Verified Document

American Healthcare Michael Moore's Movie Essay

Admittedly, there have been some minor improvements since 2007. Specifically, legislation enacted in 2009 by President Barack Obama eliminated the ability of health insurance companies to exclude certain individuals from coverage and to deny coverage to beneficiaries in need of expensive healthcare services by simply canceling their policies. That legislation extended the maximum age that children may remain on their parents' policies as well. Unfortunately, the Obama administration essentially gave up on pursuing the most important necessary changes such as by abandoning the "public option" that the President emphasized in his election campaign.

The Advantages and Disadvantages of Government-Run Healthcare

In principle, government-run healthcare is far preferable to private-sector-run healthcare for the same reason that government control is necessary over other essential commodities and services. In the absence of government control, the private sector will exploit every conceivable opportunity for profit, even at the expense of human lives. Moore's film documents the callous manner in which health insurance companies routinely deny coverage exploiting legal loopholes in their contractual obligations and the virtual futility of individual patient's efforts to overcome those obstacles to receiving the care...

Certainly, the picture Moore paints of healthcare in Cuba underrepresented some of the relative inadequacies of that system; the same may be true of Moore's depiction of healthcare in Canada. In general, the more that government becomes responsible for healthcare services, the longer patients will inevitably have to wait for non-emergency services and the less flexibility they may have in terms of providers. However, there is not reason that government-run healthcare necessarily need to be implemented on an all-or-none basis. Britain's very successful National Health Service (NHS), for example, allows patients to supplement the cost of services to increase their options over those available exclusively at the government's expense (Kennedy, 2006; Reid, 2009). Ultimately, the most sensible solution might be the very one first championed and later abandoned by President Obama: namely, to establish a public option that would compete with the private sector and thereby maintain a natural cap on prices through the traditional dynamics of the marketplace. Without a doubt, that, and the eventual elimination of the control over legislators enjoyed by healthcare industry lobbyists must be addressed in meaningful ways if healthcare in the U.S. is to remain available to all, rather than just for the wealthy. Despite its flaws and possible one-sided tone, Moore's film contributes in a valuable way to that discourse.
References

Gordon, S., Buchanan, J., Bretherton, T. (2008). Safety in Numbers: Nurse-to-Patient

Ratios and the Future of Health Care. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Kennedy, E. (2006). America: Back on Track. Viking: New York.

Reid, T. (2009). The Healing of America: A Global Quest for Better, Cheaper, and Fairer Health Care. New York:…

Sources used in this document:
References

Gordon, S., Buchanan, J., Bretherton, T. (2008). Safety in Numbers: Nurse-to-Patient

Ratios and the Future of Health Care. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Kennedy, E. (2006). America: Back on Track. Viking: New York.

Reid, T. (2009). The Healing of America: A Global Quest for Better, Cheaper, and Fairer Health Care. New York: Penguin Group.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Healthcare Crisis US Health Care
Words: 1617 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

Universal healthcare is the only saving formula for this nation, which is doomed in a health care crisis of unprecedented proportions. There is a urgent need to transform healthcare from its present state of commercialism towards the humanitarian approach which guarantees 'healthcare for all' independent of their social or financial circumstances. A shared and collective responsibility of healthcare management is the only viable formula for America. It is high

Michael Moore's Sicko
Words: 1397 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Psychology How Sicko is Relevant to Psychology Michael Moore is an American filmmaker that has created a body of work and a niche market for hard hitting documentaries about issues critical to American culture. In 2007, he directed, produced, wrote, and starred in a documentary called, Sicko, about the American healthcare system. Moore's films have a habit of polarizing audiences. Audiences have been known to strongly agree with him and known to

Universal Healthcare the Pros and
Words: 1359 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

Some believe that a universal healthcare system would provide fewer incentives for doctors, who would be less likely to perform at their best. Doctors who are not paid based on their quality may be more likely to perform at a lower quality, some hypothesize. This argument is also used to support the fact that having national health insurance may dissuade those who would be good doctors from going into

Health Care and Healthcare
Words: 1202 Length: 3 Document Type:

health care system delivery with other nations (European/Canada) with emphasis on its relative strengths and weaknesses? Michael Moore's Sicko reveals that nearly 50 million U.S. citizens are not insured, whereas many usually fall prey to insurance firm red tape and frauds. Interviews are carried out with individuals believed to be sufficiently covered; in truth, these individuals do not receive health services at all. Ex-workers of insurance firms explain cost-cutting efforts

Cuban Healthcare in Cuba: An
Words: 1368 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

" The article goes on to say that a correspondent for a Pennsylvanian newspaper who visited the country in 2007 stated, "I asked the guide what Cubans did if they had a cold. The guide said that a Cuban would go to the doctor -- a visit free of charge -- who would write a prescription for aspirin. However, there would be no way to fill the prescription. We visited a pharmacy

Sicko Is a Quintessential Michael
Words: 366 Length: 1 Document Type: Essay

For example, one woman got into a car accident and expected insurance to pay for her expenses related to the accident, minus the deductible. The insurance company denied her claim on the spurious grounds that the woman had a "prior condition" that was unrelated to the accident. If private insurance companies are not fulfilling their obligations to consumers, then public insurance becomes the only solution in a free, just,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now