Verified Document

Academic Integrity Case Study

Related Topics:

Business Questions on Academic Integrity

Who was most at fault for this situation?

Both Reggie and Arnie were in the wrong, both severely compromised academic integrity by copying the work of another and presenting it as their own. Reggie did not only copy the ideas and present them as his own, he copied the entire text. One may argue that under the circumstances he may have made a bad decision, with the different pressures he had not time to write the paper, as he had more important priorities. However, even allowing for difficult circumstances he undertook a course of action he knew was wrong. This is seen with the conversion he had with Arnie, when he told Arnie not to do the same; he was attempting to ensure that he was not caught. Arnie then made the same decision; to copy from an internet web site, and submit it as his own. However, if Reggie had not told Arnie about the web site, Arnie may not have cheated.

One may ultimately argue that the students are to blame. However, when looking more deeply there may also be some contributory factors. The students had a lot of reading, and do not appear to have understood the subject matter, there may be some consideration of the teaching that took place. However, this does not move the blame, as the students should have approached their teacher to ask for help. One may also argue that had the content not been available, then the student should not have been able to use it. However, there may also be many legitimate uses of the content, such as to increase understanding; therefore it is not the real cause. One could also look at the level of warnings that the collage gave regarding academic integrity; if they were...

However the ultimate blame can only reside with the poor decision made by Reggie who was the cause, and was followed by Arnie.
2.

Was Reggie more at fault than Arnie?

Reggie found the web site and gave Arnie the idea, so one may argue that Reggie has a greater share of the blame. However, Reggie made a decision to copy the web page, and Arnie made the same decision, so both may be seen as to blame. One may argue that it may have been Arnies decision to copy the web site that led to them being caught due tot he similarities in the two papers. However both made the same decision to cheat so both are equally to blame.

3.

Should Dr. Johnson have given Reggie and Arnie an 'F' in the course?

Dr Johnson gave both students an F. When one considers the situation, neither student fulfilled the basic criteria, as neither sent in their own work; therefore an F. is more than fair. The only other options would be to pass or fail the students. If they were passed they would pass a course without doing all of the work, which would be unfair on other students, and as seen in the case, without fully understanding the content. It may be argued that failing the students would also be fair, as the students copied work, and this may also place doubt on past work. However, as a first offence, an F. is fair.

4.

Is it ethical for websites to sell term papers, even if they advertise them as 'for information only?"

This is a difficult question, as just like any other tool that may be used in…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Academic Integrity Different Scholars Have Provided Their
Words: 1452 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Academic Integrity Different scholars have provided their various definitions of academic integrity and narrowed it down to a particular concept. Some define academic integrity as an ethical policy or moral code of academia. Such include values like rigor and honesty within research and academic publishing, maintenance of academic standards and avoidance of plagiarism or cheating. Some have also defined academic integrity as an intellectual honesty; where honesty is based on formulating

Academic Integrity Students the Importance of Academic
Words: 1249 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Academic Integrity Students The importance of academic integrity for students in the criminal justice and security field can not be emphasized enough. Those who are today's students are the criminal justice and security professionals of the future. This short essay will briefly examine issues relating to honesty and integrity in criminal justice and security in the fields of government agencies, corrections, law enforcement, courts or private security. We will present three

Academic Integrity Exercise 1- Academic
Words: 4300 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

It can therefore be concluded that academic integrity and ethical conduct are expected of every learner in all academic procedures. The academic principle represents the honesty in coursework, as well as ethical conduct in clinical, lab, research and homework assignments and should be maintained in all academic communities. Exercise 2- Personal values Personal values Personal values are crucial in both our working and personal lives, in that they help shape own individual systems

Academic Integrity Is a Vital Issue That
Words: 643 Length: 2 Document Type: Application Essay

Academic integrity is a vital issue that carries past school years into careers and the work world in life. It can also affect relationships with peers, family, and other societal members. Schools have strict rules regarding academic integrity to teach students the importance of working hard in honest ways for success, not only in school, but throughout life as well. One of the biggest lessons I have had to learn was

Academic Integrity I Do Not
Words: 2015 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

" 6 (c). Tolstoy's work indicates that materialism brings only temporary happiness. The true value of living is in the love and devotion of family, which brings the ideal of heaven closer to a person's heart. True meaning in life comes in the form of those who would miss and weep for Ivan when he has died. 7. (a) I find the overall tone of the conversation convincing. The dean is very official and

Academic Integrity and Examples of Proper Citation
Words: 485 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Academic Integrity and Examples of Proper Citation Answer the following question: How can these resources help students uphold academic integrity? These resources help students uphold academic integrity by teaching them to understand the difference between appropriate and inappropriate use of source material. More specifically, they define and distinguish verbatim quotations from paraphrasing and mere referencing or crediting the ideas of another author. Probably the most valuable aspect of the material is that

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now