Verified Document

Zeynep Ton's A Minimum Wage Hike Could Article Review

¶ … Zeynep Ton's A minimum wage hike could help employers, too, in the Harvard Business Review. This article is a speculative piece about the effects of proposed minimum wage increases at the federal level. The author takes a look at companies that superior wages and benefits for their industry. The underlying theme is that this is juxtaposed against a common argument that raising the minimum wage will be universally harmful. The common argument takes beginner's level supply and demand graphs and uses them as the basis for the claim. The basic elastic supply and demand graph shows that as the cost of a good increases, demand for that good declines. Thus, if the minimum wage increases, businesses will face higher costs, will pass those costs onto consumers, will suffer lower profits or will reduce employment, or some combination of these negative outcomes. The author here is pointing out that the world is a heck of a lot more complex than that. Microeconomics does not end with the study of rudimentary supply and demand graphs, but incorporates a broader range of considerations into its arguments.

The author highlights a couple of those arguments. The first is the "good jobs strategy." The second is the efficiency concept. The two are at times related. First, microeconomic principles can be used to examine the good jobs strategy. The author cites four firms in particular -- Trader Joe's, Costco, Spanish supermarket chain Mercadona and convenience store chain QuikTrip. The author acknowledges that these companies do not have too many similarities, perhaps except for the nature of the goods they sell -- they are all in convenience and food...

This industry is characterized by a state of monopolistic competition, wherein the players must find ways to differentiate in order to earn profits, because the industry is highly competitive and customers have high bargaining power (ease of switching and substitution). All of these companies are highly successful in their industries despite their counterintuitive view of wages and benefits.
I do not know much of anything about QuikTrip and Mercadona but I do know about Costco and Trader Joe's. Of all the places to buy your food, these are two of the most differentiated. Trader Joe's has a unique buying experience, strong branding and has developed an almost cult-like following. Their customer service standards are high and the stores have a very uniform feel. This points to staff members that are engaged and knowledgeable, and managers who are well-trained in the company's store management strategies and tactics. Trader Joe's is able to accomplish these things by using pay and benefits to increase their pool of applicants -- they get better people. Then, they retain those people better. It is the same situation with Costco -- they have far fewer employees on the store floor, but every store is run very well and management in particular is skilled. Both companies see the value in having better employees and take steps to attract and retain those people.

This is textbook microeconomics, if more complex than the rote "raising the minimum wage is bad" arguments. The minimum wage argument is not a one-sided equation. There are buyers of labor, but there are also sellers…

Sources used in this document:
References

Ton, Z. (2014). A minimum wage hike could help employers, too. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved February 2, 2014 from http://blogs.hbr.org/2014/01/a-minimum-wage-hike-would-help-employers-too/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Minimum Wage
Words: 2529 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Minimum Wage Even though minimum wage has been around for many years, and was established to make sure that working people could survive and pay their bills, there are still many problems with it. This paper address both the pros and cons to raising the minimum wage, discussing not only how people can be helped by the increase in pay, but also how they are ultimately hurt by it to a

Minimum Wage
Words: 960 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Minimum Wage Why the minimum wage should not be abolished in the United States. There are diverse issues that have been debated by politicians and critics concerning the minimum wage in the United States. Some say that the minimum wage causes an increase in the unemployment rate. In turn, it causes negative effects on the nation's economy. However, the truth on this proposition is still to be proven yet. Taking the side

Minimum Wage Is There Anything
Words: 1025 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

The company can also allow a position to go unfilled for a time to increase its leverage; the unskilled worker would starve trying to stall for a higher wage. This again invalidates the argument that the free market can set wages effectively -- it cannot given the imbalance of bargaining power between workers and businesses. The minimum wage serves a specific economic role of balancing the bargaining power between

Minimum Wage History of Minimum
Words: 1398 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Proposal

Only 2.1% of minimum-wage workers belong to a union, versus 12.0% of the overall working population. Nonetheless, labor unions fight passionately for a higher minimum wage (Sherk). When the minimum wage rises, it becomes more expensive to hire unskilled workers. This makes the decision to employ highly paid and highly skilled workers, instead of unskilled workers, more attractive to businesses, and so businesses want to hire more skilled workers (Sherk). With

Minimum Wage Laws Have Always Had a
Words: 591 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Minimum wage laws have always had a high price to pay. Essentially, there are a number of costs associated with governments implementing minimum wages on an otherwise free labor market. First, there is the issue of reconciling increased labor costs with static production profits. According to the research, "Minimum wage increases make unskilled workers more expensive relative to all other factors of production," (Gorman 2008). The increase in wages can

Minimum Wage There Are No
Words: 618 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

This creates a knock-on effect wherein this spending fuels hiring at other companies, whose workers also spend. In contrast, the additional profits earned by corporations as a result abolishing the minimum wage could be invested anywhere in the world and capital gains from stock price improvements are taxed at a relatively low rate. Without a minimum wage, there would be more Americans working, but they would not make enough

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now