Verified Document

Administrative Evil As A Social Article Critique

Accordingly, Browder notes that "the discipline of public administration has little sense of its historical circumstances and constantly re-issues 'new' calls for science and rigour. Instead, we must focus more research on critical, historically-based studies." (p. 1) Browder argues that the insertion of administrative evil into such discussions provides just such a basis for consideration. Key Scholars:

The key scholars of importance in this discussion are Adams & Balfour, whose 1998 text Unmasking Administrative Evil is identified as the seminal work on the subject by Dubnick & Justice. Indeed, Adams & Balfour have continued to examine these issues, resolving as recently as 2007 that "the ethical framework within a technical rational system thus posits the primacy of an abstract, utility-maximizing individual, while binding leaders and professionals to organizations in ways that make them into reliable conduits for the dictates of legitimate authority, which is no less legitimate when it happens to be pursuing an unethical or even evil policy." (p. 4) This denotes that today, in the wake of events such as the War in Iraq, the Abu Ghraib prison scandal and Hurricane Katrina, social construct remains a powerful force in shaping the priorities and the ethical orientation of administrative institutions.

Works Cited:

Adams, G.B. & Balfour, D.L. (2007). Leadership, Administrative Evil and the Ethics of Incompetence: Lessons from Katrina and Iraq. The Third Transatlantic Dialogue: University of Delaware.

Browder, G.C. (2001). Book Review: Unmasking Administrative Evil. Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management, 8(3), 173-184.

Dubnick, M.J. & Justice, J.B. (2006). Accountability and the Evil of Administrative Ethics. Administration & Society, 38(2), p. 236.

Order Number

Details

Messages

Pages

Due Date

Subject

Level

3

$30.00

Yes

APA

Public Administration

Article Critique

Dubnick_Ma...

Administrative Evil

Instructions:

Instructions for: Critical Article and Analysis (1...

BUT primary focus is the dissection and brining up the most important points and specific paragraph/quotes referenced please.
READING:

Melvin J. Dubnick and Jonathan B. Justice, "Accountability and the Evil of Administrative Ethics." Administration & Society 38 (May 2006): 236-267.

SUBJECT: Ethics

THEME: Administrative Evil

PURPOSE: Requirements for Critical Article and Analysis Data Mining. I am not seek a Literature Review but rather a review for the purpose of preparing for PhD Pre-Qualifying exams

NOTES:

- data mine the article and classify into categories, i.e. key tenets, pros/cons, application to PA, key scholars/works, etc. -- . (crude example uploaded on the Shields-Taproot article)

- analysis views the article/s within the context of the larger academic discipline. And how it applies to the "Theme"

- As appropriate should consider the background of the book's author, the soundness of the argument and methods, and how the book fits into the larger academic debates raised within Public Administration.

- Review bibliography/references in back of article or book and select relevant follow on readings that would relate directly to the "Theme."

- The critical analysis and review should have a clear structure; for example, it may be organized according to the original book's chapter sequence, arguments, etc.

- argument about the article or book is well supported with necessary details, such as examples or direct quotes.

- Expand and illuminate key concepts by linking to supplementary files (e.g., graphic images, tables, exhibits, audio clips, video clips, and embedded Flash files) from the review.

- Writer is welcome to include in the critical analysis and review which include references to other works -- " such works frequently establish the scholarly conversation around an article or book's topic AND applicability to the specific "them" -- " but make sure that references to outside works are clear and helpful to the review as a whole. In other words, don't refer to an external work just to prove you have read it.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Social Work Antonio Case Study
Words: 2204 Length: 6 Document Type: Case Study

This leads one to believe that they are not very well off financially and the mother has not real education in order to obtain employment since she is currently attaining administrative assistant training. Antonio also has issues with controlling his behavior when in the daycare environment, as he frequently has violent outbursts and crying spells. If one were to assess Antonio from an Eco-Feminist perspective one would be better able

Managing the Social and Ethics Issues in Organizations
Words: 7661 Length: 25 Document Type: Term Paper

Social & Ethical Issues in Management Brief Background/History of Corporation Epitech is a technology company that creates and develops software for administrative use for other corporations. The company was founded in the year 2009 and has since then grown to become one of the renowned software technology companies in the region. The headquarters of the company is situated in the state of Virginia. The company is best known for its Omega software

Global Corporate Governance and Social Responsibility
Words: 2591 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Global Corporate Governance and Social Responsibility Microsoft Corporation An in-depth analysis of all possible factors responsible for the Social efforts Socio-Economic, Cultural, Technological and Legal Factors Strategic ideas involved in addressing corporate social responsibility issues The Unique Composition of Microsoft Creating Better-Quality Products Using Conventional and Contemporary Resources Political acumen In recent years, augmented degree of interest has been shown on the subject of "Corporate Social Responsibility," also known as "CSR." This interest has been shown, both in the

Wal-Mart Social Responsibility Analysis: An Employee Perspective
Words: 2780 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Wal-Mart Social Responsibility Analysis: An Employee Perspective To begin the study "the purpose statement is "a statement that provides the major objective or intent, or "road map" to the study" (Creswell, 2009a, 104).Therefore, the purpose of this narrative is to discuss what employees at various Wal-Mart facilities around the Kansas City area have experienced regarding the social responsibility initiatives undertaken by the company. The method for this particular paper is a

White Collar Crime
Words: 3070 Length: 11 Document Type: Term Paper

Ford Pinto and Corporate Crime Experts on corporate crime such as David O. Friedrichs (1996) used to lament the lack of attention given to white collar crime. This was due to the mistaken assumption that unlike violent street crimes, white collar crimes were victimless and therefore, less harmful. However, recent events such as the recent Firestone tire blowouts, the rollover of Ford's rollover vehicles and Enron Company's padding of profits and Arthur

Business Ethics Case the Examination
Words: 4454 Length: 15 Document Type: Case Study

Alford reports that "for some, the earth moves when they discover that people in authority routinely lie and that those who work for them routinely cover up. Once one knows this, or rather once one feels this knowledge in one's bones, one lives in a new world. Some people remain aliens in the new world forever. Maybe they like it that way. Maybe they don't have a choice." (Alford,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now