. A student merely has to fill out the forms associated with the Common Application once and then can send the form electronically to a wide range of institutions spanning from Cornell University to the University of Miami to The College of New Jersey. According to NYU student Damon Beres, it has made it too easy to apply to college, particularly competitive colleges, with a touch of a 'send' button. Beres cites statistics which indicate only a very tiny minority of highly qualified students are able to get into the Harvards and Yales of the world. Beres sees this as an injustice: by encouraging too many people to apply to too many schools using the Common Application, many of his fellow, qualified students are being turned away. Beres' solution and logic is simple: do away with this universal app and numbers will magically decrease and so will competition to get into the nation's top colleges. However, despite his impressive academic pedigree as an NYU undergraduate, Beres' logic is extremely flawed.

First and foremost, Beres' analysis does not take into account the full reality of applying to an elite school through the Common Application. Almost all of the major colleges that accept the Common...

While it may indeed be easier for students to apply to a few less-competitive schools on the Common Application that do not require supplementary materials, this would not solve what Beres sees as the main problem facing academia today, namely an overabundance of applicants for elite institutions, which he feels makes competition absurdly high even for the most hard-working and intellectually gifted of seniors.
Having separate applications would merely mean students would have to fill in their identifying name and school information on different forms for NYU, Harvard, Dartmouth, and so forth. This would be unlikely to deter an applicant from applying who had been honing his or her high school resume in the hopes of being accepted at a top school. In other words, it is assuming that the most competitive candidates are so lazy they will not bother to fill in a few extra lines on a separate application and will reduce the number of schools they apply to as a result. (Remember, they already have to do the 'hard work' of writing extra essays to apply to these schools, even using the Common Application). Finally, the mere fact that applications are online facilitates the process. Even if there was no Common Application, students can still fill out an online form with far greater ease than a paper form, thus increasing the potential they will apply to more schools (based upon Beres' logic). The Internet enables students to research a wider variety of schools than was possible in the…

Sources used in this document:
Work Cited

Beres, Damon. "The Common App Fallacy." Washington Square News, 22 Jan 2008:1-2.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

College Entrance Describe a Character
Words: 703 Length: 2 Document Type: Application Essay

She is testimony to the fact that human beings, even if their bodies may be slaughtered, cannot die, so long as they strive to make lasting legacies of their lives. Even after Anne perished in a concentration camp, her day-to-day chronicle of her life, encompassing everything from her first menstruation to the careful watch the Secret Annex dwellers kept upon the doings of the war, lives on. Often, I too

College Admission and Financial Aid
Words: 6362 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Federal admission issues Before one can even consider the issue of whether or not illegal immigrants should be eligible for financial aid, one must first investigate whether or not these students are even permitted to attend American institutes of higher education. Like the other questions addressed in this paper, there is no clear answer to this question. At this time, there is no federal law prohibiting illegal immigrants from attending institutes

College Application for Immigrant My Name Is
Words: 647 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

College Application for Immigrant My name is XXXXXXX. I came to the United States two years ago, and spent my first year attending English as Second Language (ESL) courses, in order to improve my English skills. While I still struggle with some of the finer points of writing and speaking English, my vocabulary and understanding of the English language has improved greatly. From this experience, I realized that mastery of the

College Admissions Quotas Despite Recent
Words: 703 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Due to the racial mixture of the Brazilian people, affirmative action is failing its intended goal. However, Rochetti does see how this system could benefit the population of Brazil with some benefits. In order to help bridge the gap between the rich educated Brazilians and the poor, uneducated people there, Rochetti believes that admission quotas should be used based not solely on an individual's race, but rather their class

College Application Have Always Been
Words: 559 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

This will certainly prove very helpful in my career as a speech pathologist or any related field. I have been in this field for ten years. And I know that it's a long time. But for some reason I find myself very motivated and highly interested in this field only. I have no plans of switching fields. This seems to be my core purpose in life. I have read about your

College Admission on Why I Have Chosen
Words: 317 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

College Admission on Why I Have Chosen to Become a Physician Assistant The reason I have chosen to become a physician's assistant is based on my desire to be a part of the medical community. I have always had great respect for those who chose to dedicate their lives to helping others, whatever their field of career. However, the medical community holds a strong attraction for me because it is

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now