Verified Document

Wrongful Convictions Based On Eyewitness Accounts Imagine Essay

Wrongful Convictions Based on Eyewitness Accounts Imagine if you will this hypothetical scenario -- you are walking to your car in a parking garage after a long day at work. You are tired and thinking of what is waiting for you on your desk tomorrow and what you will have to eat when you get home. Suddenly, a man jumps out from behind a parked car and points a gun at you, asking for your money. You are terrified and give him your wallet. He runs away and you call the police. They arrive and you give a sketchy description of the guy who robbed you. He was Hispanic, was wearing a dark jacket and jeans. You can't remember how tall he was and couldn't see the color of his eyes. You didn't see any tattoos, just the gun, which was huge. The police call the information in and another squad car on the way to the scene sees a Hispanic man a couple of blocks away and when he sees the squad car, he starts running away. They chase him and catch him, they pat him down and discover a switchblade knife on him. He's wearing a dark jacket and jeans, but doesn't have a gun. They handcuff him and have you drive past him to see if you can identify him as your robber. You see a Hispanic man standing with two or three policeman around him, with his hands in handcuffs...

You assume that they have the right guy and so you identify him as your robber. He is charged and goes to trial. You are not informed that he did not have a gun on him, and the police were not able to find a gun where he might have disposed of it between your parking garage and where they picked him up. He is convicted of robbery based solely on your testimony.
This happens every day many different times a day in every city and every state and probably in every country -- wrongful convictions based on faulty identification. When you are the victim of a crime, most of the time you are in panic mode and you are not focusing on the assailant to find identifying details. Alarmingly, research has shown that more than forty percent of eyewitness accounts are wrong and it has been estimated that more than ten thousand (10,000) people a year are wrongfully convicted due to faulty eyewitness accounts. (Cicchini, p. 386)

The Supreme Court has not rendered a decision on eyewitness testimony since 1977 and even though it is notoriously unreliable, it is usually permissible in court proceedings. It has been suggested that expert testimony be given explaining to the jury how unreliable eyewitness…

Sources used in this document:
References

CICCHINI, M.D., & EASTON, J.G. (2010). CRIMINAL LAW: REFORMING THE LAW ON

SHOW-UP IDENTIFICATIONS. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 100(2), 381-413.

Retrieved from EBSCOhost on May 16, 2011.

Greene, E., & Loftus, E.F. (1984). Solving the Eyewitness Problem. Behavioral Sciences & the Law,
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now